MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[summit_fever]

who are you summit? what do you stand for? you've given me townie vibes in all other games can you do it agian pls?

Maybe. I probably need a break. Why'd you vote Vecna?

i get stupid paranoid way too much

Anything in particular?

[Vecna]

the wifey keeps talking about the gay neighbour making love on the opposing balcony.

I dno how to feel about this at all

film it obviously

Do you think she knows it's with Vecna?

thatd be quite the trick

[Vecna]

Anyways it's done. I think there is at least 1 scum on the day 1 Bunny wagon. Maybe 2. I think ghug and seth are less likely to flip scum compared to the others.

This one. No scum answers like that when being questioned

Why not? Would it not be a pretty benign explanation? Suggests 1 scum, or even more, on that wagon. That's not a huge stretch to make. So if scum were being questioned with that exact question, how would you expect them to answer?
[/quote]

its the "anyways, its done" part that did it for me. Not sure if thats enough to TR the slot over, but it reads pretty good.

[TrPrado]

Laying in bed on my phone, listening to music, perfect reading conditions for Mafia.

[TrPrado]

Ask and you shall receive!

##VOTE WORCEJ

What's scummy about worcej?

I haven't been an asshole. Remember his crappy post about that?

I don’t! What was it and why has it struck a cord with you?

[TrPrado]

Worcej in M54: "If I get lynched for being an asshole then those who vote for me are actually not trying to sort this game out," and "I understand why you would be upset, but I am an asshole/bully when it comes to things like these." Before ultimately..

worcej has died, he was Albert Caquot, a Vanilla Town

But it's M47 where he really shines. "Being an asshole like I am is not scummy btw, it’s just rude," and "I know I am rough and annoying and an asshole..." and "No, I am just simply an asshole." Which led to...

The town gathered again to try to continue their streak and cornered worcej, unaware that a creature of myth would be their victim. They truly did not know shit about the Congo.

WORCEJ has died. He was the OKAPI, a Vanilla Town.

Contrast that to M1010 where, as I pointed out before, he won as scum in no small part because he was congenial and kept his nose clean.

Congratulations to Jamiet, worcej, and damo for the win as mafia!

I was also worried about him buddying me in that game, because worcej and I often butt heads, but we hadn't that game, and we haven't this game. It's not proof, but it's good enough for me on D2.

Huh? Isn’t it realistic for someone to want to be better at the game if they get repeatedly voted out as VT for the same behavior?

[summit_fever]

Summit has consistently been responding to pressure by cherry picking or ignoring it. I told him he ignored my question, he asked me to repeat it and when I did I didn't get an answer. But he REALLY needed to post his EON reads instead. Not liking this.

Couldn't say it any better. I like this wagon.

##vote summit

You think I'm scum due to my interactions with Prado?

I don't really get it. Foodcoats did a lot of damage tunnelling xorxes and myself in M1011. Why condone this type of behaviour? At least Foodcoats was pleasant enough to apologise after. If that is forthcoming in this instance I'll be genuinely surprised.

This guy has been on my ass with disingenuitiy since early in day 1 with a "I don't think you're town" and then has the temerity to act insulted I didn't respond to that. Then it goes on and on with disagreement over shit I didn't even say. He isn't asking questions trying to ascertain the truth. He's in a tunnel.

[TrPrado]

No, but everyone has now complied (of sorts).

Bo and Durga prevaricated the most.

What do you mean prevaricated? They left ambiguity?

debated delayed dithered

What’s the distinction between them and myself here? Vecna praised me for being “stubborn” about it is there some kind of significant difference?

[TrPrado]

Summit has consistently been responding to pressure by cherry picking or ignoring it. I told him he ignored my question, he asked me to repeat it and when I did I didn't get an answer. But he REALLY needed to post his EON reads instead. Not liking this.

Couldn't say it any better. I like this wagon.

##vote summit

You think I'm scum due to my interactions with Prado?

I don't really get it. Foodcoats did a lot of damage tunnelling xorxes and myself in M1011. Why condone this type of behaviour? At least Foodcoats was pleasant enough to apologise after. If that is forthcoming in this instance I'll be genuinely surprised.

This guy has been on my ass with disingenuitiy since early in day 1 with a "I don't think you're town" and then has the temerity to act insulted I didn't respond to that. Then it goes on and on with disagreement over shit I didn't even say. He isn't asking questions trying to ascertain the truth. He's in a tunnel.

Oh the early D1 thing was a joke, I just wanted someone to say something about a different topic. I genuinely did not care or have a read on you at the time.

[TrPrado]

The EOD stuff, on the other hand, is stuff I am very concerned about.

[bozotheclown]

BunnyGo has more posts than flash, Hamilton, Yoyoyozo, and the Chaqa and emc slots combined. It would be kind of funny if those were the 5 scum.

[summit_fever]

Couldn't say it any better. I like this wagon.

##vote summit

You think I'm scum due to my interactions with Prado?

I don't really get it. Foodcoats did a lot of damage tunnelling xorxes and myself in M1011. Why condone this type of behaviour? At least Foodcoats was pleasant enough to apologise after. If that is forthcoming in this instance I'll be genuinely surprised.

This guy has been on my ass with disingenuitiy since early in day 1 with a "I don't think you're town" and then has the temerity to act insulted I didn't respond to that. Then it goes on and on with disagreement over shit I didn't even say. He isn't asking questions trying to ascertain the truth. He's in a tunnel.

Oh the early D1 thing was a joke, I just wanted someone to say something about a different topic. I genuinely did not care or have a read on you at the time.

It was a joke? Then why demand a response?

[TrPrado]

as annoying as it is to admit it, bozo is probz town

I am finally betting some towny vibes from you. Bozo is town, Damo is town, Durga is probably town. Prado is probably town. Ghug is probably scum.

Why is ghug scum?

[TrPrado]

You think I'm scum due to my interactions with Prado?

I don't really get it. Foodcoats did a lot of damage tunnelling xorxes and myself in M1011. Why condone this type of behaviour? At least Foodcoats was pleasant enough to apologise after. If that is forthcoming in this instance I'll be genuinely surprised.

This guy has been on my ass with disingenuitiy since early in day 1 with a "I don't think you're town" and then has the temerity to act insulted I didn't respond to that. Then it goes on and on with disagreement over shit I didn't even say. He isn't asking questions trying to ascertain the truth. He's in a tunnel.

Oh the early D1 thing was a joke, I just wanted someone to say something about a different topic. I genuinely did not care or have a read on you at the time.

It was a joke? Then why demand a response?

I wouldn’t post it if I didn’t want a response, serious or not.

[bozotheclown]

If you pick any 5 players in this game, there is a 78.3% chance that at least one is scum.

[TrPrado]

As I start to catch up here, and holy shit, it's like an endless Buster Keaton clip.

Where I sit at this point, and this is only from very quick, cursory reads.

Seth's "goodbye" to Bunny was pretty scummy to me.

Durga: in my games with them, they've been equanimous. Town, scum, both the same. I've got to dig into those two games to determine anything more. And then the questions...the questions.

So if I have learned anything at this point in my mafia career, in an overall sense, think before writing. I'm trying to do that.

Secondly, as town, when there are better town around, stay out of their way as they investigate unless there is a something that can strengthen a read. I'm really just getting here into the game, so give it time.

??? The questions? Think before writing? What was the point in writing this? Who was intended to read it?

[TrPrado]

##VOTE Prado

Literally all the guy does is twist facts to hammer on summit.

I don’t think you’ve read summit properly if you think the facts have been twisted.

[summit_fever]

##VOTE Prado

Literally all the guy does is twist facts to hammer on summit.

I don’t think you’ve read summit properly if you think the facts have been twisted.

Why am I scum?

[summit_fever]

If you pick any 5 players in this game, there is a 78.3% chance that at least one is scum.

Bozo, come on.

[TrPrado]

While looking at "mourning" as a tell, HR's passing really went by mildly.

My focus for the next while is to investigate: 1) what made HR a choice for NK1 and 2) Who were they reading close enough that might have contributed to question 1.

What are you getting out of death reactions? What makes you think that indicates something?