Hahaha Acomist... that made me laugh, I like that one. ;) (But I still think he was good overall.)
You place WAY too much emphasis on STATS, gopher27, I can't say it anybetter than Herm Edwards here...
YOU PLAY TO WIN THE GAME!
And, more specifically, the BIG games.
The 49ers and 'skins of that era:
1980: Neither.
1981: 49ers with a young Montana, Clark, and no one else, really, win SB XVI, thank's to Montana and Walsh's genius and that great goal-line stand... "The Catch" is STILL regarded as one of the most spectacular, important plays in NFL history, not just the play, but who it came AGAINST, that it beat Landry's Cowboys, who'd following the next year fall while the Niner Empire would rise
1982: Redskins win in a STRIKE-SHORTENED season; its futile to wonder what might have been, but I don't think SF would have folded or missed the playoffs if their regulars had been able to paly more than half the year; all that said, granted, good win over the Killer B's Defense and John Riggin's on 4 and 1 still is vivid for football fans
1983: I call this one a tie because the Redskins beat the Niners, but did so in part because of a controversial penalty that hurt the Niners in the final minutes; take away that penalty and the field position that ensued from it and the 49ers hold on to win and we have a Bay Area Super Bowl... and as the Redskins, such a great offensive team, got KILLED by the Raiders... what might have been if not for that call...
1984: 49ers win with one of their best teams and beat a young Marino and the Killer B's
1985: That's just the BEARS YEAR, both the 'skins and Niners did great but nothing was stopping that team.
1986: SF had a first-round by but got killed by the Giants, but seeing as the Giants also killed the Redskins, seems to me they fell to the same enemy.
1987: Yep, the Redskins had this one; we saw our first glimpses of Steve Young, but this is the Redskins year.
1988: The Niners have a rocky start but rebound and win the West, beat the Vikings team that defeated them a yar ago, beat the Bears at Soldier Field in -26 degree weather (seems to ME they could play and win on the road and in the cold...) and then the classic SB XXIII where Montana leads the famous drive to win the game in the closing seconds... and... the Redskins didn't even MAKE the playoffs
1989: The 49ers, with one of the greatest teams EVER in NFL history. When the NFL did their "America's Game" series looking at the 42 Super Bowl winners, each for an hour and interviewing the palyers and coaches of the teams and dynasties (and everyone should check this series out, great to see the old footage from all the way back to the 1966 Packers to the 2007 Giants, and the interviews... if you love the NFL you MUST see it, go to hulu and they have all the episodes their for free to watch) ranked the Top 20 Super Bowl winners ever, the 1989 49ers came in at #4. Ahead of them: 1972 Dolphins, 1985 Bears, 1978 Steelers, so #4 behind THAT is pretty darn good. Montana. Young. Craig. Rathman. Rice. Taylor. Brent Jones. Ronnie Lott. Eric Wright. Charles Hayley. On and on... and they beat the Vikings 41-13, the Rams 30-3, and John Elway's Broncos 55-10 in the SB, STILL the biggest blowout ever. An d the Redskins... didn't even make the playoffs.
1990: The 49ers have a great season, roar out, BEAT THE REDSKINS IN THE PLAYOFFS... and fall short of their third consecutive SB (and a likely 3-peat, they WOULD have beaten those Bills) due to Montana getting knocked out of the game and a last-second FG, they lose to the Giants 15-13.
1991: The 49ers, without Montana for the year, step back a bit as Steve Young finds his ground as the new Niners starter, and the Redskins win the SB... beating the fearsome Atlanta Falcons and Detroit Lions on the way (and then getting the Bills... right there that's almost a gimme SB, playing the BILLS.) ;)
1992: The end of the 1980s Era as after this year Montana leaves and the "Team of the 1990s," the Cowboys (or so they styled themselves... eh, they deserved it) take over. To cap the era: Steve Young's 49ers BEAT the last Joe Gibbs Redskins Team (of his first tenure) in the playoffs, and go on to the 1992 NFC Championship Game, one of the Greatest Games Ever, and... well, just as the 49ers beat the Cowboys to rise to their SB glory, Aikman outduels Young to lead the Team of the 90s to their first SB.
After all this: The 49ers win a 5th SB in 1994 under Young against the Chargers in SB XXIX, Young breaking Montana's single-game TD record in a SB by throwing for 6, and stay great until 1999, when Young suffers a concussion, and the Niner Empire falls; it briefly comes back in the early 2000s, and Jeff Garcia and Terrell Owens lead the 49ers back from 24

down to win 39-38 against the Giants, second only to the Bills' 32 point playoff comeback as the biggest postseason comeback. Currently the team is 8-8, and on the fringe of retaking the division. And the Redkins... signed Donovan McNabb and have done nothing too great since 1991.
To leave out that last bit, the final tally:
SB appearances in the 1980-1991 era:
SF: 4, winning all 4
WSH: 4, winning 3
Against each other in the playoffs:
SF: 1-1
WSH: 1-1
Both beat each other once, the Redksins doing it en route to being routed by the Raiders in SB XVIII, the 49ers doing it en route to a last-second loss in the NFC Championship Game (and given the Bills were the opponent waiting, that basically WAS the SB, and it took knocking out Montana AND a last-second miracle of a kick for the Giants to beat the Niners.)
It seems to me, then, against each other they both played well, both won once...
But the most important number, 4 rings to 3, points to SF.
The Team of the 80s.
Not to bash the Redskins, they were great in that era, too- just not the "Team of the Decade." Another thing that's odd about the Redskins- it seems that in large part their 3 wins came with 3 different TEAMS... Theismann winning one, Doug Williams winning one, and Mark Rypien winning one, John Riggins to Timmy Smith to... someone... the most consistent part of the team to me looks like The Hogs and The Smurfs (plus the ageless Darrell Green) but STILL... a lot of changes.
The 49ers had basically the same team win SBs XXIII and XXIV, the XIX team was not too dissimilar from those teams, its missing Jerry and a few other key components, and has Dwight Clark and Dwight Hicks which the later teams didn't have, but its similar... really the only "hugely different" winner for SF in that era is the first winner, the XVI team, and that was the first team and the start of it all, so its natural that players will be added and the team get better...
The Redskins were always changing, but nevertheless one of the best teams of the 80s.
The 49ers were, in essence, the same, went 4-for-4, and are the Team of the 80s.
@Tru Ninja:
Elway, Favre... yeah, I can see that, either way, #2/#3, they can go either way, if you want Elway at #2 I have no problem with that, he WOULD have won many more SBs if he'd had the teams the NFC big boys like the Giants and Redskins and Rams and Vikings and 49ers of that era had...
Still, as he played Montana in SB XXIV and lost THAT BIG, and Montana was... Montana, and could do it even without the 49ers (he BEAT THEM when he played young and his old team in the 1994 season when he was with the Chiefs, and the year before had the Chiefs in the AFC Championship Game and fighting before he was knocked out of the game) so Montana IS #1 for me, and I think for most people.
Granted if you were playing backyard football and you took Montana and I had to "settle" by picking Elway, that wouldn't be a pick to cry about... ;)