Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 189 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
kevindolan (144 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
"by convoy", "by land"?
Is there a reason moving an army to an adjacent coastal territory I get the option to go "by convoy" or "by land"? Is there a good reason one would convoy a unit between adjacent territories?
15 replies
Open
RBerenguel (334 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
23 buy in, WTA, 3 places left
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7697
2 replies
Open
Ballack (2571 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
join the first game in 2009
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7731 16 hours and points.
5 replies
Open
Gobbledydook (1389 D(B))
31 Dec 08 UTC
Replacement for Austria needed
http://www.phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7659
A game for Australians, all three SC's intact, only Spring 1902.
Any Australians (or even Earthlings) join and put Austria-Hungary back to order!
1 reply
Open
Gobbledydook (1389 D(B))
31 Dec 08 UTC
Happy new year!
Happy new year!!!

It's new year in Hong Kong now!
2 replies
Open
airborne (154 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
Rule One...Don't get shot
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7735
0 replies
Open
greydawn (115 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
AFK Player
We just started a game (League of Nations) and it is Autumn 1901. While I realize that Austria might have accidentally missed his turn, he has also done no correspondence at all, leaving me to wonder if he's really going to play at all.

9 replies
Open
cwfilson (194 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
Creating a Tie or Shared Victory
How do you do it?
2 replies
Open
mdruskin (2062 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
Phpdiplomacy game stats - best country to play
I ran a quick script out of curiosity to see which countries win the most on phpdiplomacy. Just got the "finished games" pages and parsed the HTML. Turkey turns out to be the best country! Full stats below the fold.
16 replies
Open
Gobbledydook (1389 D(B))
30 Dec 08 UTC
The 300 point buy in PPSC.
Game is open now.
Game phase: 48 hours.
Buy-in: 300.
All except Zxylon and multi-accounters are welcome!
15 replies
Open
jwalters93 (288 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
WTA games
how does one create a WTA game?
6 replies
Open
Major Malfunction (100 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
Vanishing Point(s)
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7729

Need 5 more for 100pt game.
0 replies
Open
Major Malfunction (100 D)
31 Dec 08 UTC
New Game - Any takers?
So i'm looking to round up some players for my first game via phpDiplomacy.net

I'd like it to be a good game and am happy to consider any timelimit or pot that I can afford. Don't leave me hanging people...
8 replies
Open
Pandarsenic (1485 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
So we should totally have an Open Press Diplomacy Game
I just completed my first one - it was quite fun. I'd like to play another - preferably without people who CD/NMR.
14 replies
Open
Jacob (2466 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Other Games
Outside of Diplomacy what are your favorite boardgames? Try to limit yourself to two or three if you can.
Page 1 of 3
FirstPreviousNextLast
 
Jacob (2466 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
My number one is still Settlers of Catan. Outside of that I enjoy Vegas Showdown and Hammer of the Scots quite a bit.

Also, I'm getting Here I Stand for Christmas and I have high expectations for it!!
figlesquidge (2131 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Cluedo, Chess and Scrabble
Although its not a board game, connect-4 is wonderfully addictive!
Pandarsenic (1485 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
I want to try Settlers of Catan.

Chess (especially variants like Penultima) and Chinese Chess are probably my other favorites.
Samo (534 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Camelot, Shatranj, Morabaraba.
Dexter.Morgan (135 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
A wonderful game called "Conquest" by the late Donald Benge (died in 2007 thanks to a drunk driver). It was self-published and it's future is uncertain - but if you can get a copy it's worth it. One website describes it as follows:
"Conquest was designed to be a diceless wargame. Set in ancient times, Conquest has players utilizing troops, cavalry, chariots, elephants and ships to try to capture their opponents' fortifications or occupy the "quest" locations. The map is designed for point-to-point movement, and play hinges on a pool of action points that each side uses to move its different units. Conquest comes in two versions, one designed for four players and one designed exclusively for two."
Link: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/game/67
It's got plenty of complexity to always be new and fresh - and yet it's rules are simple and a game can be played in a couple of hours.

I also play chess. Connect-4 is pretty good, figlesquidge - check out "Four Score" - a 3-D version of it. Very good game.
Dexter.Morgan (135 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Sorry - "Score Four" is the correct name, not Four Score:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Score_Four
Dexter.Morgan (135 D)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Here's a very good description with pictures of Conquest... it's in German - but Babelfish works pretty well in translating it.
http://www.grand-conquest.de/
Draugnar (0 DX)
25 Dec 08 UTC
Axis & Allies (all versions), Feudal (AH Bookshelf Games), and virtually any of the Mayfair and European games. I'm into boardgaming...
wangster mcnasty (0 DX)
26 Dec 08 UTC
settlers of catan = win
axis and allies D Day
sanctuary
ValHelmethead (100 D)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Axis and Allies. Me and a friend from college still get together every new and then to waste a day playing a major victory.

Stratego: Just good fun.

Chess: I'm just good enough to realize how bad I actually am.
Kevin (0 DX)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Chess
Settlers of Catan
Puerto Rico
Harangutan (100 D)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Puerto Rico, LAWL, awesome inside jokes there.
Setttlers of Catan
Monopoly
wee_alex (1330 D)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Twilight Struggle
Third World War (GDW)
Twilight Imperium
RBerenguel (334 D)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Go
Hex
Streetsoccer (go to www.littlegolem.net if you want more information about this)
lazysummer8484 (0 DX)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Chess - I've been playing for 6 years
Monopoly
Risk
stratagos (3269 D(S))
27 Dec 08 UTC
Settlers and Carcassone are pretty keen. Panda - try this site for an online version of the former: http://games.asobrain.com/

My wife visits the game shop on a regular basis, so #3 is constantly shifting ;)
Invictus (240 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
I always liked Don't Wake Daddy.
positron (1160 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
Kingmaker. Haven't played in years. I miss games with 40 pages of legalese masquerading as a rule book. I miss having the time to play them even more.
kestasjk (95 DMod(P))
27 Dec 08 UTC
Is poker a board game?

I also like all the standard ones; risk, monopoly, chess, etc
Draugnar (0 DX)
27 Dec 08 UTC
Kestas! A fellow poker player! Do you play tourny or cash or both? I'm a cash player. I play once or twice a month to supplement my income and take some money from the fish at the Grand Victoria in Rising Sun, IN.
Go is, in my view, possibly the finest two player game without a luck element involved.

It's considerably more challenging than chess, and i'm not sure there's a game which is more genuinely analagous to human conflict.
boolean (288 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
How is Go amy more analagous to human conflict than other games? Just by virtue of being an abstract game about controlling territory?
flashman (2274 D(G))
27 Dec 08 UTC
And how is it 'considerably more challenging than chess'?




maintgallant (100 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
Serenissima

also:

Chess
Catan
Axis & Allies
Race for the Galaxy

(of course, saying that go is better than chess is up for debate as they feature differing styles of thought)
flashman (2274 D(G))
27 Dec 08 UTC
He didn't say Go was better than Chess, but that it was 'considerably more challenging', which although presented as a fact is more of a value judgement.
Ok, maybe I should have said "Considerably more challenging to compute". There is no real prospect of developing a computer programme which can come close to defeating top Go players any time soon. They've had Chess on the ropes for a while now.

I would argue that more challenging to compute can safely be shortened to more challenging, as the only element of the two games which is not computational is playing the pieces.

As for the human conflict thing...

It's pretty difficult to write a pithy couple of lines to entirely substantiate the view that I hold, which I shared more with the intention of prompting people to look into the game than to prompt requests that I justify my stated view.

I guess a simple way of putting it, is that I cannot think of a single argument, fist fight or full blown war, which I cannot see
reflected in instances that occur on the Go board.

This isn't an invitation for people to attack my opinions, though I doubt i'd be as keen on Diplomacy as i've become if it bothered me when they do ; )

Perhaps, Chess fans, or those who think other games are more like real conflict, might like to explain their position rather than just challenging mine?

Happy gaming folks.

spyman (424 D(G))
27 Dec 08 UTC
According to wikipedia there are are a number of reasons that make Go more challenging to program than Chess, such a larger board size (19 by 19 instead of 8 by 8) and more options for the first move (55 moves for Go, and only 20 for Chess). There were a number of of other reasons listed too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Go
As far as which game is more challenging, I think that would depend on who you were playing.
spyman (424 D(G))
27 Dec 08 UTC
I don't really know what I am talking about here, but I think that programming a computer to play Diplomacy against high level human players would be far more difficult than Chess or Go - way further into the realm of science fiction.
RBerenguel (334 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
I have played amateur chess and go, and left chess because I felt it was too arbitrary. It felt like a game with... well, weird rules, weird pieces, and so on. Also you depended a lot on your opening knowledge, after a certain level, and I didn't felt like learning a lot of that.

When I learned about go.. well, it's different. It's rules feel more natural. I don't think it maps human conflict better than chess (none of them does it pretty well) but the overall feeling of the game is better (for me). For the programming part, Go has a lot of intuition in it, some things you (you or the best players!) just know are right, but couldn't really explain why should be so, program-wise. Strategy is hugely deeper than in chess (the bigger board accounts for a large part of it, of course), and that's the stronger point against computerized players.
RBerenguel (334 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
Spyman, Diplomacy would be a Turing test for a computer player, and doesn't fit the "game" part, but the language processing and reasoning part.

Page 1 of 3
FirstPreviousNextLast
 

63 replies
RBerenguel (334 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
New game (unanounced by creator)
I just joined it: "In Soviet Russia......", http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7703 25 buy-in PPSC, 65 hours phase (that's it!)
1 reply
Open
DingleberryJones (4469 D(B))
24 Dec 08 UTC
Gunboat with a diary
Message follows
56 replies
Open
diplomat1824 (0 DX)
29 Dec 08 UTC
Theory
I have a theory. I think that my critics secretly enjoy my presence, and would be sad if I left phpDiplomacy. Please respond.
27 replies
Open
Jacob (2466 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
Another Thread about PPSC vs WTA
The more I play on this site the more I wish I could get more WTA games going. I just really don't feel like PPSC games provide the Dip experience that is intended by the game.

They are still good practice, but WTA games are where its at in my opinion. Sure wish it was easier to get people to join them...
7 replies
Open
Sicarius (673 D)
29 Dec 08 UTC
nice 700 point game
PPSC
100pt buy in
slow phases as top avoid cd's and encourage diplomacy
3 replies
Open
Jacob (2466 D)
29 Dec 08 UTC
New Game: On Earth is Not His Equal
165 point buy-in
WTA
48 hour phases
6 replies
Open
xcurlyxfries (0 DX)
30 Dec 08 UTC
I just wanna get this straight...
If I have 700 php points, and make 1 game WTA 700 buy in and lose, would I get all my points back?
6 replies
Open
saulberardo (2111 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
Join it for 30 points!!!!
hey people we need just more three players to complete the table, join now!
http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=7704

2 replies
Open
diplomat1824 (0 DX)
30 Dec 08 UTC
New game
Hosted by diplomat1824, this game is entitled "Tribute to diplomat1824"
7 replies
Open
1097 (181 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
Drawing
If you draw, I know the points are equally shared between all surviving players. Does this include Civil Disorder players?
3 replies
Open
Australian players
I want to find 6 other Australians to play an game just among fellow Australians
31 replies
Open
Jacob (2466 D)
26 Dec 08 UTC
Turning an enemy into an ally.
What are some successful approaches you have used? Obviously, these are very situation-dependent. Are there any principles that seem to be generally true in all or at least most situations?
25 replies
Open
S.P.A.O. (655 D)
27 Dec 08 UTC
Problems with order resolutions
game URL: http://phpdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=6965
game name; asd
several players, including myself, have had problems with order resolution in this game. We've started a vote to pause. is there anything we can do?
there's no point in playing if orders don't go through right.
6 replies
Open
ag7433 (927 D(S))
30 Dec 08 UTC
Beginner Game - The Price is Wrong, Bob!
PPSC - 50 hr phases for professionals and max diplomacy - 5pt to join

Experienced players welcome if they wear an educator hat.
1 reply
Open
SuperFlyDaddio (113 D)
30 Dec 08 UTC
The Price is Wrong, Bob
Come and join this new game.
0 replies
Open
Page 189 of 1419
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top