MAFIA 75: TROUBLE AT THE PRECINCT [HIDDEN]

[Vecna]

ah okay, so there is not even the possibility of a mechanical guilty. I was thinking I was gonna need some firm words with jamiet after this game

[Vecna]

anyhow....

[ghug]

Did he actually indicate anywhere what his actual results were on N1/N2?

Or is there literally no reason that im not end-hammered yet? Because that is some fucking amazing plays there if he really just lolguiltied me just before dying.

Is this you claiming guilt?

[President Eden]

it’s that time again boys (and Rumi)… RGB power rankings

These players are out of my POE pool, whether due to them being mechanically clear or due to my belief that they simply wouldn’t be playing this way if they were mafia, one way or another. Underlined players are mechanical clears, italicized players are read out of the pool.

These players are in my POE pool but are not my top picks for mafia at this time.

These players are my most likely picks for mafia.

President Eden — role PM.
ghug — scanned innocent by a flipped cop with both godfather and innocent tag possibilities accounted for.
Chaqa — claimed doctor; if claim is false, downgrade to italics and place behind Rumi, because I think his D1 vote on Byz was very good, and I think his attempts to mech solve today are townie. people will probably dispute pulling him out of the pool without being doctor, and that’s fine, I’m just confident enough that this isn’t mafia Chaqa.
Bonatogether — his game makes no sense if he’s scum.
Rumi Tobari — has bled town all game with earnest insights etc.

worcej — I was not serious earlier about killing him being gg, but despite his bleeding town in spots, I don’t feel like he should be totally out of the pool. just very deep down in it. no need to hash out the Byz stuff for the billionth time but I think we can all acknowledge that he was protecting snowByz to some degree, whether you think that’s alignment-indicative or not is up to you. I’m just wary enough of it to leave him in the pool but not enough to suspect him in a big way right now.
bo_sox48 — not around a lot due to vacation, but consistently has insightful and incisive questions and certainly looks like he’s trying to solve the game. could actually warrant putting him above worcej perhaps.
celaph — see above note basically, minus vacation excuse, I think?
rdrivera2005 — feels like he’s earnestly trying to solve the game when he is around, can’t think of a reason why he would play D1 the way he did as mafia (credit bo for pointing this out). also ~reasons~

Vecna — uncharacteristically low investment in any of his positions. behavior around snowByz really hard to explain as anything but teammate.
Hamilton Neon — see Bona case basically, and I feel like Brian’s total contribution since subbing in would not uncharitably be described as “cmon guys idk what’s happening pick someone else and gimme time.”

I am aware that I have one fewer suspect than there are living mafia. I’m still trying to work out whether I think bo, celaph, and rdrivera are all town. If they are then I actually would say worcej, despite my earlier disclaimer… but I don’t know that I’m ready to declare all three of bo/celaph/rdrivera town. I think it’s fine that I don’t have it literally ALL figured out yet

[rdrivera2005]

@Eden - I like your post but really dislike the colors.

I think I would put Chaqa in blue and Celaph in red but we it's a small change. Abd I am glad someone is reading my posts....

[worcej]

its actually pretty annoying that its probably optimal play to misskill me after that Jamiet statement, because there is no way im ever eating a NK, and this shit is just going to be looming for the rest of the game, dividing town votes.

im a fucking liability now

This is too defeatist to me…

But pretty genuine?

Yeah, but it isn’t something I would ever expect to see from Vecna. It’s more some shit Chaqa would spew for being scummed as a PR

[worcej]

ah okay, so there is not even the possibility of a mechanical guilty. I was thinking I was gonna need some firm words with jamiet after this game

Unless Jamie lied, this is true.

[Chaqa]

Ah, I've solved it.

Neon and Sabi were chosen to drive because the driver knew them.

Ergo Bona deep cover scum confirmed

Get em boys

[President Eden]

I don’t think rdr should be the safety wagon for the bomb. Should be whichever of Vecna or HB we don’t vote off

[Chaqa]

I don’t think rdr should be the safety wagon for the bomb. Should be whichever of Vecna or HB we don’t vote off

I think HB might be town now.

maybe bo?

[President Eden]

I don’t think rdr should be the safety wagon for the bomb. Should be whichever of Vecna or HB we don’t vote off

I think HB might be town now.

maybe bo?

Based on what? (to both sentences)

[bo_sox48]

If HB is town I’ll eat a cucumber in one bite

[bo_sox48]

Ok maybe not in one bite

[Chaqa]

If HB is town I’ll eat a cucumber in one bite

@emc

[worcej]

Ah, I've solved it.

Neon and Sabi were chosen to drive because the driver knew them.

Ergo Bona deep cover scum confirmed

Get em boys

Lol…

Deez Nutz

[Bonatogether]

Ah, I've solved it.

Neon and Sabi were chosen to drive because the driver knew them.

Ergo Bona deep cover scum confirmed

Get em boys

i've never met neon before this

checkmate liberal

[President Eden]

If HB is town I’ll eat a cucumber in one bite

@emc

not an answer

[President Eden]

@Eden - I like your post but really dislike the colors.

I think I would put Chaqa in blue and Celaph in red but we it’s a small change. Abd I am glad someone is reading my posts....

Tell me about celaph in red… Chaqa in blue I understand

[rdrivera2005]

@Eden - I like your post but really dislike the colors.

I think I would put Chaqa in blue and Celaph in red but we it’s a small change. Abd I am glad someone is reading my posts....

Tell me about celaph in red… Chaqa in blue I understand

The game I remember most Celaph as town was one we went to kilo together (I was Mafia) and he played an really great (I won but just because I have an almost perfect voting record, but he was so solid on his analysis I almost lost). This game I don't see that level of reasoning. I see some big wall posts with not much to add. I see a push on me that's based on nothing and that only appeared D2 as he was townreading me D1. I see a willingness to save Byx D1 and Snowy D2. This is more reasons to scumread him then I have to scumread Vecna to be honest.

[bo_sox48]

All those +1s and nobody voted for him