Mafia 47 - The Sixth Mass Extinction, Sign Ups

[dargorygel]

@Neph

I would like to play (especially without the venom) but for the period 24/07-29/07 I will have phone access only and participation in this period would be sporadic and low in content.

I'll let you decide.

Thanks.

Just play so well that you get NKed before that

DAMO IS CONFIRMED TOWN!

[Jamiet99uk]

I will play and expect people to behave properly. And I expect GMs to set (and enforce) some rules against tryng to game the system. What Chippe did last game is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.

What rule did he break? Quote it.
If you can't, what new rule do you propose? Draft it.

[ND]

Oh, I can't wait for this.

[damo666]

I can

[rdrivera2005]

I will play and expect people to behave properly. And I expect GMs to set (and enforce) some rules against tryng to game the system. What Chippe did last game is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.

What rule did he break? Quote it.
If you can't, what new rule do you propose? Draft it.

I think he didn't break any explicit rule, but I still think it was against the game spirit. Imagine if all players decide to "prove" his role that way, it's not what the game is about.
I would suggest a rule that says that any question about GM messages and role messages should be dealt with the GMs on private messages and not in game thread. In fact, if I were GM I would forbid any direct call to GM on the main thread. If you have something to ask to GMs you should do it privately and the GM decides if there is a need to post the answer on the main thread. Just a suggestion.

[ChippeRock]

I will play and expect people to behave properly. And I expect GMs to set (and enforce) some rules against tryng to game the system. What Chippe did last game is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.

What rule did he break? Quote it.
If you can't, what new rule do you propose? Draft it.

I think he didn't break any explicit rule, but I still think it was against the game spirit. Imagine if all players decide to "prove" his role that way, it's not what the game is about.
I would suggest a rule that says that any question about GM messages and role messages should be dealt with the GMs on private messages and not in game thread. In fact, if I were GM I would forbid any direct call to GM on the main thread. If you have something to ask to GMs you should do it privately and the GM decides if there is a need to post the answer on the main thread. Just a suggestion.

How is it against the spirit of the game? I claimed I was a VT and hinted that I had received the exact same VT role PM as posted on the OP (which is implied by a claim).

I shouldn't be punished for manipulating you guys into thinking I thought I had a genuine way to mechanically prove I was a VT. It should of been obvious that there was no way to break the game - as previously stated by worcej & Jamiet. It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched.

[bo_sox48]

I’ll play on the condition that nobody fights about petty bullshit that doesn’t matter anymore in the sign up thread.

[rdrivera2005]

What rule did he break? Quote it.
If you can't, what new rule do you propose? Draft it.

I think he didn't break any explicit rule, but I still think it was against the game spirit. Imagine if all players decide to "prove" his role that way, it's not what the game is about.
I would suggest a rule that says that any question about GM messages and role messages should be dealt with the GMs on private messages and not in game thread. In fact, if I were GM I would forbid any direct call to GM on the main thread. If you have something to ask to GMs you should do it privately and the GM decides if there is a need to post the answer on the main thread. Just a suggestion.

How is it against the spirit of the game? I claimed I was a VT and hinted that I had received the exact same VT role PM as posted on the OP (which is implied by a claim).

I shouldn't be punished for manipulating you guys into thinking I thought I had a genuine way to mechanically prove I was a VT. It should of been obvious that there was no way to break the game - as previously stated by worcej & Jamiet. It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched.

I don't think you should be punished as you didn't break any rule. What I want is a rule to avoid bringing things outside of the game like PMs into the thread. There was once a rule against bets that have the same spirit.

[Percy Williams]

I’ll play on the condition that nobody fights about petty $&@!*#€@!$*& that doesn’t matter anymore in the sign up thread.

I'd like to fight you on that.

[dargorygel]

I’ll play on the condition that nobody fights about petty bullshit that doesn’t matter anymore in the sign up thread.

Too late?

[dargorygel]

Chippe writes: "It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched."

True, you did 'that claim thing.' True, you didn't get mislynched. But the two were not connected causally.

[Percy Williams]

I think he didn't break any explicit rule, but I still think it was against the game spirit. Imagine if all players decide to "prove" his role that way, it's not what the game is about.
I would suggest a rule that says that any question about GM messages and role messages should be dealt with the GMs on private messages and not in game thread. In fact, if I were GM I would forbid any direct call to GM on the main thread. If you have something to ask to GMs you should do it privately and the GM decides if there is a need to post the answer on the main thread. Just a suggestion.

How is it against the spirit of the game? I claimed I was a VT and hinted that I had received the exact same VT role PM as posted on the OP (which is implied by a claim).

I shouldn't be punished for manipulating you guys into thinking I thought I had a genuine way to mechanically prove I was a VT. It should of been obvious that there was no way to break the game - as previously stated by worcej & Jamiet. It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched.

I don't think you should be punished as you didn't break any rule. What I want is a rule to avoid bringing things outside of the game like PMs into the thread. There was once a rule against bets that have the same spirit.

Ha!
He broke the rule against gambling!
[ Quote] It was a big gamble to make, [/Quote]

[ChippeRock]

Chippe writes: "It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched."

True, you did 'that claim thing.' True, you didn't get mislynched. But the two were not connected causally.

Oh yeah, I agree (other intentional elements of my game play certainly had a much greater impact) - but it certainly started me on the right note to getting a universal VT read.

[Jamiet99uk]

Chippe writes: "It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched."

True, you did 'that claim thing.' True, you didn't get mislynched. But the two were not connected causally.

Oh yeah, I agree (other intentional elements of my game play certainly had a much greater impact) - but it certainly started me on the right note to getting a universal VT read.

I really don't think it did.

[FlaviusAetius]

28 players?

nope

play!

[ChippeRock]

Chippe writes: "It was a big gamble to make, but it guaranteed I didn't get mislynched."

True, you did 'that claim thing.' True, you didn't get mislynched. But the two were not connected causally.

Oh yeah, I agree (other intentional elements of my game play certainly had a much greater impact) - but it certainly started me on the right note to getting a universal VT read.

I really don't think it did.

Sure it did. Nobody even bothered to read me or even suspect me of being non-town after that - and I just reinforced that opinion with the rest of my play.

[FlaviusAetius]

I think everyone just kinda pretended it didnt happen and moved on, sure it saved you on the first day, but more so it just kinda exposed how everyone was scumreading you cause they didnt like you, not for anything you did in the game

Players
1. ChippeRock
2. foodcoats
3. EspressoPatronum
4. Vaporwave
5. worcej
6.Percy Williams
7. damo666
8. Jamiet99uk
9. ND
10. Vecna
11.rdrivera2005
12. xorxes
13. bozo
14. FlaviusAetius
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.

I will be at Temple Orientation the 11th and 12th, will still have phone access
(i got one!!!)
I will also be on a Greece trip to visit my family from the 21st to August 3rd
Will still have phone access there too( I think ) If this game lasts that long, and I survive that long, I'll probably need a sub

[ChippeRock]

Oh yeah, I agree (other intentional elements of my game play certainly had a much greater impact) - but it certainly started me on the right note to getting a universal VT read.

I really don't think it did.

Sure it did. Nobody even bothered to read me or even suspect me of being non-town after that - and I just reinforced that opinion with the rest of my play.

By "read", I mean "detailed read/ISO".

[Jamiet99uk]

"Temple Orientation"

What the fuck is that? Have you joined a cult?

[MoscowFleet]

Players
1. ChippeRock
2. foodcoats
3. EspressoPatronum
4. Vaporwave
5. worcej
6.Percy Williams
7. damo666
8. Jamiet99uk
9. ND
10. Vecna
11.rdrivera2005
12. xorxes
13. bozo
14. FlaviusAetius
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.

Substitutes:
1. MoscowFleet