Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 313 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
lobstermagnet (145 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Disbanding?
This is my first game (and my first build phase) of online diplomacy. How do I disband an army to build something else?
6 replies
Open
mapleleaf (0 DX)
07 Jul 09 UTC
New game
All are welcome(except the riff raff)
15 replies
Open
jbalcorn (429 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Moderator, Please unpause
New Deal 2
Game # 11544

Password protected gunboat game. Austria wanted a pause to go away for the holiday weekend. It's Wednesday.
2 replies
Open
Danaman (1666 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Paused games
Is there anyway to force a player to unpause a game? I am in a game where a player paused the game over 2 weeks go as soon as it went bad for his country. HNone of his other games are paused just the one.
1 reply
Open
idealist (680 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
question about retreat
hypothetical situation:
If an army in st.pete bounced an army in sevastpol in moscow, and an army in warsaw was dislodged, can this disloged army retreat to moscow?
4 replies
Open
raid1280 (190 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
24 Hour Turns - The Quick Dagger - Need Players
Need 6 players for a 24 hour turn game. 20 pt bid.
0 replies
Open
jbalcorn (429 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
New Deal 2 - paused
New Deal 2 paused so that Austria could go to Disneyland for the weekend. Apparently, he's having a really good time.
5 replies
Open
djbent (2572 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
league bets
anyone want to bet virtual money on who will advance or be demoted in the leagues. it's too early to tell definitively, but it would be fun, as long as it doesn't devolve into commenting on ongoing games or some other metagaming.
Captain Dave (113 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
I'll happily wager a tenner that I am NOT going anywhere (except perhaps relegation to a new E League if it gets created, although maybe my flukey draw in Game One will prevent that)!
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Don't worry, you can't get demoted into non existent leagues.

Can I put a virtual tenner on my sitting slap bang in 4th (the only non-moving spot) in League A, and another tenner on destp's promotion to the Premier League, or is betting on your own games illegal?
Captain Dave (113 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
TGM, you set the rules! Although if 'suspicious betting patterns' arise, then you might get a call from the bookmakers!
djbent (2572 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
i think betting on your own game is illegal. conflict of interest and all that.

i was considering putting down ten on destp's promotion however. and another ten on dangermouse being relegated to league A from the premiere league

(also ghost you have a typo in the description, you call league A league 1 at one point)
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Where?
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Found
Chrispminis (916 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
What are the promotion/demotion schemes for each league again?

The bet on dangermouse seems like a pretty sure thing, short of like a solo or two-way draw in his last game.

I'll put 10 down on Xapi hanging on with that solo to win his league, B2.

I'll put another 10 down on Bugger to win C1.

And yet another on Laoban to win C2, which is quite impressive considering he's up against Babak and woooo, and has managed to do phenomenally in his first two games.

That's all the virtual money I have at the moment, though I'd also point out Friendly Sword in C3, gjdip in D1 (DbJ not far behind), bartdogg's success in D2, Troodonte in D3, LanGaidin and lulzworth in D4.

As much as I'd like to bet on myself in B1 (I'm not doing so bad!), my money would be on Ivo.
djbent (2572 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
premiere demotes three to league A
league A promotes three to premiere, demotes 3 to B1 and B2
B1 and B2 each send the top player to A, as well as the better of the two runner up players; 3 each are demoted from B1 and B2 to C level
C1, 2, and 3 each promote the top two players; 3 players are demoted from each one to D level
D1, 2, 3, and 4 promote top two players from each, plus the top 3-ranked player; presumably no one is demoted from D, unless they are booted from the tournament for CD or something.
djbent (2572 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
i bet we see sean accompany dangermouse on the slide down, and see abgemacht and gryncat demoted from league A. hard call on B1, but i think you might make the grade Chrisp, a lot depends on that last game. Xapi definitely takes B2 - but who else will advance with him? and who will be demoted? el perro artero looks like will go down, thewonderllama too, perhaps, and i think centurian or stratagos will advance.

interesting question - if destp gets demoted from B1, but holds his own or gets promoted in league A, what happens ghostmaker?
Chrispminis (916 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Yeah, it's interesting that destp is doing better in League A than League B1. =P

Unless he solo's in the third game of B1.
djbent (2572 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
true. which doesn't seem beyond possibility.
Xapi (194 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Please, don't give me too much credit, I'm perfectly capable of screwing things up and getting relegated to second, or even further down.

I do hope 12 points in a second put me in A league next season.
Draugnar (0 DX)
08 Jul 09 UTC
All of you betting on league D1 need to realize that three of the four games are still running and anything can happen. Game 1 was a true cockup with two dropouts (one was replaced, the draw took care of the second) and Captain Dave lucking into a 1SC even share of the draw. gjdip was nice and did the draw when his primary competitor for a solo dropped. Look for different results in 2, 3, and 4...
Draugnar (0 DX)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Oh, and look at D1 - 2, 3, & 4 for one common name consistently in the top three (and leading game 4).
djbent (2572 D(S))
08 Jul 09 UTC
@draugnar - of course we don't know how it will shake out. if we waited until all four games were played, betting wouldn't be much fun, now would it? =P
djbent (2572 D(S))
08 Jul 09 UTC
i think we'll see farmerboy and maniac at the bottom of D1, dingle, captain and draugnar scrapping for the middle range, and i bet ag takes the league, with gjdip right behind.
Draugnar (0 DX)
08 Jul 09 UTC
I'm just saying you shouldn't assume anything at all from game 1 cause it was farked big time with the drop outs. Had we never had a drop out, it would probably have been a four way draw as there was a two vs. two battle going on when the first NMR and drop occured, leaving me gutted because Turkey didn't bounce in MAO when he NMR'd.
Farmerboy (280 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Way to pile on my skill djbent. But if I $100 to bet that is what I would say as well!
djbent (2572 D(S))
08 Jul 09 UTC
well, not so much a reflection of my faith in your abilities, but rather the situation you picked up. you could pull off something big in game 4! after all, Jacob didn't christen you "FarmerMAN" for nothing...
Centurian (3257 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
I don't think I will be coming out of B. I've really botched things. First I give Xapi a solo and now I've decided to not take Bulgaria in my opening moves as Turkey. There would have to be some serious mistakes on their part for me to get promoted. Xapi will probably get by on the one solo.
jbalcorn (429 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
HEre's ten on Laoban being promoted from C2. And another ten on bartdogg being promoted from D2. Can I put another ten on a daily double for both of them and get better odds?
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
The better of destp's positions stays, so if he is promoted from league A, he will be in the Premier League.
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC

premiere demotes three to league A
league A promotes three to premiere, demotes 3 to B1 and B2
B1 and B2 each send the top player to A, as well as the better of the two runner up players; 3 each are demoted from B1 and B2 to C level
C1, 2, and 3 each promote the top two players; 3 players are demoted from each one to D level
D1, 2, 3, and 4 promote top two players from each, plus the top 3-ranked player; presumably no one is demoted from D, unless they are booted from the tournament for CD or something.

Is only true if there are no drop outs... which there have already been. If destp is first or second in B-level, and stays up in A level then all firsts and seconds will get promoted, for instance.
Alderian (2425 D(S))
08 Jul 09 UTC
I know we've had two drop outs just in D3 which probably isn't that unexpected for the bottom rung. How many drop outs have there been in the higher level leagues?

So if an extra person from B gets promoted to A, how do you fill the void in B? An extra person from C gets promoted to B and an extra person from D gets promoted to C? Or just one less person from B drop to C? Or just a judgment call on your part at the end of the season based on what makes sense?
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Premier League: None
League A: None mid season, one player pulled out last minute
Leagues B1/B2: None

These are the four leagues that are totally comprised of players who have played a whole season.
Don't you think placing side bets, stating who you think is doing well, could affect the game? Wouldn't this qualify as not talking about ongoing games? While specific game play is not discussed, the 'game' for the leagues is more than just the single game, but the sum of the four.
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Perhaps, not that I think people will be taking notice of it... you might be right though...
djbent (2572 D(S))
08 Jul 09 UTC
any league player who is remotely concerned about their position is already coming to some conclusions (maybe similar, maybe different than expressed in this thread) and weighing them in account in his or her actions. since it's not about one single game, but the sum of all four (or three) and it's about speculation on who will do well overall, not who is going to win a specific game, i don't think this is the same. nonetheless, TGM calls the shots, and if he says it's not cool, we can let this thread die. alternatively, if a number of other players feel like Dingle, speak up and we can let it die as well in that case.
Xapi (194 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
I feel like a Dingle.

Not really, I just find the phrase funny.
In my own case, I can say I didn't really think about gjdip as a threat to win, because he was a replacement player. I hadn't yet formed any emotions for or against him, because I had no experiences shared with him, because he replaced a player (whom I DID have strong feelings about). Now, based on this post, I realize that even though he is a replacement player, that because the player he replaced was doing pretty good, I DO need to be concerned about him.
Granted, it was an oversight on my part, but I guarantee that not everyone has analyzed the 4 games as a group as concisely as some people will summarize above and below in order to make virtual bets.
Centurian (3257 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Does a replacement player take over the won points of the player he replaced? Thats seems a little strange to me.
Xapi (194 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
I think not, but in that case, he did pick up his CD positions.
gjdip (1065 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
My 15 minutes of fame.
Akroma (967 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
while you are at it, I have a hot tip for the GFDT
There were no completed games at the time. Though he did pick up some nice positions.
gjdip (1065 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
@DJ: I picked up a good position in game 1. Game 2 was rubbish.
Draugnar (0 DX)
08 Jul 09 UTC
And three and four are all gjdip, no adopted positions in them. I'm saying nothing else or it might affect the diplomacy in game.
Draugnar (0 DX)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Except this - rmember game 1 and you deciding not to support me like your predecessor had done, gjdip. <grin>


39 replies
lanyards (100 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
New Forum Suggestion
Hey, I am new here. I don't know what forum this is, but phpBB forums are way better. I suggest whoever owns this site to look into switching over. http://www.phpbb.com/
49 replies
Open
obiwanobiwan (248 D)
02 Jul 09 UTC
"Greatest" Philosopher (2 Categories, See Below)
It's a silly thing to "name" one the greatest, there are at least 10 titans of thouht who could easily all claim the title of "Geatest Philosopher" but anywhoo...... it's fun. :D

So, 2 categories, Mental (ex. Kant, Descartes, Kierkegaard) and Political (Locke, Hobbes, Marx) and off we go.......
154 replies
Open
lilone223 (100 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
join ww33
jon game u have about 6 minutes to join
0 replies
Open
jiaflu (443 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Need 2 for a game.
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=12005

101 buy in.
4 replies
Open
lilone223 (100 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
join doomed world
join my game doomed world so i can get it go join quick game starts in 12 hours
0 replies
Open
DingleberryJones (4469 D(B))
06 Jul 09 UTC
I'm stuck on a 3 hour conference. I don't have to speak. its really boring.
Now entertain me!
114 replies
Open
KaiserAl32 (135 D)
08 Jul 09 UTC
Fast Game
I started a fast game with a 25 point pot. It's called Troubadour. This is specially designed for all those people that want to bet 25 points on a fast game, but require notification via forum.
0 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
LIVE GAME just 59 minutes to join!!!
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=12033
Kozaki Odin-Nol-Odin
5D's
7 spots open
0 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
LIVE GAME who wants in?
Wondering how many people would be interested
15 minute turns tommorow morn 9 PST 11 EST
7 points to join
12 replies
Open
ruffmike (100 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
join newbie-9 .....
join newbie-9 ..... bet only 10 to play....
0 replies
Open
airborne (154 D)
06 Jul 09 UTC
world leaders fast game tomarrow?
http://www.worldleadersthegame.com/fast_games/fast.php
Anyone interested?
5 replies
Open
Ursa (1617 D)
04 Jul 09 UTC
Dutch Diplomacy draadje
Zijn hier nog meer Nederlanders?
59 replies
Open
ag7433 (927 D(S))
07 Jul 09 UTC
Suggestion
It would be handy if the mods had a central email we could mail instead of posting on the forum. Does this exist?
25 replies
Open
Xapi (194 D)
06 Jul 09 UTC
Moderation actions
Question/proposal inside.
22 replies
Open
bh (898 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
Pluraserver
When I load a page on phpDiplomacy, my browser starts making hundreds of requests to pluraserver.com containing an affiliate id. This is bothersome. Anyone else experiencing this behavior?
1 reply
Open
airborne (154 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
High Bet Game?
a 50-75 point ante game is anyone interested?
0 replies
Open
Chalks (488 D)
06 Jul 09 UTC
WTA 101 buy in
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=12005
DO IT. :D
2 replies
Open
Lummis (100 D)
03 Jul 09 UTC
" The Thirteen Neighbours ", Study of 13 Adjacent Alliances.
" The Thirteen Neighbours ", A Study of the 13 Adjacent Country Alliances
* (A/G) Anschluss, the Austrian-German Alliance
* (R/T) The Juggernaut, the Russian-Turkish Alliance
... . * = -Known tactics- ; ...
38 replies
Open
Lummis (100 D)
03 Jul 09 UTC
The Viking Hammer , (E/G) Alliance.
* ' The Viking Hammer ' * ... (VH) - (The V-H)
or, the English-German Alliance (E/G), an anti-French Gambit.
- Introduction: I was reading strategy articles and found t...
...
15 replies
Open
yeunghauyip (1654 D)
06 Jul 09 UTC
How does the system decide who gets the retreat if two countries both retreats to that place?
May I ask if both countries are trying to the same place, which is the only choice for both countries, then how does the system decide who gets the retreat?
25 replies
Open
qoou (434 D)
07 Jul 09 UTC
There was a recent post about a certain cool strategy that got bumped off the bottom
If I remember correctly, someone had made a post about something like the following (using a Germany being attacked by Russia as an example):
9 replies
Open
bishopofRome (0 DX)
06 Jul 09 UTC
Moderator Email?
anyone know it?
3 replies
Open
Page 313 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top