MAFIA 49 -Avengers "Re-release"- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

[Nephthys]

2. Cybernetic Eye (one shot cop scan)

Use this on someone who you think would be a good clear. Knowing that they will die shortly after, it is good to target someone that will contribute if cleared. I would limit this is a null read of yours in the top half of the posters.

This is awful advice. Why try for a townclear instead of trying to hit scum? Makes no sense. If you are going to clear someone and force scum to kill them, it's better to do it with someone useless, not with someone that will contribute anyway. It is not necessary to be clear in order to contribute. I would say look in the bottom half of the posters, which are the ones we most want information on.

Of course you want to hit scum. That's so obvious it doesn't need mentioning. My advice was a secondary consideration that makes a hell of a lot of sense. There would, for example, been little point scanning yuuki as he didn't contribute all that much due to sheer lack of posts.

You want to maximise the benefits from the item right?

Hope for the best but prepare for the worst?

[Nephthys]

Stopped at store. Still not caught up. Don’t read you yes.

@Kit. Shoot chaqa unless they explain their fake Dr Strange claim VERY well.

What possible motive could scum!chaqa have to claim what they did?

What possible motive could town Chaqa have had?

WHY IS THIS GAME SO FULL OF IDIOTS?

Hmm strong words coming from someone who shot two townies...

[Nephthys]

1. Hadron Enforcer (one shot gun)

Use this on someone widely scumread. Kalel/Maniac most likely at this stage

Only if she scumreads them as well and can justify it with other than "they were widely scumread".

2. Cybernetic Eye (one shot cop scan)

Use this on someone who you think would be a good clear. Knowing that they will die shortly after, it is good to target someone that will contribute if cleared. I would limit this is a null read of yours in the top half of the posters.

This is awful advice. Why try for a townclear instead of trying to hit scum? Makes no sense. If you are going to clear someone and force scum to kill them, it's better to do it with someone useless, not with someone that will contribute anyway. It is not necessary to be clear in order to contribute. I would say look in the bottom half of the posters, which are the ones we most want information on.

Of course you want to hit scum. That's so obvious it doesn't need mentioning. My advice was a secondary consideration that makes a hell of a lot of sense. There would, for example, been little point scanning yuuki as he didn't contribute all that much due to sheer lack of posts.

You want to maximise the benefits from the item right?

Hope for the best but prepare for the worst?


*formatting

[BunnyGo]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

Thanos can choose a vote value of 0,1,2,3 if they have 2 stones.

[Nephthys]

Scumteam is;

Kalel
Vapor
Maniac
Food/Fox

[Chaqa]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

Thanos can choose a vote value of 0,1,2,3 if they have 2 stones.

Bunny has been relatively unaware of the mechanics of this entire game, but he picks up on this detail?

Huh. Bunny could be Thanos, actually. Like 50% chance.

[Maniac]

I don't think Yukki did try and save me. I think he probably just altered the day's length well before I was on the chopping block. Maybe because he couldn't be on EOD, Idk

But he was on at EoD.

Was he on the original EOD. I think I saw on the bot that he hadn't been on for a day and a half. That could record posts rather than accessing the page off course. My bad.

[Nephthys]

@vapor, wanna actually make a case on why I'm scum?

[BunnyGo]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

Thanos can choose a vote value of 0,1,2,3 if they have 2 stones.

Bunny has been relatively unaware of the mechanics of this entire game, but he picks up on this detail?

Huh. Bunny could be Thanos, actually. Like 50% chance.

I’ve actually been surprised nobody thought I was Thanos more. That said, I was reading up rules more recently (after correctly getting called out). See my posts referencing some. Also see all my questions to GM where I was thinking about mechanics and interactions. Was learning.

Also, didn’t join either lynching late. Was on bozo before it was clear which wagon would win. Jumped off all leading wagons on D2. Correctly I might add.

If I’m Thanos (which I’m not) I’m playing such a deep game you’re screwed. The only chance is for the scum to get me. And if I don’t die sacrifice one of their own to reveal. Come get me scum.

[rdrivera2005]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

I would not oppose Vision using Mind Stone on me, but I didn't get why only me and EP could be Thanos with a +2. First day a VT was lynched so it doesn't matter who were in any wagon (Thanos don't need to be on a wagon to use his power) and anyone in Yukki wagon except Xorxes and Jamiet could be SK (but I am not so sure SK was on Yukki wagon but I don't want to discuss this at night).

[RagingIke297]

##Call GM - Could I choose to hand my item to another player? Or is this stones only?

You can hand any items off to other players

##call gm

Is it possible for item thief to pass the stolen items to their scum teammates?

Yes

##Call GM, can a player with a non-stone item hand it off to another player

Yes

[Nephthys]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

Why am I included there?

I wasn't on yuuki at EOD

[Nephthys]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

Why am I included there?

I wasn't on yuuki at EOD

Nvm, I'm stupid. There is nothing to stop SK!Rivera/EP just using the vote as +1 anyway

[Chaqa]

I don't think it's worthwhile to speculate on who/how the extension happened. Occam's Razor says that Yuuki used it, for whatever reason. He didn't tell us he had his stone stolen, so our best assumption now is that Thanos has the Time Stone now.

That said... we know that if Thanos has the Time Stone, he is either Rivera or Espresso. So if we see a vote manipulation happen, and it ISN'T a +2 vote, we know Rivera and E.P. AREN'T Thanos, and that Thanos is in the pool of {Neph, BunnyGo, Kitsune, KalEl} instead.

I think tomorrow Vision should use the Mind Stone on either Maniac or Rivera, to be frank.

I would not oppose Vision using Mind Stone on me, but I didn't get why only me and EP could be Thanos with a +2. First day a VT was lynched so it doesn't matter who were in any wagon (Thanos don't need to be on a wagon to use his power) and anyone in Yukki wagon except Xorxes and Jamiet could be SK (but I am not so sure SK was on Yukki wagon but I don't want to discuss this at night).

I was incorrect on how the stones worked.

[Nephthys]

1. Hadron Enforcer (one shot gun)

Use this on someone widely scumread. Kalel/Maniac most likely at this stage

Only if she scumreads them as well and can justify it with other than "they were widely scumread".

2. Cybernetic Eye (one shot cop scan)

Use this on someone who you think would be a good clear. Knowing that they will die shortly after, it is good to target someone that will contribute if cleared. I would limit this is a null read of yours in the top half of the posters.

This is awful advice. Why try for a townclear instead of trying to hit scum? Makes no sense. If you are going to clear someone and force scum to kill them, it's better to do it with someone useless, not with someone that will contribute anyway. It is not necessary to be clear in order to contribute. I would say look in the bottom half of the posters, which are the ones we most want information on.

Of course you want to hit scum. That's so obvious it doesn't need mentioning. My advice was a secondary consideration that makes a hell of a lot of sense. There would, for example, been little point scanning yuuki as he didn't contribute all that much due to sheer lack of posts.

You want to maximise the benefits from the item right?

Hope for the best but prepare for the worst?


*formatting

To follow up on this, I would say that someone like food is an excellent scan. He both can contribute a lot as town and be a good catch as scum.

[Vaporwave]

what makes me your scumlean, Nephthys?

I haven't seen any cases you've done on me, is this some subtle form of omgus?

[Vaporwave]

hey emc, is he still following the game?

[Vaporwave]

oh maybe he came for other threads

pardon-moi

[Vaporwave]

Never felt more uninspired than this game

Temasek as only suspect, I will have to sheep both Jamie and xorxes and Serial Bunny Killer

Maybe even Kit, our only female detective in this game