M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Bonatogether]

ok i see people didn't read my post

[Ezio]

I’m town. I was the wrong town, and I’m lucky I moved with two minutes.

Your move was irrelevant, and you're scum. You moved after the vote was already decided by Eden, and the rest of town.

I’m town, Ezio.

For me to be scum you have to believe I would declare ghug’s alignment despite my teammate being the necromancer. You have to believe MM ended on a town player every day except one time, me, her teammate.

I don't believe you're town. I don't believe any town with half a brain could look at yesterday and vote Bunny.

I do believe that MM ended on you, her teammate.

I seem to recall the day before you were the second place wagon that *barely* didn't flip.

I can guarantee that for your failure to vote Monarch today, you have doomed yourself to be a miskill.

[Bonatogether]

tonight bunny gets nked, hopefully food gives us more night chat things, we kill will, someone else gets nked, repeat

[Ezio]

ok i see people didn't read my post

I didn't really. I saw you made a case against aaro, and I wanted to spray you with water like a cat.
It's over.

[Bonatogether]

ok i see people didn't read my post

I didn't really. I saw you made a case against aaro, and I wanted to spray you with water like a cat.
It's over.

jesus fuck lmao that is not the post i'm talking about

[Bonatogether]

boooooring

can we skip to the next day?

[President Eden]

foodcoats, what do the dead think about this situation?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Yay

Good job guys i skill issued

Is there any chance we can hammer the day?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Yay

Good job guys i skill issued

Is there any chance we can hammer the day?

*end

*night

Typo tuesday

[aarodactyl]

@bona: You're honestly just reading me wrong. Like I've said to bunny, I think I've gotten called out in every game I've played on this site for not being as solve-y as people expect. I can find some instances of this if you really want, but to be honest, I don't think rehashing this discussion again is helpful for town, especially when we all agree Worcej and Will need to be voted out.

That said, I will eventually find those games to show you (especially since I think in one of them, you go after me for the same exact behavior) since at this rate, we're going to end up in with a me, you, and food final 3 or something.

Anyways, I get up at like 5:30am for my job these days, so I'm going to be going to bed pretty soon. I'll probably just check back in at the start of next phase to put in my vote.

##Call GM: If we hammer someone at the beginning of a day phase (let's say at an hour into it), will the night phase be 23 hours long or 47?

[President Eden]

ok misinterpreted what was happening with eden

can we not claim that everyone alive now, especially those on madmo, were provably online except for will and had the demonstrative capacity to just end the game, implying none are scum

Bunny was the only living player absent at EOD. So yes functionally it’s true that everyone who voted Monarch should be clear.

It’s just Will/worc/foodcoats here, let’s keep it real.

[foodcoats]

Your move was irrelevant, and you're scum. You moved after the vote was already decided by Eden, and the rest of town.

I’m town, Ezio.

For me to be scum you have to believe I would declare ghug’s alignment despite my teammate being the necromancer. You have to believe MM ended on a town player every day except one time, me, her teammate.

I don't believe you're town. I don't believe any town with half a brain could look at yesterday and vote Bunny.

I do believe that MM ended on you, her teammate.

I seem to recall the day before you were the second place wagon that *barely* didn't flip.

I can guarantee that for your failure to vote Monarch today, you have doomed yourself to be a miskill.

Well, I’ve explained why I played why I did. I’ve made the game more complicated and I regret that, but I will continue to try to help town read me correctly.

Here’s another consideration. If I was scum, who was only acting apathetic to the game but was in fact lurking in the wings looking for the win, why did I appear and vote with 10 full minutes to go rather than placing a vote with a few seconds to go (or using that situation to continue to claim ignorance)?

Similarly, given how the MM versus Bunny claims were indeed logically “solvable” - as in, the combination of evidence did actually make it technically correct to always kill MadMonarch - do you really think that in the active players yesterday, there was NO scum hedging?

[foodcoats]

foodcoats, what do the dead think about this situation?

As I said I quit the gravechat. I’ve rejoined in case Bunny dies and has information post-death.

However, you seem to think that I am lockscum, so why would it matter what I say the dead say?

[brainbomb]

##Call GM: If we hammer someone at the beginning of a day phase (let's say at an hour into it), will the night phase be 23 hours long or 47?

If a hammer happened as described above, the night would be 23 hours. however there would be a consultation with the mafia team to ensure a shorter than advertised night would be acceptable for their party. If it were 12 hours into a phase I would probably rule the night should be longer, but once again, this is all about what is reasonable for the team being forced to have a shorter amount of time to make decisions.

[Bonatogether]

tomorrow we zot will out of existence no matter what

[President Eden]

tomorrow we zot will out of existence no matter what

I don’t care that much, but I think I slightly prefer worc because I think y’all are more likely to stay on course and kill Will without me than worc

But if y’all pinky promise to get worc next then ok

[Bonatogether]

tomorrow we zot will out of existence no matter what

I don’t care that much, but I think I slightly prefer worc because I think y’all are more likely to stay on course and kill Will without me than worc

But if y’all pinky promise to get worc next then ok

i'm less convinced worcej is scum

[President Eden]

tomorrow we zot will out of existence no matter what

I don’t care that much, but I think I slightly prefer worc because I think y’all are more likely to stay on course and kill Will without me than worc

But if y’all pinky promise to get worc next then ok

i'm less convinced worcej is scum

that’s exactly why I want to kill him while I’m still alive to ensure it happens lol.

I don’t know if I trust y’all not to blow this :/

[Ezio]

I don’t care that much, but I think I slightly prefer worc because I think y’all are more likely to stay on course and kill Will without me than worc

But if y’all pinky promise to get worc next then ok

i'm less convinced worcej is scum

that’s exactly why I want to kill him while I’m still alive to ensure it happens lol.

I don’t know if I trust y’all not to blow this :/

I'm scared of these comments from Aaro and Bona scumreading each other and shit.
I'm worried Food is gonna convince them to flip.
FWIW, I'd vote we flip food tomorrow for exactly this reason...

[President Eden]

i'm less convinced worcej is scum

that’s exactly why I want to kill him while I’m still alive to ensure it happens lol.

I don’t know if I trust y’all not to blow this :/

I'm scared of these comments from Aaro and Bona scumreading each other and shit.
I'm worried Food is gonna convince them to flip.
FWIW, I'd vote we flip food tomorrow for exactly this reason...

Do you remember when food outed as Cleric?