M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Chaqa]

With Fox subbing out (as well as Dargo) I think their lurking is NAI. I thought Dargo's play when he was here was a bit scummy, which would imply Bunny is a bit scummy until i see otherwise.

Fox I had no strong feel for, though I didn't have a super scumread on him.

I really just don't see there being two doctors...

[Chaqa]

You know what would make it easier to work out brain and RHKs claims?

A massclaim

See if there are any other double ups.

I'm not sure if mass-claim is pro-town or anti-town.

Neph, why have you gotten so concise all the sudden? What happened to madman Neph from earlier?

[Squigs44]

Hello. Won't be able to read anything for another hour or so, and I definitely won't be able to read enough of the game to play as normal, so while I'm gone:

Who should I sheep and why?
Please @Squigs me for my convenience

[Chaqa]

Hello. Won't be able to read anything for another hour or so, and I definitely won't be able to read enough of the game to play as normal, so while I'm gone:

Who should I sheep and why?
Please @Squigs me for my convenience

@Squigs - I wrote some catch-up summaries for Bunny here that may help:
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... d=w:148216
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... d=w:148238

Widely considered to be accurate.

[damo666]

More GM Note:
I am scraping the barrel to get replacements... if you know a friend who has a friend who also knows how to play Mafia, I may need them by EOD...

That's a tad uncomplimentary to squigs isn't it? I've a mind to complain to the GM

[BunnyGo]

Why if you believe food is scum you must also believe I'm scum, a short summary

the tl;dr version is:

food is very much a careful player as any alignment, and cost-benefit analysis is something that he does. He also does not have a thing for heel face turn that some other players do have, so extensive and extra unnecessary steps for deception are unlikely.

This defense of food reads as vacuous to me. I don’t understand the
Case on food. But it seems more substantive.

[Nephthys]

You know what would make it easier to work out brain and RHKs claims?

A massclaim

See if there are any other double ups.

I'm not sure if mass-claim is pro-town or anti-town.

Neph, why have you gotten so concise all the sudden? What happened to madman Neph from earlier?

Cause I really didn't wanna get pulled into the drama.

Best to back off and let it conclude then come back and contribute

[Chaqa]

You know what would make it easier to work out brain and RHKs claims?

A massclaim

See if there are any other double ups.

I'm not sure if mass-claim is pro-town or anti-town.

Neph, why have you gotten so concise all the sudden? What happened to madman Neph from earlier?

Cause I really didn't wanna get pulled into the drama.

Best to back off and let it conclude then come back and contribute

I meant Neph from Day 1 to... well, now. Or, a bit earlier.

[foodcoats]

Food is still scum
he knew there was a jailor. his d2 outs him. his reax to being alive is fake. it shows hes lying

It's a sex cult, okay?

Jamie puts us in Jail. Chaqa is the Sexy Neighbour. EMC writes the fanfic.

And they don't call me Lightning Rod for nothing...

[Chaqa]

Why if you believe food is scum you must also believe I'm scum, a short summary

the tl;dr version is:

food is very much a careful player as any alignment, and cost-benefit analysis is something that he does. He also does not have a thing for heel face turn that some other players do have, so extensive and extra unnecessary steps for deception are unlikely.

This defense of food reads as vacuous to me. I don’t understand the
Case on food. But it seems more substantive.

There is a decent case for food as scum, but his actions w/r/t the Neighborhood QT just make me think he's town through and through.

[BunnyGo]

Also, bringing it up again but,

Massclaim?

Having not been part of conversation before: this at first glance seems pro town. We get a sense of numbers and ability. Scum either choose inconfirmable roles or we catch when they don’t confirm. Then search through the unconfirmed ones.

Just lifting the veil on the closed part of the game seems pro town.

That said, I’m often wrong about this stuff.

[BunnyGo]

@brain

What do you make of rhks claim? Do you think he’s a doctor as well?

Probably true if the setup is designed to make claiming en masse as useless as possible. if hes real then you lynch me and towns down probably 11 in a row and scum probably gets desperate tryinh to stop a cult from balooning.

but eh whatever.

Are we sure 3P is a cult?

[Nephthys]

I'm not sure if mass-claim is pro-town or anti-town.

Neph, why have you gotten so concise all the sudden? What happened to madman Neph from earlier?

Cause I really didn't wanna get pulled into the drama.

Best to back off and let it conclude then come back and contribute

I meant Neph from Day 1 to... well, now. Or, a bit earlier.

You meant you preferred that?

[Nephthys]

Also, bringing it up again but,

Massclaim?

Having not been part of conversation before: this at first glance seems pro town. We get a sense of numbers and ability. Scum either choose inconfirmable roles or we catch when they don’t confirm. Then search through the unconfirmed ones.

Just lifting the veil on the closed part of the game seems pro town.

That said, I’m often wrong about this stuff.

I like this guy

Lets keep him around

[BunnyGo]

so when ego takes over, bb being a liar is the main charge. its what im accused of every game. nonstop. never ends. even when im not lying they find reasons why im lying. or they invent scenarios where im dishonestly crumbing. which again, SHOULDNT BE A CONCERN OF TOWNIES IN THE FIRST PLACE

I mean...you got me lynched last game...that concerned me.

now what. what do you want from me. just vote me if youre gonna hold last game agInst me. I dont have the energy to foght 7 ppl at once

Sorry. Didn’t mean to make you feel cornered. Just pointing out your claim lady game did cause he PR of the role you claimed to lose the CC (well I was AFK so no CC)

[Nephthys]

Also, bringing it up again but,

Massclaim?

Having not been part of conversation before: this at first glance seems pro town. We get a sense of numbers and ability. Scum either choose inconfirmable roles or we catch when they don’t confirm. Then search through the unconfirmed ones.

Just lifting the veil on the closed part of the game seems pro town.

That said, I’m often wrong about this stuff.

I like this guy

Lets keep him around

Until I explicitly say that we have to lynch him this phase and offer no explanation

[BunnyGo]

I mean...you got me lynched last game...that concerned me.

now what. what do you want from me. just vote me if youre gonna hold last game agInst me. I dont have the energy to foght 7 ppl at once

Sorry. Didn’t mean to make you feel cornered. Just pointing out your claim lady game did cause he PR of the role you claimed to lose the CC (well I was AFK so no CC)

You did play the rest of the game well...so that was ok. And I didn’t shoot you. So that was ok too.

[Chaqa]

@brain

What do you make of rhks claim? Do you think he’s a doctor as well?

Probably true if the setup is designed to make claiming en masse as useless as possible. if hes real then you lynch me and towns down probably 11 in a row and scum probably gets desperate tryinh to stop a cult from balooning.

but eh whatever.

Are we sure 3P is a cult?

We don't even know there IS a third party. It's possible EMC's Third-Party Universal Backup was the 3P.

[BunnyGo]

Aha! Finally good ol' Neph made a reappearance.

I'm quite open to starting a flash wagon if anyone else would join

Can someone explain why? And what Nephs post means? And why we are sure Chaq isn’t 3P with goal of recruiting a lot of people to his nefarious cult? Shouldn’t we talk about lynching Chaq?

I have not yet made you a summary post, but I think you should reread at least the EON posts from everyone before posting more inthread, as well as all the adjudications.

I’ll keep posting. But will read before bed tonight

[damo666]

Wow. Caught up.

About to go to bed. Will no doubt wake up to 50 pages of which there will be maybe half a dozen pots worth reading.

Good night.