MAFIA 83: HALLOWE'EN IN THE TOYSHOP - GAME THREAD

[rdrivera2005]

I am still some pages behind but decided to drop some thoughts now that I have some time.

I have townleans on Kak and Spirit. Kak is a tone thing and Spirit look legit hunting, I like his posts. I think I can add Macca here too. They look town

I don't like the Sweet wagon, can't see any real reason to vote him and Darg is on my suspect list (sorry Darg, but I can't follow your logic).

HB could be scum here, his posts just look too fluffy at some points.

The others I just don't have any impressions worth of mentioning.

So different thought processes and different reasoning = scum.

Not necessarily, each one usually have a different thought process. But I usually follow your logic and this game I can't. This turn a red flag to me.

[damo666]

Nope nope nope nope

##Vote rdr

No!

[damo666]

I need to go to my neighbors’ sister-in-laws’ nieces’ Quinceanera so leave me alone

Unnecessarily rude

[damo666]

##vote darg

[worcej]

Both ND and Will seem town.

Suspicious of Karrotcake's disappearance.

Could join ghig on worcej once he corrects his vote.

Bona is another possibility.

Probably go with one of those 3 or Demon unless something startling happens.

Basically this is a typical day 1 and I'm largely null on most players.

I like how I am universally a D1 kill for you damo lol

[Bonatogether]

i forgor worcestershire was here

[worcej]

i forgor worcestershire was here

I am forgettable this game

[worcej]

My baseline opinions are still unchanged. Keeping my vote where it is for now.

[Bonatogether]

worchester tell me your thoughts so when nd asks me for mine i can say something

[DemonRHK]

I need to go to my neighbors’ sister-in-laws’ nieces’ Quinceanera so leave me alone

Unnecessarily rude

Well no crap, it’s me.

But seriously, kak wanting the open box of dog poo over the mystery back then immediately hedging is so lazy. Like he couldn’t be bothered to hunt for three reads

[worcej]

worchester tell me your thoughts so when nd asks me for mine i can say something

Louisiana is beautiful and I miss the south. This wedding weekend has been a blast.

Oh? You wanted game thoughts:

1. ghug is D1-ghuging, which is normal. If it continues on D3, kill him then.
2. damo has done his low effort give 3 names he'd be willing to kill without committing much other than disagreeing with other people's opinions - this is NAI for now.
3. ND is fine and came off as actively pursuing a lead - Will is defensive and I think it's a TvT situation.
4. I don't see the reasoning for darg. But I'm not looking hard enough and no one has put it on a platter.
5. Sweet is the only one to put something on a platter that I saw and it's weak. I don't really like it and feel it's more scummy for him to low-effort kill HB off.
6. HB just doesn't strike me as scum with what I was able to read.

[sweetandcool]

@ kak
Your vote seems random and maybe even spurious.
Admittedly, you are not pushing the wagon, but 'darg didn't do any amazing things the first few hours' is ridiculous. Who did in the first few hours?

This is a plop vote, buddy.

Find a better place.

I am staying on sweet. It has to do with that business about brain's meta analysis. Part of it is that sweet jumped on brain about it, but also wrote, in effect, that he didn't mind it so much. I think he was trying to pull votes (now or later) onto brain, setting up a misskill.

It IS a tinfoil hat. But tinfoil hat is my costume this Hallowe'en.

This is so interesting. I'm flattered that you think this highly of my abilities. I don't think I would have thought to do that as Mafia. I'll have to keep that in mind.

But I think your impression that I jumped on brainbomb for it is wrong. It was just one specific case that we ended up arguing about. If anything, it could be an attempt to discredit brainbomb's inevitable future push on me (if I were Mafia).

[sweetandcool]

I need to go to my neighbors’ sister-in-laws’ nieces’ Quinceanera so leave me alone

Unnecessarily rude

Well no crap, it’s me.

But seriously, kak wanting the open box of dog poo over the mystery back then immediately hedging is so lazy. Like he couldn’t be bothered to hunt for three reads

I am confused. Then why are you voting rdr and not Kak?

[DemonRHK]

Unnecessarily rude

Well no crap, it’s me.

But seriously, kak wanting the open box of dog poo over the mystery back then immediately hedging is so lazy. Like he couldn’t be bothered to hunt for three reads

I am confused. Then why are you voting rdr and not Kak?

Because there is a chance that Kak really is just lazy. And I’d rather solve rdr now

[Bonatogether]

worchester tell me your thoughts so when nd asks me for mine i can say something

Louisiana is beautiful and I miss the south. This wedding weekend has been a blast.

Oh? You wanted game thoughts:

1. ghug is D1-ghuging, which is normal. If it continues on D3, kill him then.
2. damo has done his low effort give 3 names he'd be willing to kill without committing much other than disagreeing with other people's opinions - this is NAI for now.
3. ND is fine and came off as actively pursuing a lead - Will is defensive and I think it's a TvT situation.
4. I don't see the reasoning for darg. But I'm not looking hard enough and no one has put it on a platter.
5. Sweet is the only one to put something on a platter that I saw and it's weak. I don't really like it and feel it's more scummy for him to low-effort kill HB off.
6. HB just doesn't strike me as scum with what I was able to read.

thanks worchester

[sweetandcool]

This is a tough D1, I forgot how much more difficult it is with so many players.

I wanted to reassess but I'm not going to have time. I'm not sure if I'll even make EoD.

I'm not 100% happy with my vote on Ham. His scummy post pinged me big time, but pretty much everything he posted after that felt different than what I would expect from him as scum.

I've been trying to come up with a better vote, but I keep thinking people are town or null. I was worried about Will vs. ND, but that seems legitimately like T v T (please untunnel ND). Brainbomb has been a bit funky, but he was funky in the same way last game as Town, so I'm not going to throw a vote at him for just that.

Nobody else has really given me a distinct impression. The Dargorygel wagon doesn't make sense to me. He's just null to me so far.

[sweetandcool]

Well no crap, it’s me.

But seriously, kak wanting the open box of dog poo over the mystery back then immediately hedging is so lazy. Like he couldn’t be bothered to hunt for three reads

I am confused. Then why are you voting rdr and not Kak?

Because there is a chance that Kak really is just lazy. And I’d rather solve rdr now

I've noticed Kak has a pattern D1. He posts flavour and then lightly contributes beginning of D1. Then he disappears and comes back near the end.

For some reason this always provokes several people into suspecting him.

I thought his return post was okay. I wouldn't call it lazy, but rather relatively normal I-have-no-suspects-cuz-it's-D1 and consequently making a stab in the dark vote.

I don't really get why he chose Dargorygel rather than someone else, but otherwise it seemed okay.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Its my grandmother's 95th birthday. I'll be back hopefully before EOD.

I encourage everyone to read Will and my analysis asap

Will do

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE Sweetandcool

I could have vote for any of darg, sweet, or hamilton. I have very light opinions on each of them, and honestly my vote could swing on a dime.

[Bonatogether]

##VOTE Sweetandcool

I could have vote for any of darg, sweet, or hamilton. I have very light opinions on each of them, and honestly my vote could swing on a dime.

why wouldn't you vote me for president