^Hey, stop replying to the topic there, Invictus! ;)
"Essentially all he's saying is that there's virtue in being willing to die for one's beliefs. That's far from saying we should be more like ISIS, as our resident quasi-illiterate English major points out in the opening post."
And now I shall strike down upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger all the wrath a freelancing English major can summon! :p
But you know...
When MLK gave his famous "Mountaintop" speech, he's making an allusion to Moses--and he made it for a reason, as the African-American community had been drawing (understandable) parallels to themselves and the Israelites of the Exodus story vs. Pharaoh and Egyptian slavers for decades. ("Go Down Moses," anyone? ...The African-American spiritual, not the Faulkner collection.)
And when Reagan gave HIS "City on a Light" analogy, he was clearly referencing the New Testament, and Jesus' Sermon on the Mount, to be specific.
So, generally, when you make analogy or comparison...you have more of an underlying REASON than "Oh, well, these things are kinda sorta alike."
MLK saw--to use the term more colloquially than spiritually--a connection between what he saw as the "soul" of oppressed Israelites and the soul of African-Americans, that there was a deeper connection there than "both were slaves."
Because (spoiler alert) A LOT of people have been slaves over the course of history.
Just like A LOT of people have been "willing to die for one's beliefs."
So of ALL the people, nations, and groups Ben Carson could've used for an analogy, he chose...ISIS.
Furthermore, let's go for the English major extra point here and take Carson's actual text--"They got the wrong philosophy, but they're willing to die for what they believe."
That doesn't sound like "Well, sure, George Wallace may have had 'the wrong philosophy' when he said 'Segregation now, segregation forever!' but hey...he REALLY believed what he believed strongly!" to anyone else?
Just saying...when you use a reference...you use it for a REASON...and of all the references he could've picked...he chose ISIS.