Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 442 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Pajak (181 D)
26 Dec 09 UTC
LIVE! "Even Santa Loves Dip"
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17544
0 replies
Open
idealist (680 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
A wish to all diplomats...
Merry Christmas!!
11 replies
Open
JECE (1322 D)
23 Dec 09 UTC
Ranking of web-based Diplomacy websites III
For some prior statistics, see threadID=477664 and threadID=489951
18 replies
Open
mel1980 (0 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
New game;) fast, 5 mins
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17541
1 reply
Open
mel1980 (0 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
URGENT- NMR Russia needs replacing
9 units/sc and Chritsmas Live is game name
4 replies
Open
baron von weber (549 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Cutting Support advice!
If for example HOL is supporting an attack from MUN to KIEL, is support cut from HOL if HOL is supported by BEL, but HOL is attacked from N Sea?
general (100 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
yes it is cut
Are you sure as that means that one unit N Sea is more powerful than 2 units i.e. HOL supported by BEL??
general (100 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
I can't say for sure...but no it does not mean the one unit is stronger than the two. It just means that the unit in HOL cannot support an attack while it is also defending. Actually the support from BEL is useless (except if TWO units are attacking HOL). I am a little unsure because I can't remember having done it in recent past but I have a feeling that this is the case...hopefully others will weigh in.
gjdip (977 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
general is right. If a supporting unit is attacked its support is lost no matter how many units support that unit.

He is also right about the support from Belgium being useful in case two units attack Holland.
Thanks guys.

What about if HOL attacks KIEL supported by RUHR & MUN, & KIEL is supported by BER. Will it succeed if HOL is attacked by N SEA??
gjdip (977 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Holland will succeed in taking Kiel. It is not affected by the attack from the North Sea as no support is cut. The fleet in the North Sea will take Holland if its move is unopposed (in this case from Belgium or Heligoland Bight).
Many thanks once again. Just one last question,,

I guess HOL still succeeds (if supported by RUHR & MUN) even if KIEL is supported by BER? As its 3 against 2?
dave bishop (4694 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
yes, as long as no other unit moves to ruhr or Munich and cut support, and moving a unit to holland (from belgium) would ensure it wasn't taken.

Even if Holland supported North Sea to Belgium, the support from holland wouldn't work because it would be dislodged, so NS would bounce Belgium
paulyork64 (351 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
a related issue. does a unit cut support by attacking a unit even if it is dislodged by a supported attack by two other units? eg

FRANCE: ionian sea to naples (occupied by Austria) supported by rome.
AUSTRIA: venice to rome.
FRANCE: piedmont to venice supported by tuscany.

venice moving to rome would cut the support for the move from ionian to naples. but would the successful attack on venice mean that the support would still stand because venice is dislodged?
ottovanbis (150 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
The Austrian move from Venice to Rome WOULD NOT cut the support from Rome for the attack on Venice from Ionian, as there is a rule (look it up if you don't believe me) stating that a unit being attacked cannot cut the support of a unit supporting an attack on that unit. Therefore you would have two sets of 2 v 1 attacks on Venice, and you would actually bounce yourself out of Venice, one of those two sets of attacks would suffice as long as Austria has no other units outside of Venice to cut support. DO NOT bounce yourself, bad idea, unless you don't want venice, then it's fine.
paulyork64 (351 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
rome is supporting move to naples not venice
ottovanbis (150 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
ohh, misread that then... no the support would still be cut as the move from rome counts even though he's dislodged, trust me, i've dealt with this before (if there's something in apulia though, he has to disband and won't give you any more trouble) is it a fleet or an army, doesn't matter for your question, just gives a fuller description to the story.
paulyork64 (351 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
thanks for the info. i picked the locations out of my head not for a specific situation but it's something i've been wondering about for a while now.


13 replies
Attavior (1677 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Christmas Live!!!
5 min, 10pts
gameID=17524
0 replies
Open
JECE (1322 D)
22 Dec 09 UTC
Moderators:
Now my 'threads posted' don't update in addition to my 'replies'! Why?
10 replies
Open
jireland20 (0 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Few more spots for this live game
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17520
2 replies
Open
Hibiskiss (631 D)
21 Dec 09 UTC
Israel admits harvesting Palestinian organs
Not an Onion article

Israel has admitted that pathologists harvested organs from dead Palestinians, and others without the consent of their families...
66 replies
Open
Join this Live game !
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17518
3 replies
Open
orathaic (1009 D(B))
23 Dec 09 UTC
Win - Draw - Survive?
considering survive counts as a loss (except in ppsc games) is survived a worthwhile goal?
84 replies
Open
Triskelli (100 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Sitter needed
I'll be gone tomorrow, and I need a temporary sitter for my running games. Is anyone interested, and can anyone tell me how that works?
2 replies
Open
hellalt (113 D)
24 Dec 09 UTC
Christmas Holidays Game
Bad Santa
gameID=17469
20 D 1day/turn Public Messaging only WTA
9 replies
Open
OMGNSO (415 D)
23 Dec 09 UTC
World Cup- England Team
NOT to be confused with London.

(If someone else has set up this thread already, it has been shoved pretty far down the pages so you better bump it)
10 replies
Open
whoisgalt57 (0 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Occupation
To reap building benefits, must I occupy a supply center through the fall into the winter, or may I merely capture a center in the spring and move on to conquer more?
3 replies
Open
raapers (3044 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Live Game (5 min/phase)
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17508
3 replies
Open
StevenC. (1047 D(B))
25 Dec 09 UTC
Need a new England....for live game....
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17499

10 center England open....
0 replies
Open
tilMletokill (100 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Gunboat Live
Dont feel like talking.
1st day on a computer(that lets me finalize) in a few days
gameID=17499
8 replies
Open
BigZombieDude (1188 D)
23 Dec 09 UTC
Using profile like Hellalt
Its much easier to just have a look at Hellalts profile than me trying to explain it, but i really like what he has done with it. Does anyone else do anything similar? This will save me time looking :)
53 replies
Open
Daniel Hawkins (115 D)
24 Dec 09 UTC
US - East Coast Team
Has anyone created this yet? And would anybody be interested in joining?
9 replies
Open
jireland20 (0 DX)
25 Dec 09 UTC
If you think you can play.....
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17500
9 replies
Open
TheGhostmaker (1545 D)
24 Dec 09 UTC
Woman knocks Pope down at Christmas Mass
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/8430118.stm
Apparently a mentally unstable woman has hit the physically unstable pontiff... sorry.
It seems to me rather odd that she was able to get close enough to him to hit him.
15 replies
Open
raapers (3044 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Live Game (5 min/phase)
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17496
1 reply
Open
denis (864 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
New live game
Celebration of the solstice
http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17495
5 replies
Open
zrallo (100 D)
25 Dec 09 UTC
Christmas eve live game!!
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17494
1 reply
Open
orathaic (1009 D(B))
24 Dec 09 UTC
Pause and Unpause?
ok, just that it occurs to me....
6 replies
Open
Le_Roi (913 D)
22 Dec 09 UTC
16 and Under Game
Any interest?
gameID=17356
PM me for password, only for those 16 and under. Let's see if this goes as well as the last one.
24 replies
Open
StevenC. (1047 D(B))
24 Dec 09 UTC
Live Game.....
Since all of my current games are paused I feel like playing a quick one:

http://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17486
6 replies
Open
jeromeblack (129 D)
24 Dec 09 UTC
LIVE GAME!!!
http://www.webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=17484
2 replies
Open
Page 442 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top