M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[ghug]

And because I know people hate reading long posts the tl;dr

Bob shades scum but never votes for them until they're already certainly dead + explains wagon distributions well given known town and scum for D1 and D2.

Can you remind me to read your post tomorrow?

[ghug]

I usually read your long posts, for the record, I just dislike doing it.

[TheFlyingBoat]

And yes there is the obvious response that hey, Durga and Celaph were on his wagon D1. Sure, but they only moved there after momentum was squarely on killing Flum and after it seemed pretty clear there was little desire in the game for anyone to move off of him. To put this in perspective, no voter on Flum ever moved their vote after Chaqa abandoned it following the beginning of Jamie's anti-Flum march (with the exception of Flum himself who accidentally voted for himself instead of me) for almost 7 straight hours, until Bona and friends decided to do their weird 6D chess plan.

[Chaqa]

Oh I'm definitely down for ##Vote Bob

[TheFlyingBoat]

There was also a strong contingent of people who had declared Bob a non-wagon possibility, which makes the Durga and Celaph votes much more explainable. If Bob isn't going to die because you have a cadre of people who aren't on the main wagon (a wagon that doesn't shed members at all as already mentioned), but have indicated that they will vote to protect him, you have essentially no reason to believe that anything under 10 votes will kill Bob and with 20 voters, you have very little to fear. So why not humor DeathLlama (personally asked Durga and Celaph to vote Bob) and buddy up to him, vote for an alt wagon, give protection to your scummate on death? Keep in mind Durga only joins after Bona says Bob will not be a counter wagon and puts him on 3 to Flum's rock solid 5 (with an implied 6 from Bona), and celaph only join after Flum gets up to 6 (with an implied 8 from Bona and Blamp). The implied votes from Bona and Blamp come IMMEDIATELY after celaph's vote, vindicating Durga's and celaph's confidence in Bob's safety.

[Chaqa]

Ideally I want to vote out Donny today.

[ghug]

I think I'm cool with Donny.

[damo666]

##vote HR

[Jamiet99uk]

if i die kill ghug

I have been trying, but with little success.

She'd moved on to Jamie. Kill him instead.

This is a scummy post.

[BobMcBob]

Oh yay I can flame TFB for having stupid ideas later tonight. Or more accurately, spend hundreds of words explaining my thought processes for the third time in a rather aggressive manner.

[Jamiet99uk]

I only say that because kgray, in my eyes, was not the most townie of the people still living.

Do you think that Ghug or Chaqa was?

[Jamiet99uk]

Ideally I want to vote out Donny today.

But you are voting for someone else.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote HellenicRiot

I would also vote Maniac today, or Ghug.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: Why aren't you voting for the person you claim you want to vote for?

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa: Why aren't you voting for the person you claim you want to vote for?

What kind of trap question is this

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: Why aren't you voting for the person you claim you want to vote for?

What kind of trap question is this

It is not a trap question.

You said "I want to vote out Donny".

You are not voting for Donny.

Discuss.

[Jamiet99uk]

You basically said, in two posts very close together:

"I think we should vote out Donny. @@Vote Bob."

If you want to vote out Donny why not vote for Donny?

[Chaqa]

You basically said, in two posts very close together:

"I think we should vote out Donny. @@Vote Bob."

If you want to vote out Donny why not vote for Donny?

Because I don’t think anyone else wants to votes Donny,

[BobMcBob]

You basically said, in two posts very close together:

"I think we should vote out Donny. @@Vote Bob."

If you want to vote out Donny why not vote for Donny?

Because I don’t think anyone else wants to votes Donny,

This feels lazy.

[Chaqa]

You basically said, in two posts very close together:

"I think we should vote out Donny. @@Vote Bob."

If you want to vote out Donny why not vote for Donny?

Because I don’t think anyone else wants to votes Donny,

This feels lazy.

Not you telling me I’m lazy