M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[kgray]

Damn, every single person on the ghug wagon D1 was town - ghug mafia confirmed

Damn, every single person on the damo wagon D1 was town - damo mafia confirmed.

[damo666]

As per Bozo request

Damo
Durga
Tom
EMC
Ghug
Bozo
Kgray
Aaro
HR
Vecna
Chaqa
Yoyo
Maniac
Bona
Flum
Balki
Jamie

Also you, why aren't you scumreading me anymore?

Reads develop. You know this.

[Hellenic Riot]

I highly approve of Jamie using his stay of execution to brag, and tip my hat to him for doing so

[ghug]

Damn, every single person on the ghug wagon D1 was town - ghug mafia confirmed

Damn, every single person on the damo wagon D1 was town - damo mafia confirmed.

Damn, every single person on the ND wagon D1 was alive. ND dead confirmed.

[kgray]

The point you and Flum are making on my aaro post is probably a fair one. I tend to keep a ton of information in my head in these games, and the size both in posts and players makes it difficult. I'm also not gonna flip a read cause I like one post though.

What about my "compelling" argument that the way he was talking when Durga was about to reveal scum was unafraid and excited and towny? Does that make you reconsider your read?

[ghug]

As per Bozo request

Damo
Durga
Tom
EMC
Ghug
Bozo
Kgray
Aaro
HR
Vecna
Chaqa
Yoyo
Maniac
Bona
Flum
Balki
Jamie

Also you, why aren't you scumreading me anymore?

Reads develop. You know this.

That's not an answer.

[Fluminator]

Iirc the M60 quote was referring to a similar ploy by a different player in that game.

hmmmmmmmmmm

Did you go back and see if his story checks out?

I checked and had no idea what he could be talking about.

[Fluminator]

I'm not actually as terrible at this game as some of you like to think.

Ooh, what are you telling your team right now?

Are you having problems getting QuickTopic to work?

Yes, can you send me the link?

[kgray]

I mean, Kgray and aaro both seem pretty obvtown, so what are you trying to tell us Ghug

I didn't say there were necessarily multiple scum on each. Just that there were more somewhere on the two of them.

It's a reason I'm less confident on aaro than you. It's also a reason to suspect damo and celaph. It's also a reason to doubt me and kgray, though I won't be voting for either of us anytime soon.

Did you forget about the conversation we had D2 where I pointed out that aaro wasn't voting for ND at a time when teacon was in danger?

[Hellenic Riot]

Was that M60 quote not referring to people fakeclaiming guns, after the aborted M59?

[damo666]

I'm not actually as terrible at this game as some of you like to think.

Ooh, what are you telling your team right now?

Are you having problems getting QuickTopic to work?

This kinda townclears Flum imo

[ghug]

The point you and Flum are making on my aaro post is probably a fair one. I tend to keep a ton of information in my head in these games, and the size both in posts and players makes it difficult. I'm also not gonna flip a read cause I like one post though.

What about my "compelling" argument that the way he was talking when Durga was about to reveal scum was unafraid and excited and towny? Does that make you reconsider your read?

It's a point in his favor for sure. I think it's that case where we're more likely to townread a new player for competence though, so at best I think I'd swap him with the empty line above him in my reads

[Hellenic Riot]

Ooh, what are you telling your team right now?

Are you having problems getting QuickTopic to work?

This kinda townclears Flum imo

Townclearing people off the way they're interacting with Jamie during a night phase is pretty wack

[ghug]

I mean, Kgray and aaro both seem pretty obvtown, so what are you trying to tell us Ghug

I didn't say there were necessarily multiple scum on each. Just that there were more somewhere on the two of them.

It's a reason I'm less confident on aaro than you. It's also a reason to suspect damo and celaph. It's also a reason to doubt me and kgray, though I won't be voting for either of us anytime soon.

Did you forget about the conversation we had D2 where I pointed out that aaro wasn't voting for ND at a time when teacon was in danger?

No, I remember that, but I think scum are less likely to jump on a wagon to save a teammate if there are already scum on it, so being there at all somewhat increases odds of being scum.

[Fluminator]

Are you having problems getting QuickTopic to work?

This kinda townclears Flum imo

Townclearing people off the way they're interacting with Jamie during a night phase is pretty wack

You said you'd sheep his reads HR.
I'm a townclear now.

[e.m.c^42]

Bozo, do you want one from me? I've the gut read one, the wifom one, and the formulaic one, lol.

Can you release as many of your reads as you can? I'm pretty sure scum is going to assassinate durga and NK you tonight.

In all honesty, it seems much more likely that I won't get NK'd for awhile because my play in this game so far has been decent shitposting, trash actual content lol

but point, will throw together a collective post before EON.

[kgray]

I snipped out the reads that weren't relevant to the question

Probably Town
Balki


Seems Scummy to Me
HR
Bona

I get not having solid reasons, but could you explain a bit about your HR/damo scumreads? Why do you think each of them is scummy and do you think they're scum together?

Also I'm very interesting in your Balki read. Why is he probably town to you?

First of all, keep in mind that I'm incredibly new at making reads like this. I don't think I'm wrong, but there's definitely things that I haven't considered (for example, I didn't reread jamie, teacon, or bunny before making the list. I'll probably do that this morning).

HR: When I started making the list, I wrote down a summary for myself and then forgot to do it for almost everyone. However, it looks like I wrote "so many bad/incorrect takes". I'm looking back, and they started the game by making digs at damo and bunny. They then small talk, take a break from small talking to scumread ND and then go back to small talking. They then focus in on examining EMC and then settle on teacon while saying they're still down to get EMC out. They have a lot of EON1 takes that I don't really agree with. They scum read me a lot (which is fair considering my early play), but in terms of actually talking to new players, they only ever seem to reach out to Bona and not Celaph or me when they ask question. It's also weird to me that I'm their top scumread on day 3.

Damo: I did some math and it said Damo's math was sus. More seriously though, when I reread their posts, my impression is that they're talking a lot but not contributing very much. Also, I get making a math mistake, but they tripled down on it being both correct and relevant. They also voted maniac day 1 and kgray day 2 which means they weren't on a viable train on either day.

Balki: Before anyone looks back and says I scumread them earlier, that was because of their last minute change to teacon day 1. I think you mentioned that this isn't scum-indicative because late swings happen, and I agree now after seeing the brain wagon day 2. I'm now considering the switch to be a town move. I think they're putting in a serious effort to discuss alignment. In general, I feel like they're being pretty helpful. the comment about not advocating for the hammer so we could take our time to do rereads also seems town to me.

You should stop emphasizing that you're new at this. These are great takes, regardless of if you're right about all their alignments, and you're underselling yourself

One comment I have about HR is that being wrong isn't scummy. If he's got a lot of incorrect takes, you have to look at why he's got those reads and if they seem faked, because town are wrong all the time.

[Hellenic Riot]

Reads List:

HR
Durga
EMC
Tom

ghug
Aaro
Yoyo
damo

Vecna
Maniac
Celaph
kgray
Chaqa
Balki
Bozo

Bona

Flum
Jamie

[ghug]

Reads List:

HR
Durga
EMC
Tom

ghug
Aaro
Yoyo
damo

Vecna
Maniac
Celaph
kgray
Chaqa
Balki
Bozo

Bona

Flum
Jamie

Why is emc above Tom?

[Hellenic Riot]

Reads List:

HR
Durga
EMC
Tom

ghug
Aaro
Yoyo
damo

Vecna
Maniac
Celaph
kgray
Chaqa
Balki
Bozo

Bona

Flum
Jamie

Why is emc above Tom?

Because a part of me hopes that Vash just said that to troll the scumteam when he asked to sub out