Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[dargorygel]

www.mafia.peterlund.se

[ChippeRock]

@chipperock
I admit I don't see your brilliant reveal. But I also don't see your shenanigans as particularly AI.
But I wanna ask you this... at THIS point, why not just tell us where your hints are? You're heading for a lynch. According to you, a miss-lynch. Seems to me the best way out of it is to reveal your reveal.
As it is, a lot of time and energy is being spent on trying to connect the dots you claim are there.
Help town, here. Tell us your hidden gems, OR explain clearly why you won't.

That's the problem: I can't, not without breaking the rules anyways. Several were on the right track (and a couple got really close to it), but if you ask me anything about it, I have to deny it. If you list out the ways I could prove I'm a VT (like Percy did), that'll help you out. Investigate my strange messages, everything I posted had a very good reason for it, designed to either help people find the smoking gun or hide the actual proof itself. Sometimes when I denied something, it was a lie.

[dargorygel]

oops
http://mafia.peterlund.se

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

[dargorygel]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

@Chippe, thanks for the explanation... doesn't help me, though

[et]

##VOTE ChippeRock

##vote TrPrado

Based. I’m in.

##VOTE TrPrado

@boz@Tom@Car
Please tell me reason of this vote.
Especially boz.
Just you vote without other words.
I can't read you are town or mafia.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

I think it’s easier to see what Scum wouldn’t do. But if you see neither, call it AI.

[ChippeRock]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

@Chippe, thanks for the explanation... doesn't help me, though

I believe I addressed what Town!ChippeRock is thinking:

Please share you reads on someone else Chippee.

Even if you somehow have proof you are VT, pointing that out D1 is terrible town play anyway

Not really. If everyone definitively knows I'm a VT, than I won't be mislynched nor will Mafia NK me - as they have bigger fish to fry than a VT.

Sorry darg, I'm trying not to break the rules again. But the clues are there - looking at my most cryptic posts should help you get onto the right track.

[dargorygel]

Pay me $20 and I’ll jail you tonight

Nice to be speaking with you again, Carl.
Do you mind if I pay you in exposure?

Just so you know, my jail doesn’t have Internet. Which makes it kind of a raw deal for you to offer to use your thousands of Instagram followers to signal boost my recycled Petri dish company from prison...

@Connor
@Carl
Do you two know each other?

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Tom, thats an ugly ISO. Start trying please. First explain your Chippe read.

[dargorygel]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

@Chippe, thanks for the explanation... doesn't help me, though

No, I get that, and agree... don't break the rules


I believe I addressed what Town!ChippeRock is thinking:

Please share you reads on someone else Chippee.

Even if you somehow have proof you are VT, pointing that out D1 is terrible town play anyway

Not really. If everyone definitively knows I'm a VT, than I won't be mislynched nor will Mafia NK me - as they have bigger fish to fry than a VT.

Sorry darg, I'm trying not to break the rules again. But the clues are there - looking at my most cryptic posts should help you get onto the right track.

[dargorygel]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

@Chippe, thanks for the explanation... doesn't help me, though

I believe I addressed what Town!ChippeRock is thinking:

Please share you reads on someone else Chippee.

Even if you somehow have proof you are VT, pointing that out D1 is terrible town play anyway

Not really. If everyone definitively knows I'm a VT, than I won't be mislynched nor will Mafia NK me - as they have bigger fish to fry than a VT.

Sorry darg, I'm trying not to break the rules again. But the clues are there - looking at my most cryptic posts should help you get onto the right track.

No, I agree... don't break the rules...

[dargorygel]

@Tom, I want to see the peterbot because I have the impression you are not being thoughtful. I suppose I could just ask. Have you been thoughtful so far? Why not?

Also, from you in particular, explain what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here.

Balki... I don't see what Scum!ChippeRock is thinking here... nor do I see what Town!ChippeRock is thinking here.

I think it’s easier to see what Scum wouldn’t do. But if you see neither, call it AI.

Aye, Balki... I don't see how scum would have any reason to do this. Thus I am not voting for him today.

[Carl Tuckerson]

Now I am confused by something, Chippe. It sounds as though you found an exploit in the VT role PM that you think might be against the rules to use.

Is it against the rules to use the information you are trying to use?
If it’s not, why are you being coy about the information?
If it is, why are you using the information?
If it’s not clear, why not ask a moderator in private if it is against the rules to use the information you are trying to use?

[Carl Tuckerson]

##VOTE ChippeRock

##vote TrPrado

Based. I’m in.

##VOTE TrPrado

@boz@Tom@Car
Please tell me reason of this vote.
Especially boz.
Just you vote without other words.
I can't read you are town or mafia.

I can’t speak for Tom, and given that multiple others are now saying his posts have not been good(?), I think I’ll keep my powder dry and let Tom explain his vote first.
So that we’re clear, I independently thought Prado was (and is) a good vote. I’ll prove it by saying the word “baseball” right now and explain how that word matters and why I think Prado is a good vote right now, after Tom explains.

[TrPrado]

(Also what’s AI?)

alignment indicative I assume

Oh well in that case

Teacon: I never said it was. Just because I push you doesn’t mean I hardline think you’re scum. It’s a piece of a larger puzzle.

[dargorygel]

##VOTE ChippeRock

Based. I’m in.

##VOTE TrPrado

@boz@Tom@Car
Please tell me reason of this vote.
Especially boz.
Just you vote without other words.
I can't read you are town or mafia.

I can’t speak for Tom, and given that multiple others are now saying his posts have not been good(?), I think I’ll keep my powder dry and let Tom explain his vote first.
So that we’re clear, I independently thought Prado was (and is) a good vote. I’ll prove it by saying the word “baseball” right now and explain how that word matters and why I think Prado is a good vote right now, after Tom explains.

(this would be funnier if you quoted a word from IN the GM's initial posts... just saying.)

[Balki Bartokomous]

Sorry darg, I'm trying not to break the rules again. But the clues are there - looking at my most cryptic posts should help you get onto the right track.

This discussion really isn’t the sort of discussion that should be in a game. If you already broke the rules, don’t keep referring to it. If there is some kind of exploit, don’t tell us to read the clues and find it. Nobody here wants to solve the game based on a GM mistake or a role PM exploit.

[TrPrado]

##VOTE ChippeRock

Based. I’m in.

##VOTE TrPrado

@boz@Tom@Car
Please tell me reason of this vote.
Especially boz.
Just you vote without other words.
I can't read you are town or mafia.

I can’t speak for Tom, and given that multiple others are now saying his posts have not been good(?), I think I’ll keep my powder dry and let Tom explain his vote first.
So that we’re clear, I independently thought Prado was (and is) a good vote. I’ll prove it by saying the word “baseball” right now and explain how that word matters and why I think Prado is a good vote right now, after Tom explains.

I think he really wants to see you at least push me if you think I’m a good vote. A vote alone isn’t a push, and no one in the game has actually challenged me. If you think there’s something essential that needs to be voiced, do it. Don’t wait on Tom.

[ChippeRock]

Now I am confused by something, Chippe. It sounds as though you found an exploit in the VT role PM that you think might be against the rules to use.

Is it against the rules to use the information you are trying to use?
If it’s not, why are you being coy about the information?
If it is, why are you using the information?
If it’s not clear, why not ask a moderator in private if it is against the rules to use the information you are trying to use?

I can post the evidence where you'll find the proof, but I can't imply that the specific piece(s) of evidence can be used to prove I'm a VT. You'll find it among my posts, but I can't direct you to it. Just look at all of my cryptic posts, and analyze my specific reasons behind each and every one of those posts.