Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 24 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Wolfyboy (100 D)
07 May 07 UTC
Changing some1 else's order?
This is the situation:
An attack is launched from an enemy in Sweden into My Denmark.
My Denmark is supporting My fleet at Hel which is moving into the enemy at Kiel.

Considering no other armies are involved, the outcome would be Denmark support move get canceled and will be changed to "hold", because the attack move from sweden. After that, the attack on Kiel will end in a tie.

But..... Let's say we add another army, mine, in Norway. This army then attacks Sweden. What happens?
1) Since Sweden can't take over Denmark, so it stays in Sweden. Then, because being attacked by Norway it changes it's move to "hold", and tie with norway. After that, The support from Denmark is renewed, and Hel win against Kiel.
2) Sweden stays in Sweden and holds against Norway, but still cancels Denmark support move.

Which is correct? 1 or 2?

BTW, sorry for not linking to the actual game, that is because it's a theoretical question, Since this scenario is not explained in the "help"...

Thanks a lot for helping me, Wolfyboy
4 replies
Open
Ignoramus (100 D)
07 May 07 UTC
Annoying bug.
When I ordered my fleet in London to the English Channel and my army in Wales to London, they both bounced as apparently they attacked each other. There was nothing blocking the English Channel and no fleet bordering it apart from my own, and I've checked my orders and nothing should have prevented the London fleet from moving.

Any thoughts?
3 replies
Open
braddles31 (100 D)
07 May 07 UTC
Russia
Are these ok moves to open in sprin 01 if you are allied wih austria and germany, at war with england and not sure re turkey?
the following moves would be:
g.o.b-swe
stp-nor
ukr-rum
sev s ukr-rum
(assuming Austria supported from serbia, and they along with G didnt attack)?
2 replies
Open
Zxylon (0 DX)
05 May 07 UTC
Question
Why is Icleand on the Diplomacy Board
9 replies
Open
braddles31 (100 D)
07 May 07 UTC
new game
Pre war open to all
0 replies
Open
The Mahatma (1195 D)
06 May 07 UTC
$helpunitid Error
A $helpunitid error is being triggered when I try to enter "The Faster Game". Our phase is over in about 2 hours, so I hope the phase doesn't process without me being able to submit moves!
2 replies
Open
Wolfyboy (100 D)
06 May 07 UTC
Taking over Territories
I moved from Con to Bulgaria in my 1st turn (I'm the Turks). Do I now need to stay with this army in Bulgaria in order to conquer it? Becase it doesn't appear like I control it yet...

I hope I made myself clear, english is my 2nd language...

Wolfyboy
7 replies
Open
Worldbeing (1063 D)
06 May 07 UTC
Potential bug
In the game <Manipulation> (id=997), I'm playing Germany, and held Denmark.
In Spring 1902, I attempted to move my F Kiel into Denmark, but was told it was stalemated. However, the English fleet in the North Sea moved in.
Either:
-why did he get in when the territory was stalemated? or
-(if he had support from Sweden) why was I told it was stalemated, when I should have been told I was defeated?
2 replies
Open
isbian (106 D)
06 May 07 UTC
North and South Coast
When you're moving into a country that has North and South coasts, why can't you pick which coast you want to move into? This would open up a lot of new strategies and possibilities, and would mean less people being in awkward situations when their fleet ends up on a different coast.
1 reply
Open
isbian (106 D)
06 May 07 UTC
New Game
The game UT 1901 was created. Another one of my games whose name has something to do with a computer game. Please join.
0 replies
Open
Brutus (114 D)
06 May 07 UTC
Rating Hierarchy
What is the ladder? Political Puppet, Casual Player,... Pro?
5 replies
Open
hannibalking (100 D)
06 May 07 UTC
World
Is there any game of diplomacy that involves the world beyond Europe?
5 replies
Open
new game
everyone is welcome to become part of a new game i created. it's entitled "join! no password!" i am new to php but not new to diplomacy in general, and i'd encourage all levels of players to join.
0 replies
Open
Alfa (1308 D)
26 Apr 07 UTC
What country are you from?
How global is the community on phpDiplomacy?

United States of America here.
Page 3 of 3
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
JuanCorrales (276 D)
02 May 07 UTC
Spain!!
Atimati (100 D)
02 May 07 UTC
from Budapest, Hungary
7 Hungarians played here the game called Magyar which is the Hungarian word for Hungarian :)
irisshadows (100 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Houston, Texas, USA

...and a few in my class just joined also.
Worldbeing (1063 D)
03 May 07 UTC
The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Harking back to the Taiwan thing, how can you connect "Taiwan, China..." and "Hitler, Nazi..."??
The Nazis=fascist
Communism=well, not fascist
China=neither!
(yes, china may claim to be communist but it's not, since in a communist society there would be both no restrictions on personal liberties and no need for them) (Yes, I'm a communist.) (Keep the Red Flag flying!)
Worldbeing (1063 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Sorry for the double post, but I just noticed someone from Galway!
One of my favourite cities, after York and Edinburgh.
Tucobenedicto (100 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Manhattan over here.

Also:
"in a communist society there would be both no restrictions on personal liberties and no need for them"

Sorry but that's a ludicrous statement.
Worldbeing (1063 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Why?
What do you know about communism except the propaganda of your own government?
In a communist society where everyone is equal, everyone has unrestricted opportunities, and there is no need or desire to limit these.
Barbosah (351 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Seems like I'm the only one from a "Third World" country. Brazil here. No, not Rio!
nobody (1064 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Germany, Berlin
Chrispminis (916 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Re : Taiwan, China and Hitler, Nazi. The relation is that they are both controversial topics, and most people have relatively strong opinions about the issues. They are quite sensitive, especially Taiwan, since it's not as one-sided as a Hitler discussion is. Still, both have the power to instigate anger and emotion.

Re : Communism
Tuco, the mere fact that you come from Manhattan makes me think you might be a tad biased. I personally do not endorse Communism, but I am ethnic Chinese. Born and raised in Toronto, my parents had conflicting views on communism, a big part because my Dad comes from a poor family, whereas my Mom came from a rich landowning family, which is a big no-no during a communist revolution.

The idea behind communism does have the sense of "in a communist society there would be both no restrictions on personal liberties and no need for them". Communism is not evil, it has good intentions, it more an argument of it's feasibility. Firstly, you would need incredible control, with no outside non-communist states, because that would ruin the social stability. As well, it depends on human nature being non-exploitative, which may not always be the case, depending on what you believe.

Just because one cannot imagine that a communist state could be a good thing, does not mean it can't be. Obviously I, personally, would not do well in a communist state, because I have been raised to strive ambitiously, and to aim for riches. :D

But enough of this, like Taiwan, communism is also a touchy subject.
undef (1390 D)
03 May 07 UTC
I'm from Romania - Bucharest (hi opripom :)
Tucobenedicto (100 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Oh hey, don't get me wrong I'm COMPLETELY biased. I'm an upper middle-class, New York City, Jew!

However, I know enough about communism to formulate my own opinion, which is that it's an inherently flawed ideology. I just feel it's wrong for Worldbeing to ignore every atrocity (Berlin Wall, Khmer Rouge, Gulag system, etc.) committed under communist rule.

That being said, yes, it's time to move on.
Photon (100 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Pittsburgh Pennsylvania USA I got about 10 friends also from here.
Somebody Else (383 D)
03 May 07 UTC
re. Taiwan/China

The government of China is in Taiwan. It's just those pesky Maoist rebels who hold the mainland.
or was it
The government of China is on the mainland. It's just those pesky nationalist rebels who hold Taiwan.

I forget...

Incidentally, you know there's a youth group in Taiwan that has Hitler as one of their role models...
raidedguy (342 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Lake Oswego, Oregon (USA!)
For those of you who know the slang names, but not where we are, think Portland, OR.
Sicarius (673 D)
03 May 07 UTC
USA, toledo ohio, I'm an ethinic American Indian
Ufor the Odd (100 D)
04 May 07 UTC
Minneapolis, Minnesota. My dad's side of the family is Dutch.
Ufor the Odd (100 D)
04 May 07 UTC
US, that is
krokodil (823 D)
04 May 07 UTC
QUOTE: Sorry for the double post, but I just noticed someone from Galway!
One of my favourite cities, after York and Edinburgh. UNQUOTE:

Yeah, its a pretty cool city. Incidentally, I plan to go to College in Edingurgh. I relly loved the city when I was there.
LucusVonLucus (1551 D)
05 May 07 UTC
Orlando, Florida U.S.A.
Should someone start a Communism thread?
darkscull (1501 D)
05 May 07 UTC
i'm from england, but currently in wales (which is not very well represented on the diplomacy map)...

I think people need to remember that communist ideology often differs from the actions of communist states.

most 'communist' countries just pay lipservice to the ideology. I think cuba is the only one that actually gets close.


anyway, there is quite a diverse population on here, i didn't expect that.


81 replies
Arthas (1769 D)
05 May 07 UTC
Country Colors
For the official version of Diplomacy, England; France; Germany; Italy; Austria; Russia; and Turkey are dark blue, light blue, black, green, red, white and yellow respectively. Is phpDiplomacy going to use those "official" colors or are we going to stick with the colors we have right now?
9 replies
Open
figlesquidge (2131 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Longest Game
I'm just wondering what peoples longest ever games are, because one of my games is at the end of 1936! The main reason for this is that twice we have reached stalemate lines, and then had them broken because of holidays and the like. If I remember correctly, the game was started back in February, which gives an idea of it's age! Links:
"Awesomeness Game" (http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gid=333)
11 replies
Open
eonwe (411 D)
04 May 07 UTC
"glaurungs wrath" frozen
Message: phase end "due now". I know this error happens a lot, but if it calls for any manual intervention i'd appreciate if anyone could fix on it.
1 reply
Open
Sun_Tzu (2116 D)
28 Apr 07 UTC
Errors in Adjudication
I had an error in adjudication, one unit supporting another unit into a SC. Defending unit attacked the supporting unit which caused the support to fail, WRONG. This is critical and basic mistake! Is there any way to correct it?
36 replies
Open
Rait (10151 D(S))
05 May 07 UTC
The game 'The Fast Game' is hanging
The game id is 810
0 replies
Open
nuclearshimmer (153 D)
04 May 07 UTC
Just what the name says...
PLAY QUICKLY has opened and is ready for anyone that wants a fast game.
0 replies
Open
Wolfyboy (100 D)
04 May 07 UTC
New to diplomacy
What do (nc) and (ns) mean?
2 replies
Open
krokodil (823 D)
03 May 07 UTC
Next phase 'due now'
Ive noticed that when Time runs out for a phase, and some people dont have their orders in, it just says the the next phase is 'due now' and then waits until the late players put in their orders.
Has anyone else noticed this? Or is it an Isolated incident.

Not a big problem just wondering is this normal.
2 replies
Open
Zxylon (0 DX)
03 May 07 UTC
Game Question???
When a stalemate occurs on the game board it appears as a red X on the region the stalemate occured. But you can see the red X for Austria because it blends right in. If you have a "to do" list on fixing the minor errors on this amazing website. I would appriciate it if you could change the X to Black or White. Thanks
2 replies
Open
Worldbeing (1063 D)
03 May 07 UTC
I return!
As promised, so I deliver!
The fabulous, amazing, Worldbeing has returned....
But, yeah, what's been happening?
1 reply
Open
aoe3rules (949 D)
02 May 07 UTC
A random idea
Player search system
A box where you type letters and it gives you a list of players whose usernames contain the characters you searched for. The list can be sorted alphabetically, by player rank, time joined, etc. When you click on a player's name, you go to the information page (the one we have already, with rank, timezone, etc.). That page should have a link to send that person an out-of-game message, which appears on their forum page as a notification message.


i had a lot more of these, and i'll post them if i remember any.
5 replies
Open
Arthas (1769 D)
29 Apr 07 UTC
Gamelistings.php is a Blank Page
Somebody please fix this problem ASAP!
21 replies
Open
Brutus (114 D)
02 May 07 UTC
The psychology of Diplomacy players
Does anyone know of any studies done by psychologists of Dip players?

There's all kinds here, but is there a "profile"?

Any amateur diagnoses?
9 replies
Open
Ralyndi (1106 D)
02 May 07 UTC
Good bye.
I'm afraid I'm going to have to stop coming onto this site. Don't get me wrong, I love diplomacy, but lately I've been neglecting my school work, and I'm under a lot of stress right now. There are more important things that this site at the moment. I may be back in the summer, though. =) I'll try my best to see my current games through, but that's it. I'm sorry to all my allies I've let down by missing a few turns here and there, and for the turns I will miss in the future.
0 replies
Open
pappy97 (135 D)
01 May 07 UTC
Why are people rude in phpdiplomacy?
Why are people so rude in phpdiplomacy? Not as a whole, but a few characters:

"03:42 PM okay, will you shut up now?"

Come on now. This is ridiculous for ANY diplomacy, internet or F2F.
46 replies
Open
pappy97 (135 D)
02 May 07 UTC
Why is the game "de_dust" not advancing to next phase?
All powers have entered orders but the game has not advanced to the next phase. Why is that? Thanks.
6 replies
Open
Page 24 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top