MAFIA 51 - LONDON BY GASLIGHT [HIDDEN]

[e.m.c^42]

STOP TALKINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

Your logic isn't necessarily wrong, it's just that I think the benefits of talking outweighs that of silence :D

although, was wondering - what would you do in games with day chat?

[xorxes]

(i'm painting ND and Tom in green even though technically neither of them is strictly a clear yet)

DAY 1

Bob (7) Vapor dargo Hosuke Kalel emc purple xorxes damo
Vapor (5) Bob Chaqa frost Flav
Computer (3) Cmdr BionicMole bozo
ND (1) Vecna
No‑Lynch (1) Temasek
damo (1) rdrivera
BionicMole (1) Demon
purple(1) BunnyGo
Hosuke (1) ND
bozo (1) Kitsune

DAY 2

frost (12) Demon damo dargo rdrivera Hosuke Temasek Kalel Chaqa bozo purple ND Vecna
Chaqa (3) Kitsune Cmdr BionicMole
bo_sox (3) Flav Bunny emc
Temasek (3) Tom xorxes frost

DAY 3

rdrivera (11) Tom Kalel ND bozo xorxes emc Chaqa purple Cmdr Flav Vecna
yavu (3) Temasek dargo BionicMole
Tom (2) rdrivera Demon
Temasek (1) Hosuke
dargo (1) yavu
bozo (1) Kitsune

[xorxes]

I'm also going to tentatively exclude Kitsune because she voted for rivera when she had other options.

That only leaves BionicMole and DemonRHK as the most likely candidates to complete team Moriarty. These are the only two for which I could not find anything yet that would suggest they were not rivera's teammates.

[xorxes]

The other team is a different story, as we don't have anything to make connections yet.

[xorxes]

If we assume scum would avoid ending up on the same wagon, BionicMole is the most likley, because Demon voted together with rivera D2 and D3.

[Chaqa]

I'm also going to tentatively exclude Kitsune because she voted for rivera when she had other options.

That only leaves BionicMole and DemonRHK as the most likely candidates to complete team Moriarty. These are the only two for which I could not find anything yet that would suggest they were not rivera's teammates.

She was really trying To AVOID Rivera...

[xorxes]

I'm also going to tentatively exclude Kitsune because she voted for rivera when she had other options.

That only leaves BionicMole and DemonRHK as the most likely candidates to complete team Moriarty. These are the only two for which I could not find anything yet that would suggest they were not rivera's teammates.

She was really trying To AVOID Rivera...

She voted for him for a while though. She could have been trying to apply the chess trick that Demon taught her. Maybe. Something to look into tomorrow.

[KalelChase]

I was expecting several pages of Flav catching up but we only got a few posts. What happened?

Im catching up right now, my mom wanted me to come upstairs to watch a movie, so I did...Im back at my dorm now, so full level of activity

What movie?

[Kitsune]

and at this point, about half hour from EOD, she pops up and has enough reads that it's obvious enough to a point that it was lurking, not being gone? Like, there is enough to see that she's read up most of what was missed. Lurker pool this game is actually very nice place to hide, as there are so many.

You give me too much credit Einstein, although I do appreciate your expert opinion on how much attention lurkers pay to what's going on.

I read the bot for the day end to end from like... 2.5 hours before EoD to 1.5 hours. There wasn't much.

From that, I had reads - and you can see them in the order I found them from my first post of the day.

[KalelChase]

Great job team,

I'm leaning towards Flavs advice to not say much at night. More tomorrow.

[KalelChase]

If we assume scum would avoid ending up on the same wagon, BionicMole is the most likley, because Demon voted together with rivera D2 and D3.

Xorx, I had you down as Townleaning Bionic... Would be looking for confirmation/correction/explanation tomorrow.

[FlaviusAetius]

STOP TALKINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

Your logic isn't necessarily wrong, it's just that I think the benefits of talking outweighs that of silence :D

although, was wondering - what would you do in games with day chat?

we already have 48 hours worth of talking thats more than enough to discuss, 24 hour, especially with mafia being able to openly communicate not a good idea!
and we already have day chat, so what do you mean

[ND]

uh why wouldn't people want to talk during the night phase. What kind of weirdo logic is that @Flav?

[CmdrLikely]

Talking at night has the same risks as talking during the day? What am I missing?

[CmdrLikely]

Talking at night has the same risks as talking during the day? What am I missing?

Edit typo:
Talking at night has the same risks as talking during the day. What am I missing?

[ND]

It's dumb, post your reads, your cases, talk about your cat or your favorite pint. I don't know what kind of weirdo logic it is not to make use of a phase to scumhunt. It's actually anti-town not to make use of a phase. People need to get their reads out. The mafia already have their qts so not talking actually puts us at a disadvantage because they can already talk.

[ND]

What a nutty thing to suggest if you ask me.

[Vecna]

I need to answer further questions tomorrow. That's all for today. But really, I had no reason to kill Bunny. I didn't think about whom I would kill but Bunny, maybe I would try some people townreading me so I could gain credits later.
You are slandering me Tom.

Time to catch up on what actually happened during D3

Yavuz seems pretty towny to me straight off the bat. A level of genuineness to his posts, and he's actually kidding around about the nightkill and Tom accusing him.

[Vecna]

RIP Bunny and Damo.

Two dead VTs isn't the worst result for the night and neither the better. Bunny was pretty towny but Damo is a weird choice, he was mostly scumread (maybe Jacko or he crumbed something that I didn't see).

I don't think we need to lynch ND today. I also don't think Chaqa is a good lynch for today, at least a lynch based only on his fake claim.

I am starting to get a lot of doubts about Vecna and Bozo, I usually get strong vibes (scummy or towny) from them and this game they agree just null. And Hosuke and Kit need to start playing.

This post strongly reads that Damo was the nightkill for the moriarty guys.

Also, Bozo is most likely not on team Moriarity.

Im surprised Rdrivera would take a stance against lynching Chaqa there though, as scum those are not usually things he does to try and speak out against town lynches.

Regardless, if Chaqa was scum im pretty sure id be dead by now, and the nightkills wouldve looked very different (besides N1, he would totally be baited to kill Nd). That dude is usually super scared of the usual suspects and always wants to kill them asap.

[xorxes]

If we assume scum would avoid ending up on the same wagon, BionicMole is the most likley, because Demon voted together with rivera D2 and D3.

Xorx, I had you down as Townleaning Bionic... Would be looking for confirmation/correction/explanation tomorrow.

What does it matter if I was townleanimg them? If they are the only one left after eliminating all other candidates, then they become the most likely. New info -> new reads.