Even if you're town, you're not gonna die tonight.
Since I'm locked out of my fucking room and only have my phone, my reads are gonna be short and sweet -
Scum:
Maniac - coached D1, made no valuable contribution and lurked. Didn't claim he was busy until pressured and didn't give any sort of specifics at all even though town Maniac has gone out of his way to get full-blown alibis in the past. If he were town, he would do that. Going into D2, he hedged his reads and lied about guak's tendencies as mafia. He has been my top scumread and will stay there until he convinces me otherwise.
Espi - he has been saved twice in favor of the investigator and a VT. The former was led by a VT but more than likely participated in heavily by mafia, though I agree with those who have said that it is possible at least one mafia wasn't on the ND wagon. That said, I don't see that alone as reason to SR guak. On D2, Espi was saved again late in favor of Jeff. Espi has also blindly followed a couple of players, myself included, and buddied hard on a number of occasions. I wouldn't be shocked if he stole the limelight again on D3 so that his partners can redirect the lynch again.
Slight scum -
Wjessop - I do not see any rhyme or reason to wjessop's play at the end of day 1 when it came to killing ND. I see him following ghug, whose case was flimsy and based largely on his gut, not on concrete evidence. I can also see him killing ghug thinking that he would be the first to catch on to the EOD1 charade - of all the people to feel threatened by ghug, wjessop is up in the top group along with Maniac. Beyond this, wjessop has blamed the lynched player on both days rather than blaming himself for helping mislynch them in an effort to justify his own play. He has ignored this point this far as far as I recall.
Null -
Guak - I don't know why he considers it acceptable to lurk like he does. If he is town, he is hurting us. I will consider him my top scum-lurker candidate on D3 if he doesn't come out and play because of the people lurking, he knows how to lurk best and he knows when, as town, he needs to start showing up like he has when he lurked as town in the past.
Vecna - I haven't seen much of him at all. I don't know whether he never really got into the game or if he is distracted by the ins and outs of the night chat. For whatever reason, I feel like his presence is less during the night than during the day.
Slight town -
Yoyo - I have reason to scumread him and townread him. He softed cop, but we already saw one VT do that. He might have bussed Maniac, but that theory only holds if Maniac were scum. He promised a case on Maniac and also claims to have created a vote tracker, though he hasn't shared it yet. He has been fairly active in chunks - about as active as I have been - and I hope to see more consistency on D3. For now, I don't expect him to be a lynch candidate.
DL - I don't think he is cleared by any means for pointing out meme's soft since meme flipped town. However, I think that his reaction to ND's cop claim is a fairly safe towntell. I don't expect mafia to take the chance of openly denying a cop claim like ND's at the end of the day, knowing the lynch is still likely to go through. Mafia would simply use their NK and keep quiet about it given the no-doc setup.
I hope every remaining player posts reads by the EON. We need all the help we can get.