M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[Kakarroto]

Hmm, I don't like that neither jamie nor d&w did answer my posts. I was a bit busy and maybe they just are, but I really don't like them ignoring me.

checking the thread again it seems they just weren't here, guess bad timing from my side. so in case you two overlooked it before:

@d&w: what exactly was it that you thought Jamie needs to be hammered this early? You jumped on brain and will who had their sights on jamie before and were quite involved with each other, so you doing that feels quite opportunistic

@jamie: you don't feel buster's vote on you was opportunistic?

[brainbomb]

I am very satisfied with the current elimination choices. wouldnt mind ghug dying here but if these are the choices thats fine.

[brainbomb]

excuse me, rosa, who are your townreads?

[ghug]

##VOTE dip

[Kakarroto]

Hey, I've been having problems posting.

I guess I just have very bad timing

you mind, if you can of course regarding your current posting obstacles, sharing your view on d&w's endvote that might've caused your untimely voteout?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE dip

Woah woah just because you’re town doesn’t mean you can vote just anyone

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Jamie is really dang hard to read. I’m gonna need more time.

ghug seems to be more consistent

Need to find a tell for Jam…

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Jamie why can’t you be consistent and easy to read

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

AAAAAAAAA I’m going mad here!!!!1!

[brainbomb]

Pregame:

https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=384793#p384793
I am really confused about exactly what the Mafia's first power is and how it interacts with the voting.
Are PR votes publicly visible?
Can you only vote for the target of docsave or the target of copscan, not both?
Can the first Mafia ability be described as follows, or am I misinterpreting something?
Each night, the mafia team may choose to change who one player votes for as the target of a role, but may not change which role that player votes for the target of?

GM REPLY, following post

The GM can correct me if I am mistaken, but this is what I believe to be the answers to your questions:

1. PR target votes are sent via PM to the GM (foodcoats) and the Co-GM (sweetandcool). Every TOWN player MUST submit a vote before the end of each night. Consequently these are not public.

2. You can only submit one vote. Consequently you must choose between directing the copscan or the docsave.

3. I believe your description of the Mafia's vote redirection power is correct.

First post of game:

Should Cop & Doc reveal themselves, so we can clear them?

@Diplomacy
It seems that you were aware of the flaws in massclaiming after the GMs clarified these questions for you in pregame about what the mafia powers could do.

##VOTE NO KILL
##END

Have you been in a game on some other forum or somewhere else before where doing this was useful in some way?

[Kakarroto]

excuse me, rosa, who are your townreads?

not really minding it, but there might be game mixes with other players (maybe?) so I suggest not giving too much information out there, just in case. Though I think I'm the only one left for that one?

Anyway, I'm leaning town for Jamie and with that thinking ghug is just town. If jamie flips mafia, I'd have to rethink ghug, but I doubt he will. I think you are quite towny brain, and if I'm wrong, I think it will show. I'm slightly town leaning will, but much less so.

damo exists in a "what brain said makes much sense" sphere, but I don't feel too good about it. But it's about the same feeling with food, so I guess you are right.

RD and worcej do have my D1 protection, though maybe I should overthink that. The game is pretty short, so not much time to figure them out I guess.

so it looks kinda like this currently:

ghug=brain > jamie > > will > (>) damo > > > d&w
(and RD and worcej are outside of it)

[brainbomb]

Frankly the only thing someone has said that hasn't been contradicted by someone else is that Jamiet hates me. Speaking of which, Jamiet hates me because while everyone else joked around and made useless posts, I joked around and wrote useless posts (endvotes only go through if most of the players endvote the same result. No-kill isn't going to get 5 hammer votes) .

Either Jamiet is a town who decided to argue with two people who I, frankly, townread, and also vote me, then campaign against me because I used no-vote as a placeholder so I didn't forget to vote and get modkilled, and endvoted as a joke, none of which which a skilled player like Jamiet is likely to do as town; OR jamiet is scum. Take your guess.
##VOTE JAMIET

Why did you take this so personally that jamie found you scum for such minor things?

[Kakarroto]

I think we only need one more vote on d&w to get him to the lead?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Does anyone remember if Jamie was Mafia in the ice cream game? I think it was M70? I can’t tell from the bot

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

What does replaced mean? Is it a role or did he sub out like heart did?

Cuz he seems to do it a lot

[brainbomb]

Ghug also seems slighly off lol

Ghug does seem off but not enough to vote them out. Copscan?

yea this is weird as shit also. but I agree actually with the idea? sure, scan ghug. whoever cop is, do that

[brainbomb]

I think we only need one more vote on d&w to get him to the lead?

I dont think hes scum its just way too radical town to me

[Kakarroto]

I think we only need one more vote on d&w to get him to the lead?

I dont think hes scum its just way too radical town to me

who else then? I don't think it's ghug if jamie is town, and it would be pretty coincidence if it's worcej and RD and both are just hanging back. Maybe damo, but you made some good points there, if I shut out my feelings for a moment. I mean will still might be, but d&w is just feeling so much more opportunistic with his endvote there

[brainbomb]

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?user=diplomacy&g=85


this is M85 where D&W was town

[brainbomb]

I think we only need one more vote on d&w to get him to the lead?

I dont think hes scum its just way too radical town to me

who else then? I don't think it's ghug if jamie is town, and it would be pretty coincidence if it's worcej and RD and both are just hanging back. Maybe damo, but you made some good points there, if I shut out my feelings for a moment. I mean will still might be, but d&w is just feeling so much more opportunistic with his endvote there

ignoring anyone else, evaluate ghug and just ghug in his present state. name a vote he has made today that was impactful or had weight behind it