Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 656 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
stratagos (3269 D(S))
14 Sep 10 UTC
Cheater alert!
I was flipping through the TV channels last night and I saw a soap opera. That blond chick? She's totally banging the pool boy while her husband is at work - cheating whore!
26 replies
Open
Winston (100 D)
15 Sep 10 UTC
Tunis= Win
new 12 hour game 3 open spots 3 hours to join!
4 replies
Open
Enoch (185 D)
15 Sep 10 UTC
An Awkward Situation
So Russia went CD and a newbie took the country over. I typed a pretty drawn out discussion of the current political climate and what my next moves were, along with some suggestions about what they could do. When I hit send, it apparently glitched massively, and when I hit the "Global" message tab (thinking it had sent normally), it posted there for everyone to see.
12 replies
Open
Winston (100 D)
15 Sep 10 UTC
New live gunboat!,
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=38203
15 bet 3 minutes to join!
4 replies
Open
acmac10 (120 D(B))
14 Sep 10 UTC
Taking Advantage of an NMR
What do you think of this? I am in plenty of day phase-36 hour phase and 5 minutes before I am logged and I changed my orders so I could snag an SC of someone who's NMR-ed. What are your opinions
20 replies
Open
omgwhathappened (0 D)
12 Sep 10 UTC
Stereotypical Accents Public Press
We had a great game going where people speak (type) in a caricature of a stereotypical accent from your country. Draw germany, talk with a german accent. Lots of fun, but had someone that needed to drop due to what seems to be a valid reason. so, we want to start one up again, and we need two more people!
17 replies
Open
obiwanobiwan (248 D)
15 Sep 10 UTC
The webDiplomacy TV Guide: Your Top 10 TV Episodes Ever!
Any show, any year, any country, any genre.

What episodes do you watch again and again, why...and, if you have them:
Links? :D
26 replies
Open
abgemacht (1076 D(G))
09 Sep 10 UTC
Grand Festive Diplomacy Tournament (GFDT) Sign-Up
This thread will be used for information on the GFDT. See inside for more info.
97 replies
Open
martinck1 (4464 D(S))
14 Sep 10 UTC
Draw / cancel with one player in CD
We have had an early CD and everyone is agreed to terminate the game. Can someone confirm the impact of a six way with the 7th country in CD on:
1. ghost Ranking points - is a 6 way draw or a 7 way draw
2. On D points - 6 way draw or a 7 way draw?
5 replies
Open
Bob Genghiskhan (1233 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
So, how many years?
How many years with absolutely no movement anywhere on the board would it take for you to vote draw in a game where you have 16 SCs, and the second place power has 7?
73 replies
Open
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
New Blackberry
And the inevitable questions... which browser, how to scroll, how to press the "Post new thread" button rather than logging onto the laptop to send this message.
18 replies
Open
FriedOkraBlues (100 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
Roma delenda est?
It has come to my attenshvn that ovr great Empire may be in the throes of a great decline.
9 replies
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
14 Sep 10 UTC
F.A.O. Moderator
gameID=38104

a gunboat for ava
5 replies
Open
woody (843 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
Players needed
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=37950

password: facebook
0 replies
Open
Rusty (179 D)
12 Sep 10 UTC
Rules Question?
A game I was in just ended, and there was no retreat phase after autumn. Carthage could have retreated a unit from Chersonesus to Sinope to keep things tied at 17s. Is this correct? Is the game over as soon as the fall turn ends and one player has eighteen centres? I would have thought Carthage would still get to make his retreat.

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=32531&msgCountryID=0
19 replies
Open
The Lord Duke (3898 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
BLA-Mos
Can someone tell me why BLA in World diplomacy can move to Arm & Tur but not Mos as all of them have a coast on BLA?
4 replies
Open
Silent Noon (205 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
Script problem messing up my orders
There's a problem with a script on the page that makes me unable to save and submit my orders ...
5 replies
Open
Invictus (240 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
Slow Crisis
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=37983

50 D, points-per-center, 24 hour phases, 10 days to join
5 replies
Open
areow (100 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
need 4 people
playing ancient mediterranian just created link is here:
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=38072
0 replies
Open
ava2790 (232 D(S))
13 Sep 10 UTC
HY ROLLERZ redux
gameID=37996

There is no password. The only requirement is 200 D and a willingness to never see them again.
5 replies
Open
Winston (100 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
Replacement for a live game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=38053&msgCountryID=3
Austria wants a replacement anyone?
And if we do find someone can the mods force cd Austria so the new guy can join?
0 replies
Open
Bob Genghiskhan (1233 D)
14 Sep 10 UTC
PASSWORD PROTECTED Live Gunboat
20 D, starts in 15. Respond in this thread and I'll send you the password
10 replies
Open
ZombieMage (100 D)
12 Sep 10 UTC
Are you ready for some...
FOOTBALL!!
26 replies
Open
jodabomb24 (100 D)
09 Sep 10 UTC
Correct me if I'm wrong, but...
This shouldn't have happened! In this game: gameID=32450, I'm Near-East. I ordered Syria to support move from Saudi Arabia to Iraq. Iran supported Iraq, so it failed. However, India, who occupies Iran and Iraq, ordered Arabian Sea to Saudi Arabia with support from Iraq. Shouldn't Iraq's support have been cut when I attacked it?
drano019 (1003 D)
09 Sep 10 UTC
If I understand your question, here's what happened:

Saudi Arabia -> Iraq with support from Syria
Arabian Sea -> Saudi Arabia supported by Iraq
Iran support hold Iraq

Is that right?

If so, the reason you lost Saudi Arabia is that you can't cut support from the province the support is being given to. In simpler terms, since Iraq was supporting an attack on Saudi Arabia, then Saudi Arabia can't cut the support. If you had attacked from Syria with support from Saudi Arabia, then the attacks would have bounced.

This rule is there so that 1 unit cannot defeat 2 units. Consider the implications if the rule wasn't there. Consider the classic board and assume that France is attacking Belgium from Burgundy and Picardy, and Germany has an army in Belgium. If Germany guesses correct, he would be able to hold out indefinitely by simply attacking the supporting army and cutting it's support, thus making the 1 German army essentially more powerful than the 2 French armies.

Here's the corresponding rule: If a unit ordered to support in a given space is attacked from a space DIFFERENT FROM the one into which it is giving support, or is dislodged by an attack from any space, including the one into which it is giving support, then its support is "cut".

Since you didn't dislodge Iraq, and Iraq was supporting into the "attacking" country (Saudi Arabia), the support stays valid.
Enoch (185 D)
09 Sep 10 UTC
As a point of reference, one German army would probably be more powerful than two French armies in real life. However, we are speaking in game terms, so drano is correct.
drano019 (1003 D)
09 Sep 10 UTC
Enoch -

I thought that exact same thing after I hit "reply"...
If A attacks B who supports C's attack on A, support is not cut unless A dislodges B.
yebellz (729 D(G))
09 Sep 10 UTC
jodabomb24, you are Completely Wrong and have been corrected by others.

Seriously, this is one of the most basic rules...

Noobs, before posting something on the forum claiming that the rules are incorrectly implemented, READ THE RULEBOOK.

It is highly unlikely that the website is messing up the rules. Bugs can happen, but they are quite rare. The website uses a very rigorous set of tests to assure that it's getting things right
http://webdiplomacy.net/datc.php
Thucydides (864 D(B))
09 Sep 10 UTC
WE NEVER SHOULD INVADED IRAQ!!!!


oh wait is that not what this thread is about?
orathaic (1009 D(B))
09 Sep 10 UTC
if anything, i think this thread rather clearly illustrates that the invasion of iraq should have been from Syria rather than from Saudi Arabia...
jodabomb24 (100 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
Yebellz, calm down. I disagree that this is one of the most basic rules. It is an extrapolation of a rule. You would actually have to go and read through the DATC tests to see this situation, something which I imagine few people have actually done. Also, I have never seen this question come up before, and despite your claim that I'm new at this, I'm not. You really should try to express your arguments in a clearer and more concise way.
yebellz (729 D(G))
13 Sep 10 UTC
@jodabomb:

This phrase is in the rulebook:
"Support is cut if the unit giving support is attacked from any province ***Except the one where support is being given.***"

As others have pointed out, without this rule one unit could defend against two attacks by correctly guessing which attack is cutting support.

It is a Very Basic rule. Here is the rulebook
http://www.wizards.com/avalonhill/rules/diplomacy_rulebook.pdf
I would advise that you read it

It is on page 12, under the section "Cutting Support", in the phrase that basically Defines how support can be cut.

It's also on page 23 (see item 13), under the cheat-sheet section "22 Rules to Help You Resolve Orders"

Again, I would strongly advise that you read the rulebook.

You may have never seen this question come up because it is a pretty basic issue. The rulebook is fairly thorough and basically the only major things that only come up in the DATC test cases are bizarre convoy examples that question the philosophy of how convoy paradoxes should be resolved.
Draugnar (0 DX)
13 Sep 10 UTC
This question comes up a couple of times a month and it is clearly stated in the rulebook. The DATC review is not required at all, just a read through with attention to detail of the rulebook will give you this info, JB.
baumhaeuer (245 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
drano is correct

@Thucy: lol
spyman (424 D(G))
13 Sep 10 UTC
I can understand the confusion with this rule. Yes it is the rules but it also true that it is not something will be always immediately understood. So give the newbue a break. It is okay to ask questions.
orathaic (1009 D(B))
13 Sep 10 UTC
Hmm, i think this should be one of the example moves.

i mean look at the last example here... i think it should be added... though this and forward retreats would make the intro a little bit longer... maybe just a link to the exceptions and advanced rules.


13 replies
comrade general (100 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
gunboat
why do people like gunboat games i mean i have never played one but i dont think i want to on account of they seem pretty boring
2 replies
Open
DJEcc24 (246 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
NFL vs Barclays Premier Leage
no no this isn't a football against futbol debate. rather a debate on which has the better system on team skill equality. Meaning: teams that do crappy one year being able to get better and do well. So in essence relegation against first draft choice.
39 replies
Open
Sicarius (673 D)
13 Sep 10 UTC
winning player dropped out!
take over the leading player in world diplomacy!
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=35713

and save the game for all the other players
2 replies
Open
LJ TYLER DURDEN (334 D)
10 Sep 10 UTC
What time zones are players in?
I seem to have a really hard time finding live games, and during the World Cup I was never on at the same time as anyone else. Is it that I just somehow seem to miss prime hours, or is my timezone (GMT -8) an unpopular one on this site?
28 replies
Open
Geofram (130 D(B))
24 Aug 10 UTC
Need a replacement in public press.
We need to replace Russia in this game:
gameID=34948
Please respond if you have any questions or want to. The game has turned out well, being able to read the letters alone are cause enough to join.
64 replies
Open
stratagos (3269 D(S))
09 Sep 10 UTC
So
so I've decided to randomly woo my wife again - no, I didn't screw up, but we're both going to be traveling a great deal over the next two months...
31 replies
Open
Page 656 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top