<lists of "bins"> So after N1, we could sort everyone by the response they receive and identify the roleblockers and use N2 to sort the players obscured by the roleblockers and identify the mailman, then we should have a good idea what bins the mafia are in. With the additional information we get f...

Bob, you made a couple statements that suggested you town-read lfischl (pasted below). Why did you vote for lfischl? Out of everybody in the game, I feel like fisch is most likely to provide an interesting response to being voted. Looking through his posts... not really. He notably didn't get very ...

I'm a little conflicted because Frog is new (or just "new"?) and I really do think it's nice to leave them in for at least one day. Let's try to find pairings and then vote for Frog's pair. Perhaps? Okay I don't like this post. Why would you ever try to find a pair just to avoid killing someone you...

I said 1 scum My point is that you just can’t know. Unless you’re mafia. If we take your guess as fact, then we could just as easily miss a second mafia on your wagon. Or if you are correct and we ignore it, we might miss a mafia on your wagon. My point is that this comment is useless and doesn’t h...

Frogsterking wrote: ↑

Sun Jan 21, 2024 5:52 am

Probably 1 scum on my wagon

This is a classic. I like saying there's at least 2 scum on my wagon when I'm up for D1 kill. I'm usually wrong.

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Sun Jan 21, 2024 4:53 am

BunnyGo seems to immediately read every post, if not for the sweetandcool joke, I would suspect he managed to set up a bot.

He also made his activity status visible once I called him out on it. He's definitely keeping up.

I like what I've seen from foodcoats so far. I'm not getting the kind of fun!kak vibes I hope for with him in the game. Jamie-brain argument reads like a classic case of Jamie-brain blowing each other up. Makes me think they're probably not both mafia. Can you elaborate on both parts of this? It's ...

Following on from my previous post, Kak seems intent on getting us as little info as possible... Do you think that Kakorroto mentioning he considered a No Kill, and removing his end vote, is scum indicative? Inherently no. But combined with wanting to kill lukers I don't like. His reads list is als...

But for real, next day we should each vote the person next in line on the player list and then ask Monarch what the vote count is so we can figure out who the lobbyist targeted and thus we can determine that the person targeted is not the Lobbyist. It isn’t much information, but it should help us o...

A Wienerdog. I suppose in Austrian the answer would be Wienerhund, but then the joke doesn't quite make sense. I can't say I laughed too much about that, but the joke kinda makes sense, though there are a lot of people who wouldn't equalize Wien with Austria, at least here. Also, what you call Wien...

@Kak I just thought of a joke during my morning walk: What do you call an Austrian dog? I'm trying to think, but nothing special comes to mind. Neither in german or english, nothing related to snow or mountains or a city name (bare 'Wien' maybe, but I fail to get a good pun myself). I hope it's not...

Is Jamie being more combative than usual or something? no its part of his game as both alignments is that if he doesnt make you waste tons of time arguing nuances with him or pedantry - then he will get accused of being too off this game. so he does it as scum to look like his town game and he does...

Frogsterking wrote: ↑

Sat Jan 20, 2024 10:08 pm

Chaqa is just so antitown that it becomes town...right??

No, that's just chaqa.

im leaning jamie scum for some of his other weird insistent stances that this game has no VTs for example. where is pretty obvious that on day 1; no one is actually arguing there are vts; rather everyone is effectively equal and a vt in having a lack of knowledge about role. He seems to just keep w...

I like what I've seen from foodcoats so far. I'm not getting the kind of fun!kak vibes I hope for with him in the game. Jamie-brain argument reads like a classic case of Jamie-brain blowing each other up. Makes me think they're probably not both mafia.

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Sat Jan 20, 2024 6:59 pm

sweetandcool wrote: ↑

Sat Jan 20, 2024 6:55 pm

##VOTE Jamiet

This is a serious vote.

Feels like they are trying extra hard to get into fights. Presumably to look town and clog up the thread with nonsense.

Do you think I am scum with BunnyGo, and that I am therefore bussing him?

What on earth kind of question is this?

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Sat Jan 20, 2024 6:26 pm

I do think lfischl is scum however.

##Vote lfischl

This vote seems worth noting. Not sure what for yet.

What is your opinion of what I am suggesting? Same as every other game bozo. Except this time it may be even more uncalled for than normal. I thought you helped come up with the idea for this game. Why do you think in a game where every player is a PR that we should not try to use that to our advan...

/snip I feel like I have played with players similar to you before and I think you are +town here. I don't expect you to say anything really telling in response to being questioned. I'm a little curious though about who you have experience with in the player list and if you have any solid meta read...

It seems to me that we could match up everyone with a role or get it down to a 50/50 with a mafia counterpart by N3 if we coordinate our night targets. Aaaand the mechs talk has arrived, right on cue. What is your opinion of what I am suggesting? Same as every other game bozo. Except this time it m...