M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

It is not obvious from the message but I think the implication is I saved myself and was therefore the NK target.

This makes Maniac look suss I guess.

It also makes the "desperately tap Ghug twice" theory seem less likely.

In the absence of a town claim I assume mafia sent the message and 3p shot him and it's a coincidence.

[damo666]

If brown rice with town don't use it on me. If it's with mafia I die tonight. Else I guess I die N4.

At least I bought us some time.

Why would you die tonight?

Because I assume mafia will try NK me. What a strange question.

[TheMadMonarch]

If brown rice with town don't use it on me. If it's with mafia I die tonight. Else I guess I die N4.

At least I bought us some time.

Why would you die tonight?

Because I assume mafia will try NK me. What a strange question.

I worked that out, why do you think they'd want you?

[Maniac]

I think town roleblocker should say who they blocked last night.

The target is highly likely mafia, hence the no nk

I second this motion. It's likely both town RBs are now used up so this info could find us mafia attempted killer and give us a town clear.

[damo666]

in the absence of that:
if you were informed that you were saved, you were attacked
if you were only informed that your save action went ahead successfully, you were not
(presumably)
which is it?

It is not obvious from the message but I think the implication is I saved myself and was therefore the NK target.

This makes Maniac look suss I guess.

does the message go along the lines of "you were saved" or of "your action succeeded"
implications aside
also you really have it out for maniac dont you
why does this implicate maniac above anyone else?

Neither. It simply says I was served a dish.

Yeah, I do seem to have it in for Maniac.

[damo666]

Why would you die tonight?

Because I assume mafia will try NK me. What a strange question.

I worked that out, why do you think they'd want you?

They tried last night.

[TheMadMonarch]

I was thinking (dangerous as it is), and it's strange to me that 1) ghug was shot before bozo mentioned the letter and 2) Bozo waited that long to mention it.

2) aside, what 1) says is that these events were independent. Mafia goes to frame ghug with the napkin, but 3p (because yes, they can start with steak) kills him for his item (which they presumably knew thanks to their scan). Why not take the item in the night? Maybe there was someone else better to steal from.

[damo666]

I think town roleblocker should say who they blocked last night.

The target is highly likely mafia, hence the no nk

I second this motion. It's likely both town RBs are now used up so this info could find us mafia attempted killer and give us a town clear.

If I saved myself this theory is out the window. In fact it just means the town RB target is not the NKer. Doesn't help that much.

[TheMadMonarch]

I think town roleblocker should say who they blocked last night.

The target is highly likely mafia, hence the no nk

I second this motion. It's likely both town RBs are now used up so this info could find us mafia attempted killer and give us a town clear.

yeah, this post is not good for maniac. I'm pretty sure damo is not 3p after that performance, but anyone advocating for the reveal of one of the 3p item is very sus and wrong.

[damo666]

I think town roleblocker should say who they blocked last night.

The target is highly likely mafia, hence the no nk

I second this motion. It's likely both town RBs are now used up so this info could find us mafia attempted killer and give us a town clear.

yeah, this post is not good for maniac. I'm pretty sure damo is not 3p after that performance, but anyone advocating for the reveal of one of the 3p item is very sus and wrong.

Unfortunately I've revealed one.

[BobMcBob]

This isn’t so much a scum slip as a confession

##vote Hamilton ## vote end

do i really have to keep asking people to explain their bad logic?

I don’t think you have to keep asking, as you’ll be dead soon.

My logic is thus:

Scum!HB roleblocks Ghug
Ghug doesn’t confirm he has been RB’d before death
Scum!HB imagined Ghug must have claimed his RB
Scum!HB says ‘two RB claims, one of which has died’

I can’t see any other explanation for you statement, so you must be scum.

see folks, this is why we explain our garbage dumpster fire logic instead of assuming other people are as wrong as us
because ghug was one of two rb claims the previous day
then subsequently died today
coincidence? hb thinks maybe not
unless of course town rb blocked snowy and hb was super unobservant

[TheMadMonarch]

I second this motion. It's likely both town RBs are now used up so this info could find us mafia attempted killer and give us a town clear.

yeah, this post is not good for maniac. I'm pretty sure damo is not 3p after that performance, but anyone advocating for the reveal of one of the 3p item is very sus and wrong.

Unfortunately I've revealed one.

I thought that was also a bad move. But not 3p indicative as you're not going to steal from yourself.

[Jamiet99uk]

It is not obvious from the message but I think the implication is I saved myself and was therefore the NK target.

This makes Maniac look suss I guess.

It also makes the "desperately tap Ghug twice" theory seem less likely.

In the absence of a town claim I assume mafia sent the message and 3p shot him and it's a coincidence.

That is more plausible than Bozo's ridiculous theory.

[BobMcBob]

The team is not Bob, BB, and me, so this did not happen. (If it was, I think we might just've)

You are 100% certain that Bob is not on the Mafia team.
Interesting.

I'm pretty sure, but not 100%.

I'm saying this would only happen with three wackjobs, and no-one to stop us.

honestly i wouldnt have put this beyond our me/you/bona scumteam that missed two nks in a row

[TheMadMonarch]

You are 100% certain that Bob is not on the Mafia team.
Interesting.

I'm pretty sure, but not 100%.

I'm saying this would only happen with three wackjobs, and no-one to stop us.

honestly i wouldnt have put this beyond our me/you/bona scumteam that missed two nks in a row

yeah... that's what made me think about it. imagine if we had BB as well.... we'd have been unstoppabl(y stupid).

[BobMcBob]

damo, what did you do with the rice on n1?

[damo666]

I am really lost as to who scum are.

I am hoping Tom is town and will do a nice summary post that will make things clearer.

[damo666]

damo, what did you do with the rice on n1?

I saved someone who wasn't the NK target.

[BobMcBob]

It is not obvious from the message but I think the implication is I saved myself and was therefore the NK target.

This makes Maniac look suss I guess.

does the message go along the lines of "you were saved" or of "your action succeeded"
implications aside
also you really have it out for maniac dont you
why does this implicate maniac above anyone else?

Neither. It simply says I was served a dish.

Yeah, I do seem to have it in for Maniac.

hmmmmm
i dunno what to make of that tbh

[BobMcBob]

If brown rice with town don't use it on me. If it's with mafia I die tonight. Else I guess I die N4.

At least I bought us some time.

why should town not use the brown rice on you tonight?