Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[Balki Bartokomous]

@MLQ, why won't you talk to us? What do we have to do to get you to join us?

[thamrick]

Faking a RB.

That's fair. I guess you'd have to weigh how willing to risk fake claiming I'd be. Especially given the knowledge that Maniac isn't claiming RB. As pointed out before, a RB doesn't clear me.

Regardless, assume I was rb'd whether you believe me or not. Now make the cases both sides.

The only reason for scum to RB you is if they thought you were Cop. The same is probably valid for the Nurse.

Even if Nurse thought I was Cop, why would they protect me and not Maniac or Tom? I was being pretty much universally scumread. Beyond the actual scum, I feel like I was one of the safest NK targets.

I feel like your logic is better than that. Reaction testing me to see if I'd hint that I was Cop?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Welp, the new forum makes it pretty easy to play mafia if it discloses who is what alignment.

WHO IS ONLINE
Users browsing this forum: Balki Bartokomous, DemonRHK, Ezio, MeanLaQueefa, thamrick, Tom Bombadil and 1 guest

[DemonRHK]

RHK looks super scummy, but there's no reason for him to be lynched, shot, or cc'd today. All that can wait a long while.

"He wooks vewwy vewwy bad and I don't like him. But no one should worry about him or try to find out if he's telling the truth."

[DemonRHK]

EDIT: I should have said 'wike' instead of 'like', gets the baby talk across better.

[Ezio]

RHK keep doing your thing. Keep scumreading/pushing/watching/etc. When you get NK'd by the mafia if you are Watcher will give us lots to go off of.
It's fair to say you have played this poorly as either alignment as that early claim served essentially no purpose, and taunting me does essentially nothing to further your case.
Trust in the system to figure out your alignment and trust in town to use your info once you die.

[MeanLaQueefa]

Balki calm your borker and get at least 1 other scum read that you can harass intermittently between me please.

I've been rereading the thread (I always do that before reading the recent stuff, so calling me out to talk to you when back reading will never work), I haven't been around much because today is my mom's birthday and we're doing family stuff, I just read EoN.

I'm very sad my bae is dead.

I'll get some reads up later tonight and be back on in a while, I still haven't had the chance to go and reread after rjm got lynched, so I need some time to collect stuff. ATM tom's claim last night was the scummiest thing I've seen all game and only served to bait out the real cop, so ##vote tom, #forBrainBomb

[rdrivera2005]

I am not nervous, I even suggested a bet with Thamrick.

I still think posting reads have nothing to do with alignment (both Jamiet and RJ did one) and suggesting it in the middle of that day look like your want to divert the discussion and frame people with no reasoning.

I still think you are scum, but suggesting to shoot a uncced PR claim is dumb as hell, so I don't know what you find weird. Weird is thamrick wanting to shoot you after the claim and then sheep you.

And look again my reads, I didn't scumread BB, I scumread Bozo and Reedeer (and you and Mean), I even answered this to Maniac later.

I see you made a bet. I think you're confident it would never happen as well.

Posting reads has everything to do with alignment. One of the most difficult parts of playing scum is knowing where to put your scumbuddies so it doesn't either out them or look too fake. I'm being scumread to shit. Everything I say today gets ignored, and if the nurse doesn't believe me, hell I don't even really want nurse protection tonight. If I'm alive D4 all I do is distract from actual scum hunting. If I don't watch, I'm useless. Let me have the watch or let me die I say.

It's not out of the ordinary to want to shoot. If people think hard enough that I'm scum, they want me gone now, so if I would flip scum they can reread and look for the others. Basic safe play is force the mafia to make the decision on me.

I didn't say you scumread him, I said you had him fucking dipped. You took his cute feline face and shoved it in turpentine. You monster.

You still didn't explain what epiphanies you had in the last 10 minutes both days to end up on the right side of history.

Demon, I expect more from you. I didn't have any epiphany, I just know how to play as town. Next to EOD you choose between the main wagons so you can limit the influence scum have in the lynch. And Jamiet look more scummy then ND and Balki and RJ looks a lot more scummy then Vash and Tom. It's not rocket science.

[rdrivera2005]

That's fair. I guess you'd have to weigh how willing to risk fake claiming I'd be. Especially given the knowledge that Maniac isn't claiming RB. As pointed out before, a RB doesn't clear me.

Regardless, assume I was rb'd whether you believe me or not. Now make the cases both sides.

The only reason for scum to RB you is if they thought you were Cop. The same is probably valid for the Nurse.

Even if Nurse thought I was Cop, why would they protect me and not Maniac or Tom? I was being pretty much universally scumread. Beyond the actual scum, I feel like I was one of the safest NK targets.

I feel like your logic is better than that. Reaction testing me to see if I'd hint that I was Cop?

I told you I didn't think you were RBed. You asked me to imagine a distopic world were you actually we're RBed. I did and now your accuse me of fishing? WTF?

[thamrick]

Balki calm your borker and get at least 1 other scum read that you can harass intermittently between me please.

I've been rereading the thread (I always do that before reading the recent stuff, so calling me out to talk to you when back reading will never work), I haven't been around much because today is my mom's birthday and we're doing family stuff, I just read EoN.

I'm very sad my bae is dead.

I'll get some reads up later tonight and be back on in a while, I still haven't had the chance to go and reread after rjm got lynched, so I need some time to collect stuff. ATM tom's claim last night was the scummiest thing I've seen all game and only served to bait out the real cop, so ##vote tom, #forBrainBomb

You didn't even bother to read BB's role? He wasn't cop.

##VOTE MeanLaQueefa

We'll settle this later rdrivera

[thamrick]

I told you I didn't think you were RBed. You asked me to imagine a distopic world were you actually we're RBed. I did and now your accuse me of fishing? WTF?

You just mad that you and your scum buddies mistakenly RB'd me and now made another townclear?

[MeanLaQueefa]

Uhhh, tom claimed cop last night tham, that's who I was referring to, not bb. The hashtag was because he was my bae and wanted tom lynched yesterday.

In your mind, how does not reading a dead person's role make me scum anyway?

[rdrivera2005]

I told you I didn't think you were RBed. You asked me to imagine a distopic world were you actually we're RBed. I did and now your accuse me of fishing? WTF?

You just mad that you and your scum buddies mistakenly RB'd me and now made another townclear?

How someone mistakenly roleblocks? And I am not mad, we are wining and if scum really roleblocked you they are just desperate.

[rdrivera2005]

Uhhh, tom claimed cop last night tham, that's who I was referring to, not bb. The hashtag was because he was my bae and wanted tom lynched yesterday.

In your mind, how does not reading a dead person's role make me scum anyway?

Interesting last scum team brain listed was

[quoteMy analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}[/quote]

And you want to lynch Tom in behalf of Brain?

##vote MeanLaQueefa

[rdrivera2005]

Anyway, need to sleep. See you tomorrow.

[thamrick]

Uhhh, tom claimed cop last night tham, that's who I was referring to, not bb. The hashtag was because he was my bae and wanted tom lynched yesterday.

In your mind, how does not reading a dead person's role make me scum anyway?

Because you don't care. You just want townies dead.

So you think Tom's claim makes him scum. That would be uber bold for scum at this point. Best case scenario, they trade a scum for 2 PRs, assuming cop CC's and watcher chooses to report that no one visited Tom. They're still at a HUGE disadvantage. 2 scum to 12 town with a townclear, a GS, and a Nurse to deal with.

[Ezio]

MLQ why exactly are you voting Tom?

[MeanLaQueefa]

Tom was almost lynched yesterday, he probably thought he was going soon, which he absolutely should, and thought he could grab one or two PR's with him. It is obvious.

They're already at a huge disadvantage and they know they can't win if the cop lives for much longer, outing the cop is their win condition now that the witch is dead, can't you see that? I'm decently sure you're town tham, but grow a brain, it is obviously tom. You didn't even answer my question, and you vote against me is total horse bork.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I'll get some reads up later tonight and be back on in a while, I still haven't had the chance to go and reread after rjm got lynched, so I need some time to collect stuff.

Thanks. Looking forward to this.

[DemonRHK]

Demon, I expect more from you. I didn't have any epiphany, I just know how to play as town. Next to EOD you choose between the main wagons so you can limit the influence scum have in the lynch. And Jamiet look more scummy then ND and Balki and RJ looks a lot more scummy then Vash and Tom. It's not rocket science.

[Cue music]

Do you wanna make a hedge vote?~
Come on let's fucking take a guess~
You never townread me anymore~
Let the accusations soar~
You help make end of day a mess...~
We used to townread each other~
And now we don't~
I wish you were on my siiiiiiiide!~
Do you wanna make a hedge vote?~
It doesn't have to be a real vote~

...Okay bye...~