MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[damo666]

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

I agree. Bona or Koala.

What if we killed scum instead

Like who? You?

[Foxcastle]

I can’t tell if we are still in the shitposting phase or if people are starting to get serious about these ideas of who we should vote.

[Chaqa]

Anyone have a gun?

[worcej]

I'm caught up.

##CALL GM:

Vote count, please?

Took me 10 minutes to do this. FML.

The only vote count you're getting for the next 24 hours:
Koalaattack (4) Dousing, ghug, Jamiet99uk, Koalaattack
Jamiet99uk (1) President Eden
Dousing (1) snowy801
Bonatogether (1) damo666
ghug (1) Chaqa
sweetandcool (1) Bonatogether

[ghug]

Calling it now I'm getting miskilled D2.

You.are never misskilled...

It happens very occasionally.

[Jamiet99uk]

Is title tinkering an offence?

Not unless you're some kind of snowflake who's triggered by the smallest things.

Does that describe you, Damo?

What do you think?

This particular thing seems to needle you.

I've done it for 10+ games and it's not against the rules.

You know that.

[Jamiet99uk]

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

I agree. Bona or Koala.

What if we killed scum instead

You know they are both town, how?

[Jamiet99uk]

Anyone have a gun?

Millions of nutty Americans, why do you ask?

[Jamiet99uk]

I do NOT have a gun, for the record.

[bozotheclown]

It should say...

Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, then he's the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate, or he's the traitor, in which case he knows that his other teammate doesn't know who he is and so it's a pretty big gamble (this might be reasonable if the second goon is a great player).

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

I am not assuming that is what the mafia did, even though I think it was their best option.

[Bonatogether]

Well in the last game you GMed the 4 of us Mafia blatantly +1ed most of each other's posts until either Bona or Eden called it out

[ghug]

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

I am not assuming that is what the mafia did, even though I think it was their best option.

Do you think Fox looks scummy here?

[Bonatogether]

##vote Bona contention

Just because.

@Koala please stop this self voting malarkey. It serves no purpose.

thanks damo i appreciate it

[bozotheclown]

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

I find that odd as well.

This is all very interesting.

Why do you think it is odd I would point out that Foxcastle seemed to be making an assumption about what the mafia decided, even though I believe what he was assuming is a reasonable option?

[bozotheclown]

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

I am not assuming that is what the mafia did, even though I think it was their best option.

Do you think Fox looks scummy here?

Not for the original post, slightly for the response.

[Foxcastle]

I am not assuming that is what the mafia did, even though I think it was their best option.

Do you think Fox looks scummy here?

Not for the original post, slightly for the response.

Which response? There were several...

[bozotheclown]

Do you think Fox looks scummy here?

Not for the original post, slightly for the response.

Which response? There were several...

The part about it being odd I would question why you were making an assumption even though I thought the assumption might be correct.

[Foxcastle]

Not for the original post, slightly for the response.

Which response? There were several...

The part about it being odd I would question why you were making an assumption even though I thought the assumption might be correct.

That's not what I thought was odd. I thought it was odd that you were doing it with shade.

[bozotheclown]

Which response? There were several...

The part about it being odd I would question why you were making an assumption even though I thought the assumption might be correct.

That's not what I thought was odd. I thought it was odd that you were doing it with shade.

I didn't think I was, I thought that you might not have read the details of the setup, it which case it could have been a town tell.

[snowy801]

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

I agree. Bona or Koala.

What if we killed scum instead

Any reason to believe there's no overlap here?