Official vote count on pg31 (EOD1):
Brainbomb: 6 votes (DammmmDaniel, Peterlund, Hellenic Riot, Chaqa, Xorxes, Floodgates)
VashtaNeurotic: 2 votes (Vecna, Floodgates)
Hellenic Riot: 1 vote (Teacon)
DammmmDaniel: 5 votes (goldfinger0303, Demon RHK, ND, Ikaneko, Vashta Neurotic)
DemonRHK: 2 votes (Deathllama8, Brainbomb)
Ogion: 1 vote (MoscowFleet)
Floodgates: 1 vote (Maniac)
Ikaneko: 4 votes (TrPrado, Ogion, Bo_Sox, DeathLlama8)
-Goldfinger0303 jumps onto Ikaneko to save BB, then flips back off onto Daniel/reedeer
-DemonRHK votes Ikaneko (also to save BB)
-Vecna, BB, Goldfinger, ND all vote Ikaneko (four votes in five posts, the fifth being a vote update)
-Xorxes and Vashta vote Ikaneko, thus lynching him
Discounting those who voted Ikaneko after he took the lead, TrPrado, Ogion, Bo_sox, DeathLlama, DemonRHK, Vecna, BB, Goldfinger, and ND voted Ikaneko, with the “core” drivers of this lynch being TrPrado, Bo, and Ogion.
EOD2: With one hour to go, DemonRHK is the only vote on Floodgates. BB, Chaqa, and Vash all jump on the wagon close to each other with roughly fifty minutes remaining, and RHK/Chaqa begin to push for Floodgates’ lynch. Prado puts in a vote with half an hour left but switches to Chaqa. Bo notes he thinks Floodgates is townie, with massive postdump to accompany, but switches onto Floodgates on the top of pg70 (as does Prado). The vote was rather close, so all of the Floodgates votes are legitimate (unlike many of the “ties are bad” jumpers onto Ikaneko at EOD1).
That being said, strong townreads I have based just off of EOD analysis are TrPrado, Vash, Demon, Bo_sox, BB, Chaqa in roughly descending order of towniness.
I wholeheartedly trust Teacon7’s claim and manually checked all of his crumbs. Not only are they all legitimate, but one of them (the pg60 one) is towards end of day. If Teacon is fake-claiming scum, I seriously doubt he’d think “oh, it’s end of day! Time to drop crumbs instead of focusing on trying not to get my partners killed!” I trust Peter’s claim considerably less, but probably wouldn’t lynch him unless something new comes up.
That leaves ND, Goldfinger, HR, Vecna, Maniac, Reedeer, and Ogion.
ND is a slight scumread for me. He’s been rather quiet all game, yet I found this post from him on pg42: “How do you not have time to read someone's posts Chaqa? Reading is a crucial element in this game” and to Maniac on pg56: “@Maniac: So you haven't read the thread?” (I seriously doubt ND has been reading the entire thread, which is atypical for him, and if he is than he’s probably scum just based on not saying anything.) On pg46, he says “Can anyone tell me if they think my point about Peterlund is valid from my reads list? Pretty sure I caught him in a fake claim” which is...not ND-like. However, it should be noted that he broke the Brainbomb-Ikaneko tie on day one, which is a point in his favor. If he’s scum that does partially incriminate Chaqa for interactions between them that I’ll compile soon (while Chaqa is still a townread for now, I highly doubt that the majority of a scumteam that has seemed very scattered and disorganized so far would all link themselves to the same person).
--CAUTION: EVERYTHING AFTER THIS IS BASED ON GUT FEEL BECAUSE I’M NEARLY OUT OF TIME, I WILL REREAD THOSE LISTED BELOW AND TRY TO FORM OPINIONS LATER--
I feel like Peterlund could be a vanilla townie, but this grows less and less likely as he continues to not retract. @Peterlund - please retract if you’re not inventor. If you’re town, having you muddle up our PR situation once more people claim outweighs whatever benefits having you in your current position does. If you’re scum, you can put yourself out of your misery.
I don’t think HR or Goldfinger would’ve committed the N1 nightkill, so they get slight town reads right now, but tbh I haven’t read them too closely. Vecna and Maniac would be the type to try that, so the N1 kill doesn’t make them townier. Reedeer, for obvious reasons, is null right now. I could see Ogion being scum but would need to reread
kbai
)
Why someone can left a diplomacy game?
)
)