M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

this can all be solved by you rereading my ghug case and weighing in on it. that would give you a nice break from having to fight with will also

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Well Jamie we can’t know you are lying or not just because you say you aren’t lying. So why is it really ridiculous if I think you are?

[Jamiet99uk]

this can all be solved by you rereading my ghug case and weighing in on it. that would give you a nice break from having to fight with will also

Sure.

Ghug is often light hearted and light in substance on D1 as any alignment. Your case on him is largely based on noticing things which I consider NAI for D1 Ghug.

There you go.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Brainbomb you don't have any evidence that meets your own standard, which you just stated, because you cannot prove that I have lied, because I did not lie.

No way to know this tho

So we are working on the assumption that you are

[Jamiet99uk]

Well Jamie we can’t know you are lying or not just because you say you aren’t lying. So why is it really ridiculous if I think you are?

Because I have repeatedly challenged you to explain why I would make up that lie, as scum - and you can't.

[Jamiet99uk]

Brainbomb you don't have any evidence that meets your own standard, which you just stated, because you cannot prove that I have lied, because I did not lie.

No way to know this tho

So we are working on the assumption that you are

The assumption is false.

Why would scum!Jamie decide to create that lie?

How does posting the explanation I gave help me win the game as scum?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

this can all be solved by you rereading my ghug case and weighing in on it. that would give you a nice break from having to fight with will also

Sure.

Ghug is often light hearted and light in substance on D1 as any alignment. Your case on him is largely based on noticing things which I consider NAI for D1 Ghug.

There you go.

I actually don’t agree with this. After page 12 of M86, Ghug has ~80% of his posts trying to actually win and play the game.

This game he seems absent, even when he’s here. His posts seem to drag on and needlessly elongate the thread (which is ironic cuz I do the same, but it’s suspicious because Ghug usually doesn’t)

[Jamiet99uk]

I am unclear on why you think anyone is anything to be honest. I havent seen a reason why you townread me? or why you stopped scumreading/stopped voting D&W?

I'll address these two points too, or else Brainbomb will scumread me for not answering them.

1. You are a null for me currently; I neither strongly townread you or strongly scumread you. I am not sure if you would create all this drama with me as scum, or if you're just bad wrong feckless tinfoil town.

2. If you look at the interactions between me and D&W it should be quite obvious, but for the record: His early posts were lacking and didn't seem well thought out, just going after me because I seemed an easy target at the time. Later, he put in a lot more work, which I positively acknowledged him for doing. If you just look at my exchanges with him it's plain to see, so I assume you did not read the recent ones, or did not read them very carefully at all.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Well Jamie we can’t know you are lying or not just because you say you aren’t lying. So why is it really ridiculous if I think you are?

Because I have repeatedly challenged you to explain why I would make up that lie, as scum - and you can't.

Ok well:

Putting a target on anothers back
Seeing who’s Overanalyzing
Seeing who is actually paying attention to your posts so you know who to NK
Filling up the thread
Baiting me into a needlessly long argument which typically ends in me being moe scummy than the instigator.

There are many reasons you could have done it, I just don’t know why.

[brainbomb]

okay, well I think ghug is mafia. and that his actions are what he does as scum, not town. and that they are not NAI.

[Jamiet99uk]

this can all be solved by you rereading my ghug case and weighing in on it. that would give you a nice break from having to fight with will also

Sure.

Ghug is often light hearted and light in substance on D1 as any alignment. Your case on him is largely based on noticing things which I consider NAI for D1 Ghug.

There you go.

I actually don’t agree with this. After page 12 of M86, Ghug has ~80% of his posts trying to actually win and play the game.

This game he seems absent, even when he’s here. His posts seem to drag on and needlessly elongate the thread (which is ironic cuz I do the same, but it’s suspicious because Ghug usually doesn’t)

You're comparing only two games whereas I have known Ghug for centuries.

You could be right, or I could be, I guess we can agree to disagree, but I'm not seeing any strong scumtells for Ghug here as of yet.

[brainbomb]

you both are holding strong and hard that each other is town. maybe you should sheep his votes? I dont know what to tell you, but if thats who you feel is your best townread so far, then maybe advocate for reasons why hes better than a null

[Jamiet99uk]

Well Jamie we can’t know you are lying or not just because you say you aren’t lying. So why is it really ridiculous if I think you are?

Because I have repeatedly challenged you to explain why I would make up that lie, as scum - and you can't.

Ok well:

Putting a target on anothers back
Seeing who’s Overanalyzing
Seeing who is actually paying attention to your posts so you know who to NK
Filling up the thread
Baiting me into a needlessly long argument which typically ends in me being moe scummy than the instigator.

There are many reasons you could have done it, I just don’t know why.

And yet I have provided the real answer. The pure answer. The answer that comes from my town heart.

[Jamiet99uk]

you both are holding strong and hard that each other is town. maybe you should sheep his votes? I dont know what to tell you, but if thats who you feel is your best townread so far, then maybe advocate for reasons why hes better than a null

I always feel hard when Ghug holds me.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ghugs other most recent game, M84, after page 11 he is mostly serious

[Jamiet99uk]

My townreads at the moment are Rdrivera and Dave&Buster's

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Because I have repeatedly challenged you to explain why I would make up that lie, as scum - and you can't.

Ok well:

Putting a target on anothers back
Seeing who’s Overanalyzing
Seeing who is actually paying attention to your posts so you know who to NK
Filling up the thread
Baiting me into a needlessly long argument which typically ends in me being moe scummy than the instigator.

There are many reasons you could have done it, I just don’t know why.

And yet I have provided the real answer. The pure answer. The answer that comes from my town heart.

How do I know its true tho

[brainbomb]

My townreads at the moment are Rdrivera and Dave&Buster's

ghug is voting rdrivera to scare him.

[Jamiet99uk]

My townreads at the moment are Rdrivera and Dave&Buster's

ghug is voting rdrivera to scare him.

I enjoyed Rdr's reaction to that.

I am not going to vote Rdrivera.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

My townreads at the moment are Rdrivera and Dave&Buster's

ghug is voting rdrivera to scare him.

Ghug also doesn’t have a track record for joke vote past ~Page 9