MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Summit is so town

why?

I can't remember lemme find it

He had this post with some very ghuggy town logic that I just can't see being worth faking

[Durga]

why?

I can't remember lemme find it

He had this post with some very ghuggy town logic that I just can't see being worth faking

yeah you're just not helpful

[ghug]

Did you even read my wall o' quotes?

I skimmed. It was long.

Why'd you townread Bunny?

Mostly this post.

Partly I’m tired. I have a deadline at work with a project I hate.

Partly I’m tired of the general meta game here of us enrolling more players in games than actually want to play. Like, how about we just all post 10 random shouts then flip some coins remove players and actually start to play?

It’s kinda dull after a while. I’m a bit frustrated with my ability as Town to cut through this BS. It’s just a bit easier as scum. Hell, even last game my specific goal was to look like a perennial Daykill possibility but never actually get it. That was EASY. So somewhat unrewarding.

Reading people when they don’t show up is impossible. I started playing forum
Mafia because I believed it was too easy for scum and I was looking to be proven wrong and learn something. I’m still waiting for that.

Anyways it's done. I think there is at least 1 scum on the day 1 Bunny wagon. Maybe 2. I think ghug and seth are less likely to flip scum compared to the others.

This one. No scum answers like that when being questioned

[summit_fever]

While looking at "mourning" as a tell, HR's passing really went by mildly.

My focus for the next while is to investigate: 1) what made HR a choice for NK1 and 2) Who were they reading close enough that might have contributed to question 1.

I'd guess they thought they were getting good odds of hitting a 3p/PR and if not he is a good town player.

who are you summit? what do you stand for? you've given me townie vibes in all other games can you do it agian pls?

Maybe. I probably need a break. Why'd you vote Vecna?

[Durga]

I'd guess they thought they were getting good odds of hitting a 3p/PR and if not he is a good town player.

who are you summit? what do you stand for? you've given me townie vibes in all other games can you do it agian pls?

Maybe. I probably need a break. Why'd you vote Vecna?

i get stupid paranoid way too much

[ghug]

What even is Vecna's scum meta?

[Hamilton Brian]

Anyways it's done. I think there is at least 1 scum on the day 1 Bunny wagon. Maybe 2. I think ghug and seth are less likely to flip scum compared to the others.

This one. No scum answers like that when being questioned
[/quote]

Why not? Would it not be a pretty benign explanation? Suggests 1 scum, or even more, on that wagon. That's not a huge stretch to make. So if scum were being questioned with that exact question, how would you expect them to answer?

[ghug]

Anyways it's done. I think there is at least 1 scum on the day 1 Bunny wagon. Maybe 2. I think ghug and seth are less likely to flip scum compared to the others.

This one. No scum answers like that when being questioned

Why not? Would it not be a pretty benign explanation? Suggests 1 scum, or even more, on that wagon. That's not a huge stretch to make. So if scum were being questioned with that exact question, how would you expect them to answer?

It's more the part where he pointed at one post and didn't elaborate for his bunny townread.

[Durga]

This one. No scum answers like that when being questioned

Why not? Would it not be a pretty benign explanation? Suggests 1 scum, or even more, on that wagon. That's not a huge stretch to make. So if scum were being questioned with that exact question, how would you expect them to answer?

It's more the part where he pointed at one post and didn't elaborate for his bunny townread.

Sorry ghug, I don't get it

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE
Apparently this community desires to go back to "hidden" status on the forum. That can be arranged.

[Durga]

##GM NOTE
Apparently this community desires to go back to "hidden" status on the forum. That can be arranged.

??? what

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE
Apparently this community desires to go back to "hidden" status on the forum. That can be arranged.

??? what

I arrived home and found complaints in my in-box about some of the language that apparently was stuck on the top of the forum in this thread. In The past, this is what led to the inconvenience of having to hide our games. It's simple. Self police (which I prefer) or be policed.

Good night.

[Hamilton Brian]

It's more the part where he pointed at one post and didn't elaborate for his bunny townread.

Come on. Then don't you challenge them on it? It’s like you’re just giving Summit a free pass.

[Durga]

##GM NOTE
Apparently this community desires to go back to "hidden" status on the forum. That can be arranged.

??? what

I arrived home and found complaints in my in-box about some of the language that apparently was stuck on the top of the forum in this thread. In The past, this is what led to the inconvenience of having to hide our games. It's simple. Self police (which I prefer) or be policed.

Good night.

Oh can we not curse? My bad. Sorry Darg

I feel like I'm being told off by my mom

[Hamilton Brian]

I arrived home and found complaints in my in-box about some of the language that apparently was stuck on the top of the forum in this thread. In The past, this is what led to the inconvenience of having to hide our games. It's simple. Self police (which I prefer) or be policed.

Good night.

This is unknown to me. Was it a thing before?

[ghug]

##GM NOTE
Apparently this community desires to go back to "hidden" status on the forum. That can be arranged.

??? what

I arrived home and found complaints in my in-box about some of the language that apparently was stuck on the top of the forum in this thread. In The past, this is what led to the inconvenience of having to hide our games. It's simple. Self police (which I prefer) or be policed.

Good night.

What??

[ghug]

I haven't read the majority of bo's posts, but statistics dictate that he's said more than one offensive thing, and he's in charge.

[ghug]

Why not? Would it not be a pretty benign explanation? Suggests 1 scum, or even more, on that wagon. That's not a huge stretch to make. So if scum were being questioned with that exact question, how would you expect them to answer?

It's more the part where he pointed at one post and didn't elaborate for his bunny townread.

Sorry ghug, I don't get it

Sequence of events:
Player is town
Sees a post, gets a town vibe from someone
Defends the person
Gets questioned on the defense
Remembers the specific post and just points to it without giving any real explanation

Alternate sequence of events:
Player is scum
Sees a post from a player they know is town, takes a mental note of it as reasoning for a future townread
Defends the player
Gets questioned on the defense
Doesn't panic at all, or feel the need to give a full explanation, just quotes the post they took note of earlier

[ghug]

Hi yoyoyozo

[Durga]

I haven't read the majority of bo's posts, but statistics dictate that he's said more than one offensive thing, and he's in charge.

+1