M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[Vecna]

yeah burying him in a ton of nonsense sure will serve wonders to get a proper answer.

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTES:

##CALL GM If riddler tries to kill Porky Pig, must they correctly identify Porky’s power to succeed?

No. Identifying the role / slot is sufficient, because the Riddler role is considered challenging enough.

##CALL GM can a bomb protect from riddler?

No, because the Riddler's guessing game is not a visit.

##CALL GM Can the doctor save from the riddler? What if the doctor is one of the victims?

Yes, the Doctor can save one of the Riddler's victims.

If the Riddler targets the Doctor, the Doctor would die before saving anyone else. Doctor saves happen *after* kills.

##CALL GM If Porky’s power is the bodyguard redirect a kill power, can he protect someone from the riddler? What if he is also targeted?

There is no "Bodyguard". Do you mean the "Absorber"? Yes, theoretically, the Absorber could take the Riddler kill.

##CALL GM Can the jailor protect someone from the riddler by putting the victim in jail? Does it protect all the victims for that night?

If one of the Riddler's targets is in the Jail, that person will not die. This has no effect on the rest of the Riddler's guesses.

##CALL GM If the riddler is in jail, can they still use their power? What if the jailor kills them?

No they can't. If they die, even less so.


I hope this makes you all very happy.

[Vecna]

lol what. I've never disagreed with anything you've said more.

the fact that suddenly a bunch of people were talking about the band means that they were not hidden very well, no?

Like, Chaqa's crumbs were well hidden. These are like "hidden, but meant to be spotted".

It's not whether or not people would notice him talking about Nirvana, it's whether talking about Nirvana because he talked about it last game as bugs can even be considered a crumb. And then him insinuating that he was directing those "crumbs" at people specifically because they were in that game...

I don't know, it doesn't make sense to me.

thats a different discussion though, no?

My point with those statements was only to counter Tom B's argument of the "crumbs" being too well hidden to ever be spotted, which is blatantly false.

Like I said back then though, it still doesnt matter much because Bunny would likely do this shit as both alignments if he thought of it (either to do silly fancy plays hoping to be a hero, or to pretend to do that for towncred as scum).

I guess im just having some major communication malfunction or whatever this game because its starting to feel like noone is getting any of my points that im trying to convey.

[kgray]

lol what. I've never disagreed with anything you've said more.

the fact that suddenly a bunch of people were talking about the band means that they were not hidden very well, no?

Like, Chaqa's crumbs were well hidden. These are like "hidden, but meant to be spotted".

It's not whether or not people would notice him talking about Nirvana, it's whether talking about Nirvana because he talked about it last game as bugs can even be considered a crumb. And then him insinuating that he was directing those "crumbs" at people specifically because they were in that game...

I don't know, it doesn't make sense to me.

Because it would be one thing if he were really bugs again and the point of crumbing was to prove it, and he explain why those references were crumbs. But I don't see how he actually thinks it would draw a NK since I don't know who would have picked up on that as being a crumb.

It makes a lot more sense to me for scum!Bunny to leave those "crumbs" to fake claim at some point than for town!Bunny to use them to draw a NK away from a PR.

[BunnyGo]

yeah burying him in a ton of nonsense sure will serve wonders to get a proper answer.

Seemed to

[Vecna]

ok, I take that back bunny, well done, it worked. I got my answer.

lah-die-da

[Vecna]

Guess that was actually quite funny

[ghug]

Chaqa "I think we can relatively safely eliminate Maniac as scum for now since he was the major counterwagon to Summit." Jeez I spend the whole game telling people I'm scum and no one believes me. I'm soooo going to try this when I'm really scum.

This post is scummy.

[ghug]

That’s all for now, thanks for clarifying GM.

Got 'im

[Donny Dude]

GM NOTE

Holy shit, give me a moment.

Bunny, You are going to drive Jamie to drink at this rate.

[BunnyGo]

And now date night. Don’t do anything I wouldn’t do while I’m gone.

[Vecna]

the fact that suddenly a bunch of people were talking about the band means that they were not hidden very well, no?

Like, Chaqa's crumbs were well hidden. These are like "hidden, but meant to be spotted".

It's not whether or not people would notice him talking about Nirvana, it's whether talking about Nirvana because he talked about it last game as bugs can even be considered a crumb. And then him insinuating that he was directing those "crumbs" at people specifically because they were in that game...

I don't know, it doesn't make sense to me.

Because it would be one thing if he were really bugs again and the point of crumbing was to prove it, and he explain why those references were crumbs. But I don't see how he actually thinks it would draw a NK since I don't know who would have picked up on that as being a crumb.

It makes a lot more sense to me for scum!Bunny to leave those "crumbs" to fake claim at some point than for town!Bunny to use them to draw a NK away from a PR.

and thats a completely valid pov. if tom B had phrased it like that then this whole nonsense-argument mightve never happened and we'd probably all be the better for it.

Still, trying to forge a proper fake-crumb if thats what youre trying to do aint easy. You need to make sure its seen, while also not making the alarm bells go off that youre actually trying to make people think youre the cop.

Anyways, can I be done writing posts now where it appears im defending bunny all day long? Because tomorrow is gonna be insufferable if he does get lynched and flips scum.

[ghug]

##CALL GM Why does the riddler text say "exact role" if that's not what you meant?

[ghug]

You don't have to answer that. Just wanted to remind everyone that bo is the worst.

[Vecna]

hey ghug, lets play a game

[Jamiet99uk]

You don't have to answer that. Just wanted to remind everyone that bo is the worst.

[Jamiet99uk]

But also:

0. The GMs reserve the right to adjudicate individual scenarios that arise during the course of the game at their discretion.

[kgray]

It's not whether or not people would notice him talking about Nirvana, it's whether talking about Nirvana because he talked about it last game as bugs can even be considered a crumb. And then him insinuating that he was directing those "crumbs" at people specifically because they were in that game...

I don't know, it doesn't make sense to me.

Because it would be one thing if he were really bugs again and the point of crumbing was to prove it, and he explain why those references were crumbs. But I don't see how he actually thinks it would draw a NK since I don't know who would have picked up on that as being a crumb.

It makes a lot more sense to me for scum!Bunny to leave those "crumbs" to fake claim at some point than for town!Bunny to use them to draw a NK away from a PR.

and thats a completely valid pov. if tom B had phrased it like that then this whole nonsense-argument mightve never happened and we'd probably all be the better for it.

Still, trying to forge a proper fake-crumb if thats what youre trying to do aint easy. You need to make sure its seen, while also not making the alarm bells go off that youre actually trying to make people think youre the cop.

Anyways, can I be done writing posts now where it appears im defending bunny all day long? Because tomorrow is gonna be insufferable if he does get daykilled and flips scum.

Okay, then if you agree that they're unlikely to be seen as crumbs then I guess I don't understand your objection to the way Tom dealt with this.

[Maniac]

Chaqa "I think we can relatively safely eliminate Maniac as scum for now since he was the major counterwagon to Summit." Jeez I spend the whole game telling people I'm scum and no one believes me. I'm soooo going to try this when I'm really scum.

This post is scummy.

At last someone believes me, my work here is done.

[Chaqa]

Oh that's B.S. The role says "However, in order to kill them, you must correctly identify their exact role." WTF does EXACT ROLE mean if not that.

Flavor name is not role.

Dumb.

This is now TWO things that are conflicting with the game as posted

/rant