A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Start a new discussion in the public forum
Post a new thread
If your post relates to a particular game please include the URL or ID#
of the game.
We get a lot of feature requests. If your feature request isn't already on our issue tracker,
then the best place to ask is the forum. This will help us gauge support for your ideas, before we add it to the todo list.
If you are posting a question please check the FAQ before posting.
If your message is long you may need to write a summary message, and add the full message as a reply.
We're playing our first game, and a player left. Can anything be done to speed up turns since he ain't logging in? When will he dissapear as a player, when all his provinces are conquered at the end of Autumn? How many votes for Draw/Cancel are requiered? Anything else I should know on the situation? Thanks in advance, guys!
I was attacked by France and Germany almost until the last years, when it was obvious by some point that the key to stop the russian solo was in the North... But never had the chance to get there in time... or did you think that I was going to turn my back to France in the Irish sea and in the Channel to save the rest of the board?
In 1908 France was attacking Edi and Lon while having a fleet in NAO and another in North Sea! By this moment Russia had already Turkey, Austria, Norway and Sweden and just entered Munich... Something clearly didn't work in the west.
East was trouble too, to be honest. I had a good relationship with Russia which was born out of necessity - Italy somehow was trying a lepanto while being in TRI. Austria took back TRI but then gave up fighting Italy. The lepanto kept pressing while he was also biting out of AH. I cannot begin to understand why AH with his last units was still trying to take my centres.
Meanwhile, Italy was hammering me hard and getting nowhere. He realized way too late that he could not continue this route and instead of helping me defend from Russia he went after France which allowed Russia to finish the conquest.
I thought Russia's play in this situation was perfect, and even with AH trying to stop his real threat and Italy changing strategies a little sooner I still think Russia would have come out with an excellent solo opportunity.
My reading of the game is fairly consistent with Lando's.
Starting out, my strategy was to move against AH and with regard to the rest of my neighbors, stay as defensive as possible and try to behave as nonthreatening as possible. I'd point to three factors as contributing to my solo.
First, AH got out of position when it moved its fleet to the SC of Bulgaria which allowed me to hold the southern SCs with little effort
Second, Italy's decision to move against France and concede the Balkans to me. I was surprised that Italy took so long to abandon his foray against France.
Third, prior to 1905 I was ordering all sorts of nonsense convoys with my army in Norway. I was hoping folks would be confused by what I was doing and maybe discount me as a threat. In 1905, I figured it was time to stop screwing around in the North. So, I moved an army to Silesia and cycled my Scandinavia forces with the goal of making them able to retreat without disbanding. I was hesitant to initiate hostilities with Germany but figured it was inevitable that he'd attack Scandinavia. Ultimately, I figured having my army in Silesia would slow him down enough to allow me to consolidate the Balkans and redirect some of my forces to the north. Fortunately, my instincts were right.
And I'd be remiss if I didn't thanks everyone for the points. This is by far my biggest win ever. Hopefully I can use these points to keep myself out of the low-point games.
In 1902, even though Italy was in Trieste, I took his fleets moving into Eastern Med, and Ionian from Adriatic as positive signals that he wanted to work together. I felt it made more sense to work with him than with a hostile and quickly expanding Russia. I saw Bulgaria as my next logical center in this approach but Russia and Italy both hit me simultaneously in fall of 1904. After that I struggled to survive but I guess I didn't do a good job.
@Lando: The reason I still went for your center (Bulgaria) even after Russia and Italy stabbed me was that I only had two units left and I thought my only chance to survive was to have my two units in centers that could support each other. So, I knew I needed my fleet in south coast Bulgaria and my army in Greece. Unfortunately, I never got Greece. The last bounce in greece in autumn 1908 was just bad luck, I think.
Congrats Oskar - well played. I played Germany. My hope was to work with either Eng and/or Russia and not so much with France. I thought Spr 01 kiel-hol; ber-keil, mun-burg signals I'm friendly towards Russia and have designs on Bel instead of denmark. I was somewhat surprised that Eng didn't walk into den instead of bouncing me in bel and I think this one move was cruicial to the whole game. With Eng and Germany only having 1 build each and Russia having 2, we were on the back foot from early on. Russia played his hand well, I thought at the time that France was slow to react to my olive branches, I tried to support him to Norway and support held him in other locations, and I thought his and England's tustles missed the bigger picture that Russia was growing huge. Italy taking French centres and leaving russia to get even bigger was puzzling too.
As always no criticisms are intended in my comments, I know how hard it can be to read others' minds. Enjoyed the game overall.
The login page on vdiplomacy says to enter your webdeplomacy usrnm and pswd, but then it says my account does not exist. Yet, I see names that I recognize on that forum.
http://vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=5642 Come on and join the chaos variant! Standard map, with 34 players, one per SC! Total randomness! 1-1-2-3-5-8-13!!!
There is a Tournament about to start on vdiplomacy.net called the whittle down tournament which needs players! The basic format is that the tourney starts on the site's largest map and players get eliminated from each round and the survivors pass to smaller and smaller maps. For more details, and to sign up, go to http://vdiplomacy.net/forum.php?viewthread=19614#19614
Serious Diplomacy Question- How nice should you be to your allies?
I am a relatively new player to Diplomacy, and often engage in (obviously) diplomacy with other players. However, I seem to find myself being to nice to my supposed allies. When dealing with allies, how nice is too nice? Thanks.
Hey, I'm having trouble getting the last few games together. I apologize to those whose games are being constantly postponed. I need two volunteers minimum to keep the tournament going. It's only 1 or 2 games folks, can anyone step up?
I've been playing here for about 2 years, but started playing at playdiplomacy about a month ago, and I have to say, they have a better interface, and a community who can actually hold an intelligent discussion. See inside for more reasoning. I hope to see some of you better players over there soon!
When you have allies like this in a game, what do you think is better diplomacy? winning the game, or upholding your good word as a player? example is this very game. could have won, wish you could see the chat. excellent diplomacy and communication here. gameID=79078
I'm tired of going through it. I'm tired of people acting like it. I'm tired of people who are full of it. Not that anyone on this site can tell it apart from something comedic.
Since I am now a Masters sub I cannot take my one month planned vacation. Sorry everyone who looked forward to it. But I HAVE decided to limit my trolling comments to one a week or less.
http://video.msnbc.msn.com/martin-bashir/46152472/#46152472 1. I thought you hated all Obama's spending...how much would a MOON COLONY cost? 2. Seriously...seriously, this is what you're resorting to now? 3. I like Star Trek, would love to hsee this happen, someday, but...no, I'm sorry--does ANYONE take this guy seriously? (Or a Moon Colony by 2020, for that matter, assuming the technology did exist, could it be built?)
What does everybody think of Dutch policies? Saw some talk show about it and even though it was in dutch (which I am) I still could understand "Yes minister" better...
Not sure if this goes here, or I'm supposed to email this to the mods, but this game needs to be unpaused: http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=73347
Anyone dare take me up on the challenge? I'm hoping to at least see The Czech, Lando, Eden, jmeyers, Barn3tt, Frank, Troodonte, Babak, Eden, Lando, rdrivera, Dunecat, uclabb, Eden, fulhamish, Troodonte, and Lando.
I think it would be a good idea to allow unrated games. After all, not all Chess games are ELO-rated for example. A simple way to do it would be to make a new variant, say "Classic-unrated". Then, adjust the GR program so that it excludes all games of that variant.