Mafia 1033 - The Next Generation [Hidden]

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamiet's vote on me is apparently because I have apparently been lurking. Fair.

Is that what I said?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

commenting on random posts because the thread is dead

Apparently we can no longer post images because the "Board Attachment Quota" has been exceeded.

Sad.

Ye i tried to attack a photo of your mom but it took up all the bandwidth

Potentially will trying to start a fight I guess?
Very low quality
however will has some other decent posts

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Jamiet's vote on me is apparently because I have apparently been lurking. Fair.

Is that what I said?

##Vote Diplomacy

The Dr Who stuff is fake, and he has done nothing else.

reason 1: you don't like my roleplay. get over it. We're playing mafia
reason 2: I have done "nothing else". Sounds to me like you're suggesting I'm lurking

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

In fact... that is for everyone. Would you have gone along with the plan?

first of all, I would have publicly and very loudly agreed, and then not used my phaser during the first night (assuming the rules were NOT changed to make the kill optional) on the assumption that maf would not kill me given I was publicly agreeing.

as for the actual post, this is towny for obvious reasons. Granted, it could be that darg was trying to take initiative to get townread early, but this day is so slow that I fail to see maf actually trying to get anything done when it would be easy to blend in with the low-quality posters.

TLDR: I townread dargorygel

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

The more town we have alive at night the greater the chance of a mafdeath

its the opposite.

if we no kill, mafia might no kill as well.

people would waste their phasers for no benefit to town at all.

no kill is anti-town

Fair point. ##unvote

So the thing about damo's no-kill vote is that it's not much of a stretch to reach the conclusion that we aren't getting anywhere, and I don't see damo playing like this as town. If damo is scum, though, this is probably an effort to waste time rather than a genuine attempt to get a no-kill vote d1. Scumread, but not going to vote here because the bona wagon is also good and already has 3 votes.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I like this post, luke foodwalker.

Do you think that damo is scumo for wanting a no kill?

Darg is town but we knew that already

Also i dont think damo would advocate for it as scum when it can very easily be shot down so i think damo is also town for this

Will, what was it before this that made you think darg was town?

first, @Will please answer this
second, foodcoats is town because of posts like these

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamiet's vote on me is apparently because I have apparently been lurking. Fair.

Is that what I said?

##Vote Diplomacy

The Dr Who stuff is fake, and he has done nothing else.

reason 1: you don't like my roleplay. get over it. We're playing mafia
reason 2: I have done "nothing else". Sounds to me like you're suggesting I'm lurking

It was your omission of reason 1 that I was talking about. Thank you.

[foodcoats]

The scummiest progression I have seen so far is Jamie’s lean on DW.

Jamie suggested DW was scum in responding to my “Who is scum?” with “Yes, he is” - not, “Yes, who is?” as in “who is scum” but saying, “Yes, Who is scum” while DW was roleplaying as Doctor Who. However, he never directly answered my question as to whether this was his meaning.

Jamie then came actually moved onto and voted DW for the “fakery” of his Who roleplay, even though this kind of behaviour is by its nature “fake,” and for doing “Nothing else” despite there being much clearer lurkers in the game.

This suggests to me that Jamie is fixated on DW inauthentically, from a scum mindset. He singled out DW a priori but didn’t want to address this baseless fixation when I called it, until he had come up with a small reason to actually scumread DW.

Also, this says nothing about DW’s alignment.

[Jamiet99uk]

The scummiest progression I have seen so far is Jamie’s lean on DW.

Jamie suggested DW was scum in responding to my “Who is scum?” with “Yes, he is” - not, “Yes, who is?” as in “who is scum” but saying, “Yes, Who is scum” while DW was roleplaying as Doctor Who. However, he never directly answered my question as to whether this was his meaning.

Jamie then came actually moved onto and voted DW for the “fakery” of his Who roleplay, even though this kind of behaviour is by its nature “fake,” and for doing “Nothing else” despite there being much clearer lurkers in the game.

This suggests to me that Jamie is fixated on DW inauthentically, from a scum mindset. He singled out DW a priori but didn’t want to address this baseless fixation when I called it, until he had come up with a small reason to actually scumread DW.

Also, this says nothing about DW’s alignment.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sShMA85pv8M

[Bonatogether]

I am sus of the ghug/bona connection. Famished conflict, joke voting but not. RED'S entrance, particularly bonas response tastes sus. I don't want to vote Red out on D1, so... sorry dear bona...

##VOTE BONATOGETHER

i never liked you anyways 🥲

[Bonatogether]

I am insulted
die, fellow human

##vote bonatogether

ok this is funny

[foodcoats]

Good night. I am around and I have a phaser.

Does anyone else think this may be a townslip?

A scum would have seen the role PMs are identical and all town have phasers. A town might not read carefully and think they are special for having a phaser.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Good night. I am around and I have a phaser.

Does anyone else think this may be a townslip?

A scum would have seen the role PMs are identical and all town have phasers. A town might not read carefully and think they are special for having a phaser.

I find it ridiculous that someone could read anything at all about the setup and then not know that everyone (except maf) has phasers. To me, this is a slightly scummy way of saying "Hi, I am town"

[ghug]

Jamiet's vote on me is apparently because I have apparently been lurking. Fair.
Foodcoat's vote on Red is based on lurking. Fair
ghug... still has a joke vote out???
dargogrygel thinks there's a ghug/bona connection, which I am skeptical of because I tr ghug
damo... claims to have solved d1???
Bonatogether also has a joke vote out
wait
the two people who dargorygel thinks are linked have both kept out early joke votes and made low-quality, 1-2 sentence posts.
##vote bonatogether

Why do you TR me if all you have to say about me is questioning my joke vote?

[ghug]

In fact... that is for everyone. Would you have gone along with the plan?

first of all, I would have publicly and very loudly agreed, and then not used my phaser during the first night (assuming the rules were NOT changed to make the kill optional) on the assumption that maf would not kill me given I was publicly agreeing.

as for the actual post, this is towny for obvious reasons. Granted, it could be that darg was trying to take initiative to get townread early, but this day is so slow that I fail to see maf actually trying to get anything done when it would be easy to blend in with the low-quality posters.

TLDR: I townread dargorygel

I disagree. Darg knew we changed the rules. He was expressing an opinion irrelevant to the game that he formed before he got his role because he had a bone to pick, which fits more in the mold of scum talking about mechanics to avoid contributing than anything else.

[ghug]

Good night. I am around and I have a phaser.

Does anyone else think this may be a townslip?

A scum would have seen the role PMs are identical and all town have phasers. A town might not read carefully and think they are special for having a phaser.

You think rd would claim something he thought not everybody had first thing day one?

[Bonatogether]

Good night. I am around and I have a phaser.

Does anyone else think this may be a townslip?

A scum would have seen the role PMs are identical and all town have phasers. A town might not read carefully and think they are special for having a phaser.

townslips aren't real so vetoed

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Jamiet's vote on me is apparently because I have apparently been lurking. Fair.
Foodcoat's vote on Red is based on lurking. Fair
ghug... still has a joke vote out???
dargogrygel thinks there's a ghug/bona connection, which I am skeptical of because I tr ghug
damo... claims to have solved d1???
Bonatogether also has a joke vote out
wait
the two people who dargorygel thinks are linked have both kept out early joke votes and made low-quality, 1-2 sentence posts.
##vote bonatogether

Why do you TR me if all you have to say about me is questioning my joke vote?

Good point. I should actually post that.

This is a cruel and unnecessary lie and I hope that you die on Saturday.

I spent some time reviewing my poor performance in the last game I played, and despite how much I helped the mafia on the last day, we still would have won if you and BunnyGo had RBed Fluminator and worcej when I said I would go along with it. Why did you lock in your RB vote on me an hour before EOD?

You really want to do this?

My opinion of your town play was already low, but I didn't believe you'd play that poorly as town, so Occam's razor said you were scum. I apologize for overestimating you. I won't do it again. I figured at that point that my words weren't moving anyone and that locking my vote could prove my sincerity. Even that didn't work on Glitter, so it wouldn't have gone any better if I'd been right, but nothing else was working, so I don't really fault myself for trying it.

If the question is why I doubted you, this was explained quite thoroughly at the time. Why are you trying to pick a flight?

If you (ghug) continued argument without the lines in bold, you could probably goad bozo into wasting a bunch more time arguing about it, and would share the blame. The bolded lines, in my opinion, prompted the end of the argument, which is not something a mafia ghug would want.

To be clear, this was my opinion before I looked at the jokevotes and such and decided to vote Bona.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Unpopular opinion: I know people like to only vote lurkers if they continue lurking for several days, but by d2-d3 there's usually enough grudges and arguments going around that everybody mostly forgets about the lurkers.
##vote rdivera

[bozotheclown]

Good night. I am around and I have a phaser.

Does anyone else think this may be a townslip?

A scum would have seen the role PMs are identical and all town have phasers. A town might not read carefully and think they are special for having a phaser.

I find it ridiculous that someone could read anything at all about the setup and then not know that everyone (except maf) has phasers. To me, this is a slightly scummy way of saying "Hi, I am town"

I also took that as a way of saying he was town.