Bored to death of rereading again. Made it to the end of p74. Honestly, All three of guak, y2k, and Vash look like they could be scum to me. And guak+Vash especially have a LOT more posts in the latter half of the game. But the continuation of each summary below:

y2k:

P45 Asks for reiteration of arguments about phil being scum. Points out Squigs' reaction to ghug's joke regarding Maniac. Calls ghug+Squigs's voting pattern meant to stir up discussion. Disagrees with reasons for finding phil scummy.
P46 Says Yassem is tunneling.
P47 Says he's not sold on Squigs, but finds Squigs more scummy than SG. Votes Squigs. Wants to "get a counter-wagon going" Challenges guak telling meme to change votes.
P48 Votes meme right after I do. Then says he is torn.
P49 Asks for a vote count.
P51 Votes SG for "trying to survive at all cost." "I feel comfortable with this."
P58 Checks in. Says we can't rely on either the WW or the vig to kill Chaqa and votes Chaqa. Concludes that lynching Chaqa now is better.
P63 Promises rereading a few players. Says he looks scummy. Hopes he can guide the town to the last two scum. Basically promises to be more vocal.
P64 Says he'll move his vote if Yoyo agrees too.
P66 Says the reason he switched was to go along with the town majority.
P68 Says he's lost. Feels certain phil is not scum. Says only way phil is mafia is if Vash is too, and says it's unlikely. Says phil can't be mafia more.
P70 Says he has strong feelings that both ghug and guak are innocent and that the two remaining scum are letting it happen. Votes Yoyo. Says a Yoyo+yassem team would make a lot of sense, pitting the louder townies against each other.
P72 Says he's surprised more people aren't calling for his head. Tells people to let him know if he can clarify anything.
P73 Says he doesn't like any of the people with 2 votes but says he couldget behind voting DO and does so.


guak:

P46 Tells me meme will flip scum, and when he does he'll be right. Says meme failed to answer anything against him satisfactorally.
P47 Says he is accusing meme not on his lurking, but based on ND's defense of him combined with his coaching the WW. Tells y2k not to vote Squigs since y2k claims he doesn't think Squigs is scum.
P48 Insults y2k's activity level. Says voting for a wagon because it is the lesser of two evils is scummy. Pushes SG about his switch in views on Squigs.
P49 Accepts meme pointing out scummy behavior from Vash. Calls Vash out on his "all 3 are town charade"
P50 Says Vash is setting himself up for an "I told you so" situation and the savior of the future.
P52 Calls meme out on a contradiction regarding WW talk.
P53 talks about WW.
P54 Explains that fake RB claims are common, tells Yassem "info" kills are worthless. Defends Squigs. Weighs in regarding ghug's attackign Squigs and squigs' townread of ghug.
P56 Says tv is right, and voting Chaqa is a waste. Says ghug and I should agree with him about killing someone OTHER than Chaqa.
P57 Calls ghug an idiot. Calls the whole town idiots for voting for Chaqa. Tells people to ignore Chaqa.
P58 Says mafia are acting crazy if they're giving up Vash and Chaqa for a WW reveal. Also says this mafia is crazy enough to do so.
p59 Says there's no risk to keeping Chaqa alive. Points out Chaqa is hardly a threat, nor his potential advice.
P60 Continues ranting about not killing Chaqa. Votes ghug based on town ghug not advocating for killing Chaqa. That's his whole argument. Says ghug is trying to screw us over.
P61 Says Chaqa is not a threat more.
P62 Says DO may be right about mafia being quiet, but creates suspect list of: Squigs, meme, ghug, and y2k.
P63 Says Chaqa is already out of the way. Says ghug is so obviously scum we all need to kill him.
P65 Says it was optimal strategy but not optimal target. Calls out Yoyo for his switch. (What about y2k??)
P66 Thinks 2/3 of the mafia voted for Squigs at end of day. Thinks y2k might be WW. Forgot mrh was still around. Night ends. Votes Vash.
P67 Says Town Vash shouldn't have claimed VT. Says Vash is either mafia or WW. Calls Vash's vote OMGUS. Says Chaqa could only offer Vash as the vig even though Vash is scum. Says that because it makes sense Chaqa would be fooled into thinking Vash is vig, he's scum. Says Vash makes the most sense as scum with meme and Squigs flipping town. Says he will reread mrh, Yoyo and phil. Claims no visits.
P68 Says mafia are as interested if not more interested in finding WW than town. Questions ghug's motives for voting Squigs. Insists the only thing making squigs scummy was his position on keeping Chaqa.
P69 doubles down on his ghug vote citing the vote switch onto Squigs. Says he tried to end the discussion a while ago. Says the case on him is a stretch. Says the reason I looked scummy earlier was meta from last time I was scum. Now thinks I'm town. Calls ghug's whole case a web of lies. (Recheck this page to see if/how much of ghug's case is actually wrong)
P70 Tells ghug to die with dignity. Says yoyo is scum with ghug. Continues to call ghug a liar and scum.
P71 Tells Yoyo his theory is wrong. Says he as mafia would've killed "the big talkers" at night a long time ago to stop conversation. (That's exactly what it looks like happened though.)
P72 Calls ghug a liar about guak bragging after Squigs died. Calls Vash's scum theory BS. Calls Vash scum for lying. Says his cases on Yoyo+ghug are forthcoming.
P73 "Rebuts" ghug's case. Says DO looks townie. Says DO has contributed more than phil or y2k or Yoyo. Claims early silence was just being busy. Says Vash's theory about mafia trying to lynch him is insane.
P74 Says ghug is scummy and OMGUSing him. Says his votes weren't wasted while ghugs were anti-town. Agrees with DO that mafia should be sitting back doing nothing.


Vashta:

P40 Claims the RB, saying he had a fulfilling evening and votes Flum.
P48 Shows surprise that Squigs is up for lynch. Says he's back for EOD. Finds Squigs town, is unsure about SG. Calls me "hella scummy all game long" and votes for me. (Right after my test vote on meme.) Vash says he doesn't like this lynch at all. (Meme leading)
P49 Vash says he thinks a townie will die no matter what. (meme, SG, and Squigs) Asks SG if he wants to die. Says he hasn't read up on the day. Lists me, DO, ghug, and Flum as his top mafia suspets. Says he hasn't read too much. Asks guak how his statements are a scumslip.
P50 Says I am "fucking obvious scum" Votes SG right after SG switches from agreeing with him to voting for him.
P51 Misunderstands my statement that the wagon against him came up like magic.
P52 Mentions vigilante action again. Says working with the WW is a bad move. Explains his lack of analysis as lack of time. Blames finals.
P55 Asks for no end votes. Votes Chaqa. Claims RB. Chaqa outs Vash as vig and calls his team useless.
P56 Says he loves watching Chaqa squirm. Thinks he is soft-cleared. Plays up that he's vig and doesn't expect to live. Says the problem with leaving Chaqa alive is the WW saving him for later.
P57 Continues to act like he's going to die. Acts paranoid about what Chaqa might contribute to his team overnight.
P58 Says mafia aren't actually down Chaqa yet. Again fears what Chaqa might do at night.
P59 Questions my comment about Squigs scrambling. Says Chaqa IS a threat in his potential advice.
P60 Insists the WW no incentive to kill Chaqa. Says Chaqa may well be a mafia leader. Also says the argument of whether or not to kill Chaqa will cost us valuable time.
P61 Says Chaqa is a threat more. Refuses ghug's idea.
P63 Says only scum can survive the night. (Vash, are you claiming scum now?)
P64 Calls out ghug's vote move. Sets himself up for another "I told you so." And delivers.
P65 Says he is going to be RB'd until he dies. Is now confident 2/3 of me, meme, and ghug are scum. Tells Chaqa to Fuck off. Says the people who suggested Squigs was scum are scum. Says he's right.
P66 Apoligizes for being less active. "If [he] dies for whatever reason" (Almost as though he knows he's not?) Night ends with 3 dead. Vash says it's awkward. Adds: "Mafia know it, may as well say. I claim rb."
P67 Votes guak.
P70 Says we lost the only person who cna kill the WW. (I don't really understand this.) Promises a long skim of the game.
P71 says he thinks it makes more sense that on D1 ND was bussed for mafia y2k. Says he finds it odd that "a certain group containing Chaqa" almost lynched him. Votes DO. Points out that y2k's vote clinched the vote in favor of SG over Vash. (He seems to be saying y2k saved him.) Tells DO guak is mafia. Says DO is mafia. Doesn't understand why DO thinks Yassem is scummy. Posts some reads.
P72 Promises a case in the morning. Calls a guak+DO scumteam. Tells guak mafia lie.
P73 points out DO misunderstanding my vote on her. Says: "Notice: I could be wrong about guak or DO being mafia, but I doubt that both of them aren’t mafia." And concludes he is okay with voting for either. Whole case is prior to P30 and blames internet crapping out on him for why it's short. Calls guak out for being quiet until Chaqa was revealed.
P74 Pushes DO more.