_Scum_
gauk
ND
Krellin
vecna
Brainybob
meme
Ghug
reedeer1
_Town_

This is my list off the top of my head, but it is subject to change and should not be taken too seriously as I have not reread everyone yet.

That isnt really a very good explanation. What makes you think that way?

Why is guak so scummy for example?, why is meme and ghug so towny?

Its not to badger you but you are an enigma this game compared to almost everyone else.

I am in the middle of some physics homework. basically its based on other peoples cases, but I will explain more in the morn.

Shit -- you know what? ghug and guak -- potential scum buddies, putting on a show.

I'm goign to throw you a fucking bone, Reeder. Take your top man...and let's run with it.

##VOTE guak

Fuck this shit.

Let's see if ghuggy man's up and follows his constant tirade that guak must go. Let's see if he's really willing to lynch his scum-buddy.

REEDER -- If guak if your top scum, THEN FOR ONCE IN THIS FUCKING GAME CAST A DAMN VOTE THAT MATCHES YOUR READS.

VOTE NOW! Prove to me that you aren't just talking shit and playing us all for fools.

Okay well heres some thoughts.

Day 1 the major wagons were
Vecna (???) vs Demon (Town)

Day 2 the major wagons were
y2k (Town PR) vs Maniac (Town PR)

Day 3 the wagons were all over the place
xorxes (scum), guak (???), ghug (???), Warden (scum), Maniac (Town PR)

Day 4 the wagons were polarized
Warden (scum), OBGYN (Town PR)

Day 5 the wagons were again dispersed
Jamiet (Town), Goldfinger (Town), Vecna (???), ghug (???)

To our knowledge we have never had a day where the top two candidates on any wagon were both confirmed scum other than Day 3.

This tells me we need to think outside the box. Putting ND on a wagon creates a conversation we have not been allowed to have yet this game. Nobody has ever pushed him until now, he has basically gotten away with doing almost nothing to help the town.

And technically speaking the Day 3 wagon chaos was Chaqa, jamiet, OBGYN, and goldfinger confusing themselves on what to go for. the wagons were all over the place, Warden was not in much danger of being lynched.

Is it possible that Day 3 we had every single Mafia member up for lynch at the same time other than Maniac? That is what krellin is suggesting, I just have a hard time imagining that being the case with all the gerrymandering going on.

I will look more into vecna.

Possible mafia combinations I think are quite possible.
Vecna-ND (and the tunnelling is fake)
ghug - Vecna (since they both have won before as mafia)
guak - meme (since they both fit the low profile type of player)
meme - Vecna (since both are either never around at EOD, or show up hella late to the party)
krellin - reedeer1 (since krellin promised to vote for him today and seems to have lost interest in that already)
ghug - reedeer1 (If he scumread reedeer1 he would absolutely say so which is why I dont think so)
meme - ghug (since ghug keeps saying meme is scum, but never quite has the cajones to actually go for that vote)

ND - reedeer1
ND - guak
ND - meme

All feel like possibilities to me based on in game play.

ND-ghug
ND-krellin

feel less sensible considering ghug doesnt seem to really quite like ND's playstyle this game at all, and krellin is not likely to join a voting block on a teammate that early in a phase.

##vote guak
for now

What? Go ahead bb -- tell me who to vote for. blah blah blah. After all, I vote for mafia, I'm guilty. I ask someone a questions about their odd behavior, and suddenly I'm scummy. It doesn't seem that anything I do for the benefit of the town has any affect but to cast me in a dark light.

So fuck this...I'm done trying. Your the second biggest dick on the block next to me - so YOU tell me what to do, big guy.

I'm sick of this crap.

Current Provisional Vote Count

guak : (2) reedeer1, krellin
krellin : (1) ghug
Vecna : (1) ND
ND : (1) brainbomb

Not yet voted : (3) guak, captainmeme, Vecna

I dont know how many drinks youve had but im on my 3rd pint. I play crazier when drunk.

https://youtu.be/89NjEeHku8o

I am fairly sure that Brainbomb is Vecna's partner.

1) He has spent a good portion of the game defending Vecna. Especially during the crucial EOD#1. At other times Brainbomb and Vecna have argued but it has been in my opinion a faux fight.

2) Brainbomb has posted SO much that a coherent and lengthy case on him would be so voluminous it would take the greatest researcher sage so long to write that by the time it was done the game would be over. Hence, case in point, Brainbomb's play is so utterly incoherent, scatterbrained, and off the wall that getting a strong read or making a succinct case is clearly impossible. This was most likely the goal and strategy going in and nothing Brainbomb has done convinces me it is not the continued strategy now.

3) I also believe at various points in the game that Brainbomb engaged Krellin (a man known for profane statements) in baseless and un-town discourse just to distract the conversation, steer the conversation off point, cast shadows.

4) A brainbomb voting history should be informative and I will try to provide that before EOD#5.

5) I believe that Brainbomb's attack on me is because the remaining mafia know that I have to be silenced. They know I won't rest in my pursuit of Vecna. If I am silenced then the mafia (may) be able to stop the Vecna push and move into the next cycle controlling the conversation. Brainbomb's rapid-fire posts are an excellent way to control the town discourse. Vecna will be able to remain in the shadows only coming out to post at night and Brainbomb will simply feign surprise at my town flip. Brainbomb-Vecna will move on to the next target. They will go for a final lynch on someone who they feel will be the easiest to pick off.

Be wary of this player and Vecna folks. They are not town. They are not helpful. They are not playing for the town win. They need to be stopped. If I do get lynched I ask that every town player to be mindful of these posts and my Vecna case. They are the keys to victory.

Brainbomb voting history next.

My vote will only before Brainbomb/Vecna this cycle.

*My vote will only be on* Brainbomb/Vecna this cycle
-edit

I can tell you goldy published it a few pages back. here it is.

day 1 voted for demon
day 2 voted y2k
day 3 voted warden
day 4 voted warden
day 5 voted goldy
day 6 voting you

He posited I have no conviction. I dont know who is scummier here, you or Vecna or guak or reedeer1 or krellers or meme or ghuggly moogles.

This games wide open dude. You arent exactly playing town at all.

Why would you have such conviction with such certainty. certainty only you and guak seem to have.

Right.. I am confident in my case bb. The record will inevitably prove that I was right.

guak always plays that way but what is your excuse exactly?

I have no clue what you are talking about. I am confident in my case. That's all that matters to me.

Here is your record at catching scum vs killing town PR. 1:1 ratio.

Here is Vecnas catching scum vs getting town PR killed ratio.
2:0

Here is ghugs ratio
2:1 as ghug correctly identified both xorxes and warden pre-maniac report.

Here is guaks ratio: 2:0

My point is the difference between us is not as stark as you try to claim. you play tighter to the hip and blindly tunnel. Ive never played that way and never will. people who play "certain" are often scum or bad townies. Paranoid people vote for their gut. another reason why ghug seems inno he is not rehearsed. theres no script he is reading from.
you have a script in front of you. it is rehearsed. it is prophesorial and utterly blind. It makes no attempt to consider everyone when were down to 8 ppl left and you still persist with this.

I cannot fathom how you can claim you are playing better than meme or guak or even stoned ass krellin at this point. My defense of someone would be my demise very quickly if I was just dipshit mafia defending a partner from the ND boogeyman.

why isn't ghug with us on guak. he was the most against guak...