Ahhh, old man Chaqa reminiscing on the good ol days.
I'm honored to be mentioned alongside Putin and CM (and more importantly, opposite the puke of the forum), but I really don't think a whole lot about what Putin, CM, and myself did on the forum has changed. If Putin wanted to be here and say that invading Ukraine was not an invasion of a sovereign nation, he could still do that. If CM wanted to ask why the nth girl of the month does or does not like him and how he should deal with it, he could still do that. If I wanted to post random articles about nothing important that the rest of you didn't really care about in a meaningless quest for approval, I could still do that. It doesn't happen anymore because Putin and CM have moved on to greener pastures and I ... well, I'm still here, being stupid and annoying like always.
The "wild personalities" you mention are a *little bit* too wild and made a constant show out of using the anonymity of a computer screen to let a bunch of vile, psychotic thoughts that they could never get away with in their regular lives. They weren't even banned exclusively because of their intolerable forum presence either, but really - do you know how many times Holocaust jokes are funny? How about how many times you have to be threatened by some douchebag claiming to have a regimen of US Marines at his command whenever he wants? Uh, none. You can interact with strangers on the internet without feeling like you have to flex muscle we all know you don't have. None of that was playful badgering. It was just dumb and if I hadn't loved playing Diplomacy so much that I played 400 games in a year and a half before I ever really interacted with the forum at all, it would have scared me away too.
Some of you don't get the whole "welcoming home page" thing, and that's cool, we can talk about how that helps or hurts us all day long, but ever since the laissez-faire days of 2012, that's the direction that we've been moving. We have 80,000 registered users and I see no reason why we couldn't strive for 80,000 more. We get new users from across the planet in school groups, social clubs, or just looking for a site that interests them, and "wild personalities" is not a helpful recruiting tool. People don't stay on a site or even interact with a forum that looks more like the mind of a serial killer on bath salts than a place of civil discourse among a bunch of strangers who might have some "wild" tendencies care about the future of their site enough that they're willing to internalize thoughts that they know they shouldn't share.