Oh, I LOVE Paradise Lost! :D
After Hamlet and maybe Macbeth, it's the single work of literature I reference the most in my writing (Shakespeare, Nietzsche, and Milton are my Dynamic Trio of Making Allusions in my English classes...and in life, really...Homer's the #4, but nowhere near as close as those three.)
But yeah, I'd love to have it--great poetry, and beyond that, it'd make me feel like Satan, cast out on that Island...and as Satan is AWESOME in that work (seriously, that may be the one time I'd root for HIM over any kind of God, he seems far more interesting and even more caring than God in the work; he actually cares when his men are beaten back in the War on Heaven, when God learns there's a possiblity Man might fall, he's jsut "Oh well...shit happens, I guess.")