M1023: Mafarmia [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[bozotheclown]

Given Bo pet rdr N1 (per claim) and rdr N2k I am adding Bo to my townpool

Can you please list your scum pool?

[Chaqa]

I think we should DK Chaqa today while damo is committed to voting for him.

##VOTE Chaqa

I think the most likely scum teams are:
Chaqa, damo, Bonatogether
Chaqa, damo, Kakarroto
Chaqa, Bonatogether, Kakarroto

Have you ever given a single explanation for scumming me?

Even Damo doesn’t think I’m scum, he just wants an info flip.

Yes:
1. your first post where you said you forgot about the game and were OK getting DKed D1
2. your D1 vote for damo
3. your unexplained strong town read of lfischl, which could be an attempt to set him up for a mis-kill
4. moving off my wagon D2 when I was in the lead, then moving back at EOD

1. Man I didn't even set up the bot, of course I forgot about the game.
2. Damo is scummy
3. TBH I forgot the exact line of thought that led to it, but I'm relatively sure it was because scum!Lfischl has no reason to switch to Bunny over me and breaking a tie is very towny
4. Are you for real? I voted Bona as a joke, and then I wasn't around for like 10 hours. When I got back, I was on my phone intermittent, and as soon as I got a chance to see a vote count I voted for you over celaph, who I town read.

I think you're one of those people who just can't see any other playstyle but yours as valid, or you're scum.

[Chaqa]

So probably if you’re scum so is Bo

If damo is mafia, that seems more like a pocketing attempt than trying to help a teammate.

Damo doesn't pocket

[Chaqa]

Kakarroto
lfischl
Bonatogether
heartthrob24909
bo_sox47
worcej
damo666
bozotheclown

This is roughly where I'm at

[damo666]

Given Bo pet rdr N1 (per claim) and rdr N2k I am adding Bo to my townpool

Like why does he get any town cred

If he’s mafia he lied about who he petted
If he’s town mafia wouldn’t care who pets who anyway

And by your logic me petting rivera on the night he’s killed should be important

There’s no consistency or logic to your game at all

Petting the nk is scum indicative if anything!

For Bo to be scum he would have to be lying about his N1 pet (would scum nk someone they petted as non-dog) with the lie not being the obvious one of that night's kill or a co-scum. Therefore I make Bo very likely town.

[damo666]

Given Bo pet rdr N1 (per claim) and rdr N2k I am adding Bo to my townpool

Like why does he get any town cred

If he’s mafia he lied about who he petted
If he’s town mafia wouldn’t care who pets who anyway

And by your logic me petting rivera on the night he’s killed should be important

There’s no consistency or logic to your game at all

Petting* the nk is scum indicative if anything!

For Bo to be scum he would have to be lying about his N1 pet (would scum nk someone they petted as non-dog) with the lie not being the obvious one of that night's kill or a co-scum. Therefore I make Bo very likely town.

ie claiming to pet the nk

[damo666]

Given Bo pet rdr N1 (per claim) and rdr N2k I am adding Bo to my townpool

Can you please list your scum pool?

Chaqa lfischl and unsure for the other Bona? Bozo?

[Chaqa]

Given Bo pet rdr N1 (per claim) and rdr N2k I am adding Bo to my townpool

Like why does he get any town cred

If he’s mafia he lied about who he petted
If he’s town mafia wouldn’t care who pets who anyway

And by your logic me petting rivera on the night he’s killed should be important

There’s no consistency or logic to your game at all

Petting the nk is scum indicative if anything!

For Bo to be scum he would have to be lying about his N1 pet (would scum nk someone they petted as non-dog) with the lie not being the obvious one of that night's kill or a co-scum. Therefore I make Bo very likely town.

Yes, obviously, but if bo is scum he's lying about who he pet regardless. Him having pet rivera has no bearing on whether he's scum or not. Smh like bro this is so obvious, do I need to do a bad math problem for you to get it?

[damo666]

Like why does he get any town cred

If he’s mafia he lied about who he petted
If he’s town mafia wouldn’t care who pets who anyway

And by your logic me petting rivera on the night he’s killed should be important

There’s no consistency or logic to your game at all

Petting the nk is scum indicative if anything!

For Bo to be scum he would have to be lying about his N1 pet (would scum nk someone they petted as non-dog) with the lie not being the obvious one of that night's kill or a co-scum. Therefore I make Bo very likely town.

Yes, obviously, but if bo is scum he's lying about who he pet regardless. Him having pet rivera has no bearing on whether he's scum or not. Smh like bro this is so obvious, do I need to do a bad math problem for you to get it?

But why would scumBo make a bad guess? Double bluff?

[Chaqa]

Petting the nk is scum indicative if anything!

For Bo to be scum he would have to be lying about his N1 pet (would scum nk someone they petted as non-dog) with the lie not being the obvious one of that night's kill or a co-scum. Therefore I make Bo very likely town.

Yes, obviously, but if bo is scum he's lying about who he pet regardless. Him having pet rivera has no bearing on whether he's scum or not. Smh like bro this is so obvious, do I need to do a bad math problem for you to get it?

But why would scumBo make a bad guess? Double bluff?

What do you mean by a bad guess?

[bo_sox48]

Chaqa is really bad at this game but he’s obviously town.

##VOTE damo

[bo_sox48]

Damo is worse at this game.

[Chaqa]

Chaqa is really bad at this game but he’s obviously town.

##VOTE damo

*checks Damo and Bozo's notes*

this means you and I are scumbos with Damo

[bo_sox48]

I don’t really care about the rest of the team until we get one.

[bo_sox48]

Although “bona bussed lfischl yesterday” has a nice ring to it

[heartthrob24909]

are you getting a sense of personalities yet? i didn't distinguish between many people for most of my first game

I have a sense of u, of Bunny, worcej, and then everyone else is blended together

@heart, has this changed?

i'm also getting a better sense of bozo the clown, mostly thanks to his survey. i think he and bona are town and even though i have a sense of worcej's personality idrk who he might be in the game

[heartthrob24909]

didn't pet anyone again

i petted Kak

[Kakarroto]

goated

##vote bunny

i want to give fisch townpoints but his first eod vote sucked

why does that qualify for town points? Also that's not how points work, they accumulate and aren't canceled out directly by previous actions (only in summery)

[Kakarroto]

Had a look at first 2 days' votes with the following observations:

Bozo and Bona are double townkillers.

Bozo's D1 move from Chaqa to Bunny making it 3-3 from 4-2 is noteworthy but Chaqa's late move to Bozo D2 confuses.

Lot of votes putting Bozo in danger D2 so on the face of it if he is scum his partners lie in {Bona, bo, heart, worcej}. However as Bozo is 2s on to be town I think going this route is too risky.

I still favour a Chaqa flip.

Ofc night events may alter this.

Let's see.

I've highlighted an especially egregious sentence from Damo that just shows Damo is arguing in bad faith and has no idea why I suspect Bozo or why I would vote him over a town read of mine in celaph.

Damo is either scum or not actively reading, which is unusual for him, no?

in a previous game where town damo and town me participated I noticed something that was absolutely egregious and was convinced he was acting in bad faith and pushed for his ejection. I still struggle to believe town damo really did this so I believe nearly everything is possible with damo now.

[Kakarroto]

[...]
That was also the post that made me vote for Chaqa D1, as it seemed unlikely Chaqa forgot about the existence of this game considering he confirmed participation after the game filled and not long before it started. Also, I thought the D1 thing was a potential scum ploy, although I did not consider at the time that it could be a signal to bus him.

What do you think about the situation of worcej then, since he was the last to post in the signup thread with a note of hurry but then didn't even vote on D1? It seems unlikely worcej forgot about the existence of this game considering he posted after the game was filled and confirmation took place, no?