Mafia 47 - The Sixth Mass Extinction - GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[ItsHosuke]

@ItsHosuke - why did you bump the thread yesterday? What was the point of that?

Simply trying to remind myself of this thread, but that... didn’t work out too well...

[brainbomb]

##Vote Percy
##End

[foodcoats]

However ItsHo is on the too early to lynch list.

I feel like this list is getting longer by the minute and is in itself problematic given the scum have fake claim options and there's no process of elimination we can perform, such as "if doc no vig" or whatever like I have seen in other setups.

I don't get the Mafia maths well enough to foresee how this will impact our ability to find all 5 scum if we mislynch again because we are avoiding lynching scummy players... but I feel like we should be trying to lynch the scummiest players irrespective of any weak claims.

I dunno, I guess the setup is trying to force us into these shitty decision points.

[bozotheclown]

So here is a new request for everyone, inadvertently inspired by rdrivera. Please give your best guess of exactly five scum, in order of confidence. You are free to change your list at any time. Proceed without participating at your own risk of getting scum read.

I will start:
1. Percy
2. Chaqa
3. bo_sox
4. dargorygel
5. flash

jamie being scum pretty much certifies emc was scum too

Jamie, flash, emc, Chaqa, dargo?

I could buy that ticket for bozo's bingo.

scumteam
xorxes
jamie
damo
bozo
emc

We need more participants. Please give your best guess at the 5 scum, you can always change your mind.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Percy
##End

You are that certain that Percy is lying and is not the Role Cop?

[Jamiet99uk]

We need more participants. Please give your best guess at the 5 scum, you can always change your mind.

I posted 5 scumreads just two pages ago. Why don't my reads interest you?

[bozotheclown]

ItsHosuke voted MoscowFleet yesterday and never moved off them.

Almost the only thing they've posted about is how they are a mason, but how they've had difficulty communicating with the other mason because of time zones. But if mason chat is open all the time, that doesn't matter. It also doesn't excuse posting literally nothing in the main thread... ItsHosuke seems to be suggesting they aren't able to post because they're so busy trying to communicate in mason chat?

Also asked for a TL;DR which bothers me, seems to exempt someone from the need to form their own ideas.

...and, took the time to post a bump... like... I am struggling to imagine the individual who thinks, "I would like to play Mafia on webDiplomacy!" and then... proceeds to NOT play? At all? Unless ItsHosuke is a total newb to the game, rolled scum, and is afraid.

Whoops wait ##vote damo666, sorry

Why??? This is useless.

##VOTE ItsHosuke

If he is scum a second scum would have to claim the other mason to cover him. I think this situation can wait though, because if he is town we are better off waiting to expose the second mason.

[bozotheclown]

We need more participants. Please give your best guess at the 5 scum, you can always change your mind.

I posted 5 scumreads just two pages ago. Why don't my reads interest you?

I missed that because it was part of a full reads list, but now I see you also said they were in no particular order. Do you care to rank them?

[bozotheclown]

My scumpool in alpha order

Bo
Chaqa
Darg
EP
Flash
Fox
Worcej

What are your top five in order of confidence?

[Jamiet99uk]

We need more participants. Please give your best guess at the 5 scum, you can always change your mind.

I posted 5 scumreads just two pages ago. Why don't my reads interest you?

I missed that because it was part of a full reads list, but now I see you also said they were in no particular order. Do you care to rank them?

Pretty tricky but I guess my top scumreads out of those five are currently Xorxes and Flash.

[Jamiet99uk]

What bothers me most is that you were interested enough in the game to address a point made by Vecna, but disinterested enough to not care who had been nightkilled.

This is a false narrative. I lost track of time and did not realise the night had ended.

It's interesting being me. And not just because I'm so popular with the ladies. You see, I've got a style that always seems just a little bit scummy, whatever my alignment. This means I get mis-read by newbies quite a lot, and it also means that I'm a realistic mislynch target for scum.

But that also means I've had quite a lot of experience, over the many Mafia games I've played in, of scum attempting to push what they hope is an easy mislynch on me. And it frequently involves a version of what good ol' Xorxes is doing right here - picking up on something I've done or said and twisting it into a false narrative, and then pushing that false narrative as a "case".

Town Xorxes studies things very carefully and often reaches highly insightful conclusions. Scum Xorxes hangs back a little bit and is less committal, unless he gets his teeth into a good mislynch candidate. Like he's doing here.

[Jamiet99uk]

You might say that because of my own personal style, I'm a walking reaction test.

##VOTE XORXES

[Jamiet99uk]

His case doesn't even make logical sense within itself.

If I was scum, Xorxes, I would know who was being nightkilled, wouldn't I ?

[Foxcastle]

##VOTE JAMIET

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE JAMIET

Because reasons?

[Jamiet99uk]

I love it when people I'm townreading cast totally unexplained votes.

[Foxcastle]

##VOTE JAMIET

Because reasons?

Yes. Reasons™

[damo666]

My scumpool in alpha order

Bo
Chaqa
Darg
EP
Flash
Fox
Worcej

What are your top five in order of confidence?

I'll ISO each then provide an order, might be a while

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE JAMIET

Because reasons?

Yes. Reasons™

Please can we discuss these reasons? It's important because you are wrong.

[Foxcastle]

Because reasons?

Yes. Reasons™

Please can we discuss these reasons? It's important because you are wrong.

No. ##END