Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 392 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Xapi (194 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Banned for Multiaccounting
The accounts posted in the reply have all been banned for multiaccounting, owned by the same player.

If you were in a game with these players and want it cancelled or whatever, e-mail us at [email protected]
35 replies
Open
masterninja (251 DX)
03 Nov 09 UTC
5 min game
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14965

10 ots
3 replies
Open
Jamiet99uk (1307 D)
01 Nov 09 UTC
One view replies per 60 seconds, please wait and try again.
When using the 'replies' link in my profile, I get the above message if I try to view my replies, then go to a forum thread, then try to view my replies again within 60 seconds. Why does the system impose a limit on how frequently I can view 'replies'? Not a big deal, it just seems odd.
9 replies
Open
Don Corleone (277 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
How much Metagaming?
I'm wondering how much metagaming you all consider to be cheating.
5 replies
Open
Praetorean (100 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
rule clarification
What happens if a ship convoying a land unit is attacked by another fleet? Is the convoy "broken" - can you support a convoy with other fleets to stop this from happening? Also, if unit A attacks unit B and unit B attacks unit A do they merely bounce or swap places?
3 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
24 Oct 09 UTC
Classic Rock
The Best Rockers of all time
Who?
What?
Wht?
45 replies
Open
lukes924 (1518 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Daylight savings time
can/did we update the clock?
20 replies
Open
Gtlblx (919 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
BUG found
:I have a fleet in Rome, and according to the order menu I can move it straight to Tuscany
4 replies
Open
masterninja (251 DX)
03 Nov 09 UTC
Possible cheating
Pls check the players in this game(its anonymous) but all left- and then Russia and Germany who were winning left, asnd now Russia is cleaning up since there is no one left in the game playing despite most having a good dc count
8 replies
Open
ZappedZ (100 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
Question about Cutting Support
If a unit that: 1) supports an attacking unit and 2) is itself supported is attacked, is the support to the attacking unit cut? I cannot think of a better way to word this so I will give an example involving France, with A Pic, A Bur, and A Mar, and Germany, with A Mun. If A Bur S A Pic-Bel and
A Mar S A Bur H, and A Mun-Bur, is the support into Belgium cut? I think that it is, but the rules do not get that specific, so I am not sure.
2 replies
Open
LitleTortilaBoy (124 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
Wow I need to pick it up.
I've been away for a while, then I recently started getting into some more games. I've dropped from top 38 to top 42 percent in the rankings. I blame it on the fact that I've had 2 of my 4 recent games start out with somebody wanting to get me automatically.
3 replies
Open
tilMletokill (100 D)
03 Nov 09 UTC
The start of sumthin NEW
A new live game perhaps
gameID=14938
2 replies
Open
jireland20 (0 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
ONE MORE LIVE GAME
Need one more live gamehttp://www.webdiplomacy.net/index.php
1 reply
Open
tilMletokill (100 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Live game?
check inside if intrested
4 replies
Open
masterninja (251 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
URGENT- Babysitter needed for live game now
Pls let me know if interested.

4 replies
Open
tilMletokill (100 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Sorry to all.
The Leauges players and players I had games with I am sorry I cd'd in them but my computer has been acting up. I hope to stay in the Leauges but if I have one more mishap with my comp I will have to back out.
0 replies
Open
fastgamer (0 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
MONDAY NIGHT LIVE 2--- JOIN
JOIN GUYS
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14933
9 replies
Open
notoriousmjf (0 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
MONDAY MONDAY MONDAY LIVE
live game. need 3 more. gameID=14930. join now.
7 replies
Open
Goldeye (190 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Replacement Russia Needed
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14399
This game will be thrown severely off kilter if the sleeping bear doesn't wake up.
It's 28 D to play. A sticky situation, but I've seen Russia come back from worse.
0 replies
Open
TheSleepingBear (100 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Players that go CD
Is there anything in the works for listing on a players profile how often he/she has gone CD in a game?
15 replies
Open
Thucydides (864 D(B))
02 Nov 09 UTC
If you've seen Dead Poets Society...
you'd like this game:
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14919
4 replies
Open
Thucydides (864 D(B))
02 Nov 09 UTC
That Gigantic Ship, Oasis of the Seas
Thoughts? Will it be Titanic II? Is it just really awesome? Does it represent society's decadence? All of the above?
0 replies
Open
Thucydides (864 D(B))
02 Nov 09 UTC
I found a song about Sicarius
Mr. Wendal
by Arrested Development. I think you'd like it Sic you should try to hear it :)
9 replies
Open
denis (864 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Lyrics variant
The idea is for a game in which you can only talk in the lyrics of a famous song. With the exception of names of countries and if you wish to ask for a pause.
13 replies
Open
Griby98 (0 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Do what you need to do
Cheap new game 1 day phase length, very cheap!!! Join Do What You Need To Do.
4 replies
Open
ottovanbis (150 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Someone Needed to fill a CD Austria
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14387&msgCountry=France
I'm pretty sure this Austria is cd'd or just about to go cd. It makes the game unfair if this countries just taps out early...
2 replies
Open
hellalt (113 D)
27 Oct 09 UTC
People you would like to meet in person
The first ones that pump in your mind are probably the most characteristic!
129 replies
Open
hellalt (113 D)
01 Nov 09 UTC
Biggest Troll Competition
Let's find out who's the biggest forum troll in the history of this site.
You can vote for 5 persons
The first one gets 5 D, the 2nd gets 4 D, the third gets 3 D, the fourth gets 2 D and the last one gets one point!
46 replies
Open
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
01 Nov 09 UTC
Austrian Statistics
below i have tabulated a variety of statistics in the first installment of individual country statistics. for the following stats, i took a sample of 100 games of the specified type (eliminations, solos and draws) to arrive at the results.
masterninja (251 DX)
01 Nov 09 UTC
Hey- Tru Ninja- i got accused of being a stabber cos of our names... are you a constant backstabber even in first few turns?
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
01 Nov 09 UTC
i did not use the following game types:

games that ended before 1904
7-way draws
games with clear indications of multi-accounting
games in which 3 or more players resigned

When Austria Draws, Who Else Draws?
Germany 59%
England 49%
Italy 44%
France 43%
Russia 38%
Turkey 32%

When Austria is Defeated, Who Solos?
Russia 30%
Turkey 25%
France 16%
Italy 12%
Germany 11%
England 6%

When Austria Solos, Who's Eliminated?
Turkey 72%
Russia 60%
Italy 58%
Germany 51%
France 32%
England 20%

Mean Year of an Austrian Solo: 1911

Best Allies: England, Germany
Greatest Adversaries: Russia, Turkey

Much of the information that i saw here was what i expected. the most startling bits of info was when i saw the sharp increase in english performance when austria does well. german statistics were to be expected since austria and germany are the tightest allies money can buy. when austria solos, england was the least likely country to be eliminated (makes sense), when austria is defeated, england had the lowest percentage of solo wins (very shocking) and when austria drew, england had the second highest liklihood of drawing as well only behind the obvious germany.

russia and turkey also were no brainers taking home the highest win pct's when austria is defeated and highest eliminations when austria solos.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
01 Nov 09 UTC
@masterninja...um, im sorry for the inconvenience. i didnt know i participated in giving you that reputation.
I think Austria being defeated would be a fairly obvious indication that England wouldn't be likely to solo as Austria's defeat is essentially a prerequisite to either Turkey or Russia gaining a solo victory.
sean (3490 D(B))
01 Nov 09 UTC
thanks Ninja, great stats. will you be releasing each country one by one?
masterninja (251 DX)
01 Nov 09 UTC
Umm fuckhead- get mods on it- my wins come from losers like you, ALL in live games where you get bored, tired or abandon....

So i am not cheating and have no issue declaring my email addy, location, name blah blah
Perry6006 (5409 D)
01 Nov 09 UTC
I first came across the E/A interdependence, when reading up on the Swedish "Diplomacy Guide", that was released back in the early 90'ies.

However, I am curious wheter not the same relation exist between G/T (very likely imho)!

Would indeed be very interesting if you produced more stats ! Good work!
masterninja (251 DX)
01 Nov 09 UTC
I only take advantage of the players here, and i LOVE fast games, esier points;)
spyman (424 D(G))
01 Nov 09 UTC
What are talking about masterninja? Who is a fuckehead? What do you want the mods to do? Who said you were cheating?
masterninja (251 DX)
01 Nov 09 UTC
Tru Ninja think i am multi accounting when i am not, spyman
orathaic (1009 D(B))
01 Nov 09 UTC
masterninja, please take your conversation to it's own thread, this one is busy having interesting facts of it's own.
Jamiet99uk (1307 D)
01 Nov 09 UTC
@masterninja: No one has accused you of multi-accounting in this thread. Please take your childish abuse elsewhere.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
01 Nov 09 UTC
@LJ yes i agree with that assessment since the stats do agree, but i find it interesting that its not just in that fashion but across the board in all of the stats presented, even when austria does well.

@sean yes, i will cover all the countries in alphabetic order. england is next
@Tru Ninja - Thank you for this, great addition. Would you like help? (Or would you prefer to rely on your own sense of judgment when selecting qualifying games?)

@masterninja - That was the most insane self conversation I've ever seen on this site.
hellalt (113 D)
01 Nov 09 UTC
Masterninja, congrats!
I will have to add you to my honorable trolls list
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
02 Nov 09 UTC
@sayjo i welcome any help youd like to offer! feel free to post additional finding /thoughts/insights. all im doing is collecting the first 100 (consecutive) qualifying games and disregarding any that arent viable games. i dont want people to necessarily view this as my work. i post the stats and leave everything open to the interpretation of others (adding my own insights as well).
amonkeyperson (100 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Can't Ghostie pull out his databases and do this for you? He'll also have a lot more then a 100 games to use....
masterninja (251 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Hellalt- i take it you do not even know what the term Troll pertains to?

Hmm
hellalt (113 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
You tell me! :P
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
02 Nov 09 UTC
i can access all 9k games on this site. size isnt the issue. it just takes time to calculate. i select 100 games since you want a sample size of at least 30 and i dont want to go thru all 9k+ games. i dont know TGM's capabilities with whatever programs he has available to him.

hes welcome to do this though. i just took the initiative.
Chrispminis (916 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
This is a great start Tru Ninja, and must have taken considerable effort on your part to sift through the games.

As has been pointed out is that if you write a program, Ghost (and Kestas obviously) have access to the database of game information and the entire process can be automated for you. This would lend considerably more accuracy as well as save you some time.
ottovanbis (150 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
I took some inspiration from this and made my own stats from diplomacy games to see if there is any progression in the success of countries. I won't interfere though with your more in-depth study. Nice job!
PyroMancer (114 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
I would actually like to know how you select the 100 games. Do you do it randomly? If so (and you should, otherwise the statistics aren't really valid...), how? Have you considered using a larger sample size? 100 of 9000 is fairly low, though not necessarily likely to be inaccurate.
beza1e1 (274 D)
02 Nov 09 UTC
Is there a database dump or something available? I'd like to play around with some statistics as well.
Tru Ninja (1016 D(S))
02 Nov 09 UTC
@chrisp i could write a program in java but i wouldnt even begin to have the time.

@pyro i just use the finished games section of this site and select the first 100 normal games. yes, a larger sample size is always better but since i dont have the time to study the population, i must simply leave it at a sample of the population. i could do it over 200 but ultimately, i dont think that the stats would vary by much. there may be a few percentage points changed here or there but the outcomes would be similar and we would come to the same conclusions.

@beza outside the finished games database, i dont know what youd be looking for.


25 replies
masterninja (251 DX)
02 Nov 09 UTC
New game- fast
Pls join- 10pt bet

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14920
2 replies
Open
Page 392 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top