@MLQ, what is your current thinking on Bo?

I'm happy to flip Bo today. I think we obviously need to flip him before LYLO, and it seems like he's widely scumread. I think he has enough interactions that we'd have plenty more stuff to analyze. If the MLQ wagon peters out, my vote will likely be on Bo.

I liked Bo's argument on Day 2 about ND. His basic premise was that ND could be scum because ND was certainly a viable lynch and Jamiet did not fight hard to lynch ND -- Jamiet voted for me. But that's basically the only thing from Bo's play that has struck me as Townie. He doesn't check-in much. He...

thamrick wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 06, 2018 8:37 pm

I find it very strange that Balki has listed Bo as a scumread for similar reasons to my own but hasn't engaged me about it.

I do think Bo is the best lynch today though.

Strange? You want to talk about it?

I agree with your points. And I think you're Town and he's Scum.

Here is what MLQ said on Day 3 about the Cop: They're already at a huge disadvantage and they know they can't win if the cop lives for much longer , outing the cop is their win condition now that the witch is dead, can't you see that? The thing is, the cop produces 1 semi-clear or 1 scum target a da...

Tom Bombadil wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 06, 2018 8:04 pm

@Balki - You don't buy Mean's argument at all that bozo could be scum and scum killed brain anyway to softclear bozo?

No. And I know MLQ doesn't believe it either. Let me pull a quote.

Sorry, I'm thinking out loud here. @Balki - Surely you are a smart guy. You tell everyone that all the time. Do you think bozo is surely town based on brain's inno scan alone? Has he done anything else remotely towny? Damn it! I do not tell people I am smart. They just read what I write and know it...

I feel like lots of people have looked at the Balki/MLQ interaction and just said "looks like Town vs. Town." We've heard that from several people. But it is such a superficial assertion, without any meat at all. I'll tell you, just from a numbers perspective, it's somewhat unlikely that Balki vs. M...

Also, Tom claimed to be saved last night, and the Nurse who did the saving is still alive, so Tom is basically clear.

@Yoyo, I think our best evidence comes from Day 1 and Day 2 votes. We got mafia on both days. Day 1 the wagons were Jamiet (lynched and flipped town), ND (turned out to be a VT), and Balki (received a town-aligned role PM). Jamiet was at only one vote for most of the day, but he received a large set...

Yoyoyozo wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 06, 2018 4:50 pm

A hero hath returnest.

Welcome Yoyo! Would you please let us know who has access to the mafia QT?

I don't want to come off that I'm against you as a person, I'm not at all, I just really really think you're scum I think that you decided you wanted to read me as scum before you had evidence. And you've just been trying to put everything you see in the "that proves Balki is scum" rhetorical box e...

Thanks balki, and thank you for answering those questions. I don't want to come off that I'm against you as a person, I'm not at all, I just really really think you're scum, respect to you for fooling people so well. I can see why brain said you were good as scum, you even had me second guessing my...

So what else? Why else am I scum? It seems like your Balki read is based on: (1) A false interpretation of my interaction with DemonRHK -- I said I found him sincere and townie, and you're saying I'm scum for that because I was trying to set up a Demon lynch? (2) Your suggestion that it was inconsis...

I'll also note: I feel a little bad about beating the lynch MLQ drum all game in your first game here. I think you're a strong player, and I hope you play again here. I'd love to see how you play as Town.

Huh, thought more would have happened today. No one else scum reads balki huh? It seems so painfully obvious to me, that makes me sad. I gave balki 8 points to respond to, he responded to 2 of them and they were ones he already talked about. Then he literally just started spouting "fake news" and "...

Yeah, but Foxy Knoxy wants to pin a rose on your nose for my effing insight! I want that damn rose on my nose.

You guys cannot rely on the peterbot for vote analysis in the final hour of the day. And it's not that hard to go read the actual pages of the thread to see it all in context. This is very important.

Also, considering all these people want to scumread reedeer seems lazy considering it took me five seconds to look at the d1 vote and nobody mentioned that once. seems like scum trying to find an easy lurker mislynch. I don't like it. Good catch, Tom. When I had considered his D1 votes, I had misre...

Also, considering all these people want to scumread reedeer seems lazy considering it took me five seconds to look at the d1 vote and nobody mentioned that once. seems like scum trying to find an easy lurker mislynch. I don't like it. Excuse me? Nobody mentioned it once? *Clears throat: Balki on Ni...