Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Squigs44]

I'm so confused. Why is Durga not dead?

My guess is that didn't kill her because it would too obviously point back to ND trying to eliminate a vote against him. So they targeted you instead.

But they didn't target me because I would be dead rn.

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTE

The PeterBot is now running correctly again.

Thanks to Dargorygel and Peter for assisting with this.

[Percy Williams]

I mean really though, Durga is the obvious choice, (and this means chippe was indeed a VT). The only reason to lynch him is either because they just hate him or they thought he was BA. IMO, the former is more likely.

[Foxcastle]

If we kill the BA, it's 5-2. NK to 4-2, and we're at LyLo.

If we don't kill the BA: best case for town is lynch scum to 4-1-1. Presume we lose 2 townies over night, making it 2-1-1, at which point we must lynch the BA, but the NK means scum win.

[Foxcastle]

I mean really though, Durga is the obvious choice, (and this means chippe was indeed a VT). The only reason to lynch him is either because they just hate him or they thought he was BA. IMO, the former is more likely.

But he wasn't, so the BA did what? Either bounced on Chippe, or... held?

Nah, I think the scum know who the BA is now. And I bet it's Squigs.

[Foxcastle]

If we kill the BA, it's 5-2. NK to 4-2, and we're at LyLo.

If we don't kill the BA: best case for town is lynch scum to 4-1-1. Presume we lose 2 townies over night, making it 2-1-1, at which point we must lynch the BA, but the NK means scum win.

Someone should check this math, but I think we have to lynch the BA to win at this point.

[Squigs44]

So either the mafia targeted the BA and BA targeted Chip, or the BA held the kill while the mafia targeted Chip, or they both targeted Chip.

All of these plausible, but mafia not killing Durga is mind boggling to me.

[ND]

Not killing Durga is bizarre since she was a townclear. But, hopefully that comes back to bite them. Btw, I was roleblocked.

[Foxcastle]

So either the mafia targeted the BA and BA targeted Chip, or the BA held the kill while the mafia targeted Chip, or they both targeted Chip.

All of these plausible, but mafia not killing Durga is mind boggling to me.

BA holding doesn't make sense to me. BA killing town does, though, more than BA killing scum.

[Foxcastle]

If we lynch the BA today, we're in LyLo on Day 7.

If we lynch scum today, either the BA wins (if we don't lynch him D7), or we go to LyLo on D8.

If we mislynch town today, there are a bunch of permutations. But the BA wins about half of them, I think.

Again, check my math.

[Foxcastle]

We may be in a situation where the best chance for both Mafia and town is to work together against the BA.

[ND]

I am going to ##Vote Fox and my case
(review why I think Fox - ET are scum in my mega case a few pages back if you haven't already)

[Durga]

WoW I love this scum team

[Durga]

Thoughts when I get home later. This is hilarious

[Durga]

Possible they targeted BA and the kill hit scum but I really doubt that. Don't know why they'd kill Chippe over Squigs. It's possible though that they're desperate to find the BA and decided to rb their first choice and kill their second.

[Foxcastle]

Possible they targeted BA and the kill hit scum but I really doubt that. Don't know why they'd kill Chippe over Squigs. It's possible though that they're desperate to find the BA and decided to rb their first choice and kill their second.

To complete the thought out loud: this would imply that ND was the BA.

[ND]

I am not BA or scum, but I was roleblocked last night.

[Foxcastle]

I am not BA or scum, but I was roleblocked last night.

So what's your explanation of why there was only one NK?

[Squigs44]

In M39 I was mafia with ND (I got killed D1), and we were in a real bad spot. ND advocated for some crazy unorthodox NKs because chaos only helps scum, and if we had made the obvious kills, the status quo would have held and ND and (I think Yav) would have been lynched since they were the top scumreads.

These NKs look like an attempt to do just this - break the status quo. That would mean ND and/or Fox are mafia.

[Squigs44]

Would BA ND claim RB?