We have two clear OMGUS votes so far.
Spirit against NES
and
CB against RD

In both cases the responding - offended - party has provided some reasoning behind their voting for their accuser, which is good, and I sort of by their reasons. I do think its worth highlighting though as if its coupled with other suspicious behaviour it can be a good sign.

With that said, I decided to do some re-reading and NES (New England Separatist), and his votes just feel scummy to me. Like he's trying to find a wagon to hitch himself to.

##Vote New England Separatist

@Foxcastle, funny you were in my A category... was that a show of a newcomer scum getting nervous and deciding to be not only active but decisive??

Let's find out.

What are you thoughts on my theory? Why don't you elaborate beyond a vote. Can you? If not thats okay, your complete lack of ability to form a complex argument should be enough to prove my point.

I was going to wait til morning for my two lists based on my prior post.

A Category: Players who are new (or i think they are, again correct me), and lurking,
-Mama Lama
-Foxcastle

Category B: Participating but not saying much of use,
-SBB
-NES
-Brainbomb

Now. I will ONLY agree to a D1 lynch on one of those 5.

And before someone points it out, I know my vote is currently on Rdrivera. He falls in another category. That I want more information before I lynch. Same category as ghug and demon.

Wait. Did you just imply that brain bomb is new?
Lmao

@CommanderByron As a newcomer, actually, staying quiet and letting the veterans smash eachother to bits seems like pretty sound strategy either way... (I guess all my posts will now begin with "As a newcomer...")

But if I was being petty snapping back with a vote like that, I relent.
##UNVOTE

Ya know, ghug, you should really read the set up, cause you mentioned what we should do with the cop...there isn't one.

Anyway, I must reiterate that as a vanilla townie you SHOULD NEVER HARD CLAIM. The worst that can possible happen is you getting cc'd by the actual PR and getting you both killed. Even in the case that Spirit brings up about tricking the mafia is not worth it as if you hard claim and they don't kill you, the counter claim could easily still happen. Not to mention that this is all solved simply by softing the roles but not hard claiming....which is what you should be doing anyway as a VT in order to protect PRs.

As for claiming a PR on your deathbed, I think this should be done by the information gathering PRs (tracker and watcher) for obvious reasons, but am unsure about any other situations.

Theoretically we could use any PR claim as bait for the tracker and watcher to catch mafia....except for the fact that the driver exists and that can easily screw up information. Honestly the existence of the stage coach driver makes the mafia really really strong if they know how to use it optimally, so let's hope they don't.

##Call GM: Will the Tracker or Watcher be informed if the person they were tracking/watching was switched. Same with any other roles that target people but I am most curious about those two.

As for thoughts on players, I really want bb to either shut up or be on task and don't have any overly strong reads cause ya know....page 8.

@Damian - no, i grouped him there because i feel he isn't saying much. Doesn't really fall in my third category, because i would be willing to lynch him D1.

@Foxcastle- Silence only benefits scum. Speak, as much as you can. Ask questions if you don't feel comfortable making statements. They call me a try-hard here because I am; if i don't have an idea where to vote. I say whatever is on my mind to get reactions. I don't have a ton of experience so seeing scum is hard for me. But, I try to create as much conversation as possible so experienced players have more to look at and more interactions to feel out.

I will chalk it up to a poor judgement for now. But my eyes are still on you.

Wow CB, deciding a day 1 lynch 5 hours into day 1, that seems a bit premature.

I mean fake hard claim btw, in case that was unclear.

Byron I think you are town.

As in fake claim a PR. I need to use my words better. Maybe New England Separatist can help.

Or Broad Expert

@Vash- I am not deciding on any one person but im narrowing my list and broadcasting it to see if their reactions build my case or exonerate them. I am willing to hear more cases but right now those 5 are my D1 list.

I still would love some input from a few players, especially experienced ones who are probably just sleeping right now.

@damian- I would actually recommend Broad Excerpt. Much friendlier and cheaper.

I mean CB, you can understand my conclusion when you said you would ONLY vote for one of those 5. After all only seems a bit premature even if they are your top picks at the moment.

How the hell does snowy have 54 posts already... I was trying to catch up. -_-

@Vash- fair enough. I guess i shouldn't have spoken in absolutes. I get excited. You have a bit of experience. Do you see my points on
-Rdrivera
-Foxcastle
(Leaving SBB, NES, BB, ghug, demon, and mamalama out since theirs have less evidence and are more feelings)

I haven't read anything but just by skimming one of Vash's posts I can tell he's scum.
##vote Vash

(Leaving SBB, NES, BB, ghug, demon, and mamalama out since theirs have less evidence and are more feelings)

I love feelings
Lets express these feelings
Gimme som a dat luv

CB, any partially reason you left Spirit off your list?

I thought he was a new player, did he play in a game I wasn't watching (tbf thats most of them)

I'm getting really good at this game.

Lol fluminator. Dude. Do you miss me or naw

D1 Official Vote Count
Brainbomb (2) Snowy801, sevenbrokenbricks
New England Separatist (2) SpiritoftheRadio, Damian
Ghug (2) Chaqa, yavuzovic
DemonOverlord (1) Ghug
Bo_Sox47 (1) Maniac
SpiritoftheRadio (1) New England Separatist
Damian (1) DemonOverlord
CommanderByron (1) rdrivera2005
rdrivera2005 (1) CommanderByron
VashtaNeurotic (1) Fluminator
UNVOTED: Foxcastle

Not yet voted: bozotheclown, bo_sox48, brainbomb, Ezio, guak, Hellenic Riot, MamaLama, Tom Bombadil, VashtaNeurotic, Vecna

NO ONE is currently set to be lynched. Approximately 42.5 hours remain

**The Tracker bot did not register Maniacs Vote for some reason


@Vashta, I'm not sure exactly how the roles interact in that case and will defer to Jamie.

I kind of do. I remember when you were the resident crazy person and now a few months later you're one of the more sane people on the forum. (how?)

I enjoyed you convincing me to lynch your scumbuddy last game. Can you do that again?

@damian, I am not sure if he's played before. I got the sense he has. But maybe he's just been around long-enough I assumed he has. I do agree now in looking back that his posts are very useless. So much so, if it would get him talking with more effort;
##Vote SpiritoftheRadio

Can someone tell me what the point of a fruit vendor is?

##GM ASSISTANCE

It appears you have bo_sox48 listed as bo_sox47

also Maniac didn't put a space between Vote and the username.... soooo maybe thats why?

Is it too try hard to help the GMs?? Is that a lynch-able offense?