WebMafia Olympics - Game #2 - Star Trek TNG: The Republic of Q [GAME THREAD]

[damo666]

Why is 3-2 preferable to 5-2?

[President Eden]

what in tarnation

Start figuring out how we can maintain control of the day kill on day 2.

I’m too angry-blind to see a solution to our problem.

sir yes sir

humble suggestion - don’t be mad at caught scum damo for making open scum power plays

[worcej]

Why is 3-2 preferable to 5-2?

Information.

You're intelligent enough to already know that answer dude.

[worcej]

what in tarnation

Start figuring out how we can maintain control of the day kill on day 2.

I’m too angry-blind to see a solution to our problem.

sir yes sir

humble suggestion - don’t be mad at caught scum damo for making open scum power plays

This is my last post of the night phase.

I need to step back - I am irrationally angry.

[damo666]

what in tarnation

Start figuring out how we can maintain control of the day kill on day 2.

I'm too angry-blind to see a solution to our problem.

During the night we quasi-vote to determine top 3 scum suspects. Everyone is only allowed to vote the top 2 survivors. Anyone breaking this rule gets auto voted by everyone else. That should work.

So everyone nominate their best guess at a scumpair.

Mine is Chaqa and Mrs Bomb.

[GlitterBomb]

Start figuring out how we can maintain control of the day kill on day 2.

I’m too angry-blind to see a solution to our problem.

sir yes sir

humble suggestion - don’t be mad at caught scum damo for making open scum power plays

This is my last post of the night phase.

I need to step back - I am irrationally angry.

I feel like you need a hug. That just happened so fast and against what I felt like was town’s agreed on or majority direction.

[President Eden]

Yea so as I teased a moment ago, damo’s play only makes sense from scum perspective IMO.

Being confident in your townreads is good enough reason to stop the triple kill, because you’re not actually depriving town of a town-directed kill by slowing things down to 2 kills instead of 3. But it’s not good enough reason to derail the double kill because it takes away our ability to safely double kill next turn and possibly engineers our demise if the mafia figure out how to force a double kill next phase.

I firmly believe town damo would have worked that out and chosen one of two townreads between Will and Flav to save. It’s just too much of a selfish hero play for town damo IMO. And it perfectly aligns with scum incentives if you’re already not long for this world.

Real questions to me are:
(1) should we not simply double kill tomorrow anyway despite the risk? I am that confident damo is scum here.
(2) does scum damo do that if his partner is also one of Flav or Will?

[Chaqa]

I’m also pretty annoyed at Damo.

Not like furious but more disappointed

[damo666]

sir yes sir

humble suggestion - don’t be mad at caught scum damo for making open scum power plays

This is my last post of the night phase.

I need to step back - I am irrationally angry.

I feel like you need a hug. That just happened so fast and against what I felt like was town’s agreed on or majority direction.

There are 2 live mafia as you well know.

Btw you didn't vote for any of the top 4 wagons. The only player not to do so.

[damo666]

I’m also pretty annoyed at Damo.

Not like furious but more disappointed

What about TFB's vote on lfischl?

[Chaqa]

I’m also pretty annoyed at Damo.

Not like furious but more disappointed

What about TFB's vote on lfischl?

I need to analyze the end of day a bit more.

But now we are at risk of mafia winning outright if they engineer a double kill tomorrow, and we will have the smallest possible amount of information to work with.

You’ve actually made one of the worst possible end of days happen

[GlitterBomb]

This is my last post of the night phase.

I need to step back - I am irrationally angry.

I feel like you need a hug. That just happened so fast and against what I felt like was town’s agreed on or majority direction.

There are 2 live mafia as you well know.

Btw you didn't vote for any of the top 4 wagons. The only player not to do so.

Ummm what? Top four wagons? Does that mean top four players that were getting the most votes?

Last I checked, Flav was in that category.

[damo666]

Yea so as I teased a moment ago, damo’s play only makes sense from scum perspective IMO.

Being confident in your townreads is good enough reason to stop the triple kill, because you’re not actually depriving town of a town-directed kill by slowing things down to 2 kills instead of 3. But it’s not good enough reason to derail the double kill because it takes away our ability to safely double kill next turn and possibly engineers our demise if the mafia figure out how to force a double kill next phase.

I firmly believe town damo would have worked that out and chosen one of two townreads between Will and Flav to save. It’s just too much of a selfish hero play for town damo IMO. And it perfectly aligns with scum incentives if you’re already not long for this world.

Real questions to me are:
(1) should we not simply double kill tomorrow anyway despite the risk? I am that confident damo is scum here.
(2) does scum damo do that if his partner is also one of Flav or Will?

Have you considered my proposal. We vote 2 and only 2 players tomorrow, anybody voting outside the chosen pair gets auto hammered.

[worcej]

I’m also pretty annoyed at Damo.

Not like furious but more disappointed

What about TFB's vote on lfischl?

Disconnected enough and put two messages of frustration into JT for the GT.

But in general, Boat made his votes with 2 minutes left and wanted to process 2 kills.

You intentionally waited until the last second and even admit to purposely taking the DK down to 1 kill because of TFB's vote allowing you that opportunity.

[President Eden]

Yea so as I teased a moment ago, damo’s play only makes sense from scum perspective IMO.

Being confident in your townreads is good enough reason to stop the triple kill, because you’re not actually depriving town of a town-directed kill by slowing things down to 2 kills instead of 3. But it’s not good enough reason to derail the double kill because it takes away our ability to safely double kill next turn and possibly engineers our demise if the mafia figure out how to force a double kill next phase.

I firmly believe town damo would have worked that out and chosen one of two townreads between Will and Flav to save. It’s just too much of a selfish hero play for town damo IMO. And it perfectly aligns with scum incentives if you’re already not long for this world.

Real questions to me are:
(1) should we not simply double kill tomorrow anyway despite the risk? I am that confident damo is scum here.
(2) does scum damo do that if his partner is also one of Flav or Will?

Have you considered my proposal. We vote 2 and only 2 players tomorrow, anybody voting outside the chosen pair gets auto hammered.

Are you volunteering to be one of them?

[damo666]

If lfischl had flipped scum would you all still be saying the same thing. Would you?

[worcej]

Yea so as I teased a moment ago, damo’s play only makes sense from scum perspective IMO.

Being confident in your townreads is good enough reason to stop the triple kill, because you’re not actually depriving town of a town-directed kill by slowing things down to 2 kills instead of 3. But it’s not good enough reason to derail the double kill because it takes away our ability to safely double kill next turn and possibly engineers our demise if the mafia figure out how to force a double kill next phase.

I firmly believe town damo would have worked that out and chosen one of two townreads between Will and Flav to save. It’s just too much of a selfish hero play for town damo IMO. And it perfectly aligns with scum incentives if you’re already not long for this world.

Real questions to me are:
(1) should we not simply double kill tomorrow anyway despite the risk? I am that confident damo is scum here.
(2) does scum damo do that if his partner is also one of Flav or Will?

To 1, I think we're forced into the double kill regardless because scum have an easy out to accomplish it.

To 2 - yeah, I think scum damo would do this to save Flav or Will because losing his partner here would be disastrous.

[President Eden]

If lfischl had flipped scum would you all still be saying the same thing. Would you?

Well no, because you would presumably not railroad your teammate and deprive yourself of two miskills.

lfischl being town is kind of a huge detail to brush over there lol.

[worcej]

If lfischl had flipped scum would you all still be saying the same thing. Would you?

Yes I would be saying the same thing, but with significantly less anger at you and more disappointed at your selfishness like what Chaqa is.

[damo666]

Yea so as I teased a moment ago, damo’s play only makes sense from scum perspective IMO.

Being confident in your townreads is good enough reason to stop the triple kill, because you’re not actually depriving town of a town-directed kill by slowing things down to 2 kills instead of 3. But it’s not good enough reason to derail the double kill because it takes away our ability to safely double kill next turn and possibly engineers our demise if the mafia figure out how to force a double kill next phase.

I firmly believe town damo would have worked that out and chosen one of two townreads between Will and Flav to save. It’s just too much of a selfish hero play for town damo IMO. And it perfectly aligns with scum incentives if you’re already not long for this world.

Real questions to me are:
(1) should we not simply double kill tomorrow anyway despite the risk? I am that confident damo is scum here.
(2) does scum damo do that if his partner is also one of Flav or Will?

Have you considered my proposal. We vote 2 and only 2 players tomorrow, anybody voting outside the chosen pair gets auto hammered.

Are you volunteering to be one of them?

If XYZ and I are the the top 2 survivors of a nightime scumvote I will vote XYZ at SOD and not make any other posts unless ABC voted other then me or XYZ and then I will hammer vote ABC.

In other words yes.

If me and a scum die it will be 3-1 going into D3. I'm happy with that.