M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[aarodactyl]

Hmmm. Maybe you’re correct since Flum was a lead wagon at around 40 minutes to go EOD1 but only Fishy was lead at 40 minutes to go EOD2.

This is why I think your PE vote is bad. It fits the narrative of a scum BM better. I also think town BM would be claiming asap due to all the other town PR claims

I’m voting food.

Oh my mistake. I didn’t notice you changed.

[brainbomb]

Before her ascension to godhood, the third Mystra was a woman named Midnight, who, along with several other individuals, including Kelemvor, played a large role during the Avatar Crisis, also known as the Time of Troubles

Yoyoyozo (5) Yoyoyozo TheMadMonarch Dousing sweetandcool worcej
sweetandcool (2) foodcoats President Eden
Dousing (2) Ezio aarodactyl
worcej (1) Foxcastle
Vecna (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
aarodactyl (1) Bonatogether
BunnyGo (1) Col7by
foodcoats (1) BunnyGo


Yoyoyozo is scheduled to die

[BunnyGo]

These 24 hour phases are hard on top of a huge game, and with my travel and family commitments over the last several days, there are large portions of the thread I've skimmed, and a couple dozen pages I just skipped. I'm now juggling game with work. I've probably also spent too much time defending myself rather than scumhunting. So overall, I feel like I'm barely keeping my head above water here.

So I'm going to shoot Flum now and see what happens. Better now, than trying to claim when I'm a wagon at 30 min out when there's no time. (Not that PR claims mean anything about alignment in this setup.) If he's scum, great. If he's not, well, I'll have earned LVP (and presumably the daykill), and that'll be that. Either way, it's better than limping along like I'm doing now.

The order is in.

(And I have work meetings now, so it'll be a bit before I'm back.)

Just saw this!

[BunnyGo]

This is why I think your PE vote is bad. It fits the narrative of a scum BM better. I also think town BM would be claiming asap due to all the other town PR claims

I’m voting food.

Oh my mistake. I didn’t notice you changed.

Join me!

[BunnyGo]

Archer Fox is town
Suicide Vest Vecna we’ll see in a few hrs (almost certainly town? this play would be silly as mafia)
D&W Duelist is town
Necromancer unknown
Battle Master unknown
Cleric foodcoats unknown
Two unknown roles

foodcoats probably town, Battle Master probably scum—town BM had better play day 1 but didn’t take it

Necromancer may genuinely be either alignment here, no reason to claim per se but they’re playing kinda risky if they are town. I think more likely scum but not strong feeling

Fox claimed archer?!

Huh? They did it before shooting flum. Did you miss it?

Yup. Just went back and ISOd Fox to find it.

Fell asleep before getting to that day last night.

[aarodactyl]

I’m voting food.

Oh my mistake. I didn’t notice you changed.

Join me!

I think voting out a known PR (that I personally townread) is a bad call.

[Ezio]

I doubt necromancer is town, personally.

Also I'm pretty confident BM is scum.

Why do you think scum would shoot ghug leading wagon?

Mafia love NK Ghug. He's a common fear kill, and I don't think he was actually under threat of being daykilled.

I think town would rather save their power, or use it on anyone *other* than Ghug.

[foodcoats]

Fox claimed archer?!

Huh? They did it before shooting flum. Did you miss it?

Yup. Just went back and ISOd Fox to find it.

Fell asleep before getting to that day last night.

Are you aware that Flum was scum?

[BunnyGo]

Oh my mistake. I didn’t notice you changed.

Join me!

I think voting out a known PR (that I personally townread) is a bad call.

A known PR with a bad power when we know there are 3 unknown scum PRs and only 2 unknown town PRs. And if necromancer (who shot the leading candidate) is town then only 1 unknown town PR.

[BunnyGo]

Huh? They did it before shooting flum. Did you miss it?

Yup. Just went back and ISOd Fox to find it.

Fell asleep before getting to that day last night.

Are you aware that Flum was scum?

Yes. That’s how I’d been assuming archer was town

[Col7by]

I think today we need a vote for someone who talks a lot to give us the most info. Although I’m not sure they are scum or not I think sweet and bunny may be two of the best options at this point. I am going to try this train again and see what happens. Open to hear thoughts.
##vote bunny

Colby, this is not a good vote. I can imagine a world where Bunny is scum, but this is just not a good option today.

You know who consistently tops the list for talking?

sweetandcool. Try that vote on.

Okay, I feel dumb for saying this. I'm not even 100% sweet is scum and I don't want to bully you into a vote.

But, you should look into the people you think are scum and find reasons they might be scum. Please don't just vote Bunny because he talks a lot. Find someone you think is doing something scummy, tell us, and then vote them.

I see I have a lot to catch up on. I documented a couple days ago why I thought bunny was scum a lot. Yoyo I would be good with but not sure it reveals as much

[BunnyGo]

Colby, this is not a good vote. I can imagine a world where Bunny is scum, but this is just not a good option today.

You know who consistently tops the list for talking?

sweetandcool. Try that vote on.

Okay, I feel dumb for saying this. I'm not even 100% sweet is scum and I don't want to bully you into a vote.

But, you should look into the people you think are scum and find reasons they might be scum. Please don't just vote Bunny because he talks a lot. Find someone you think is doing something scummy, tell us, and then vote them.

I see I have a lot to catch up on. I documented a couple days ago why I thought bunny was scum a lot. Yoyo I would be good with but not sure it reveals as much

You’re very wrong. You’ve gone down the wrong rabbit hole.

Reset your assumptions and try again.

[aarodactyl]

Join me!

I think voting out a known PR (that I personally townread) is a bad call.

A known PR with a bad power when we know there are 3 unknown scum PRs and only 2 unknown town PRs. And if necromancer (who shot the leading candidate) is town then only 1 unknown town PR.

So is it just a probability play? I think that at some point, we’ll need to flip food but I don’t think it’s necessary yet from a mechanics point of view.

[BunnyGo]

I think voting out a known PR (that I personally townread) is a bad call.

A known PR with a bad power when we know there are 3 unknown scum PRs and only 2 unknown town PRs. And if necromancer (who shot the leading candidate) is town then only 1 unknown town PR.

So is it just a probability play? I think that at some point, we’ll need to flip food but I don’t think it’s necessary yet from a mechanics point of view.

Probability plus look at my study session from last night. His VCA wasn’t great. Better than sweet, but not much. I think Vecna would do well to get us sweet or food. But food has the addition of probability.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

New vote count who dis

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Eryone hop on Vecna pls

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Or bunny too

[BunnyGo]

Eryone hop on Vecna pls

Are you caught up?!

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Eryone hop on Vecna pls

Are you caught up?!

Caught up on deez nuts

No

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Let me guess: cvecna got killed or something