Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Damo's fascination with BA over "known scum" Connor is another indication that he's totally mafia

His unreasonable defensiveness and anger over even being accused is another reason why...

Either way, I'm actually in favor of the BA NKing connor - it doesn't allow connor to be "cleared' by damo if damo flips scum and if connor is town, than damo is an easy lynch. Damo is the least likely of the two to viewed as having been "cleared" by a NK of connor flipping scum, allowing people to not rule him out and remain objective about him.

This is Chippe disagreeing with Durga just to disagree with her, not because it's actually a good idea.
Durga please don't die. Why did you have to claim? Look at the list of players I'm left with after you're dead. Lurkers and unpleasants. Oh, and I guess Fox is still here.

Hey I might not die. Maybe the scum team thinks I'm really dumb or something. Maybe Chippe is right :)

[ChippeRock]

What is your current scum list at this very moment?

I will update mine in a moment...

You. You're my scum list

Any motivation?

This is a question with an obvious answer peter. Here's the answer: Because you're lurking.

[ChippeRock]

His unreasonable defensiveness and anger over even being accused is another reason why...

Either way, I'm actually in favor of the BA NKing connor - it doesn't allow connor to be "cleared' by damo if damo flips scum and if connor is town, than damo is an easy lynch. Damo is the least likely of the two to viewed as having been "cleared" by a NK of connor flipping scum, allowing people to not rule him out and remain objective about him.

This is Chippe disagreeing with Durga just to disagree with her, not because it's actually a good idea.
Durga please don't die. Why did you have to claim? Look at the list of players I'm left with after you're dead. Lurkers and unpleasants. Oh, and I guess Fox is still here.

Hey I might not die. Maybe the scum team thinks I'm really dumb or something. Maybe Chippe is right :)

Scum might also want you because you're an easy person for people like Squigs to sheep off of and lynch town.

[Durga]

I can't wait to never engage with Chippe and his backwards thinking again honestly.

Sorry I don't have the energy to explain to you why your killing Connor proposal is ridiculous. I just don't.

[Squigs44]

My current scumteam in case anyone is wondering is damo, Fox, ND, and Peter.

ND/et could potentially be swapped there.

[et]

I made list and I am going to verify from Day1.
1 damo-Connor-Fox-ND
2 damo-Fox-ND-peter
3 damo-Connor-Fox-peter
4 damo-Connor-peter-ND
5 damo-Connor-Flav-ND
1 is the list I think most likely.
2 is second likely, 3 is third...
These may change by verification.

[Squigs44]

His unreasonable defensiveness and anger over even being accused is another reason why...

Either way, I'm actually in favor of the BA NKing connor - it doesn't allow connor to be "cleared' by damo if damo flips scum and if connor is town, than damo is an easy lynch. Damo is the least likely of the two to viewed as having been "cleared" by a NK of connor flipping scum, allowing people to not rule him out and remain objective about him.

This is Chippe disagreeing with Durga just to disagree with her, not because it's actually a good idea.
Durga please don't die. Why did you have to claim? Look at the list of players I'm left with after you're dead. Lurkers and unpleasants. Oh, and I guess Fox is still here.

This is another example of my ideas being overlooked simply because I was the one to utter them.

Please tell me why my logic is wrong if that's your opinion, but don't try to shade me without telling everyone what is wrong with my logic.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems here that you think:
A) Damo is scummier than Connor
B) Connor should die before Damo

[Durga]

I made list and I am going to verify from Day1.
1 damo-Connor-Fox-ND
2 damo-Fox-ND-peter
3 damo-Connor-Fox-peter
4 damo-Connor-peter-ND
5 damo-Connor-Flav-ND
1 is the list I think most likely.
2 is second likely, 3 is third...
These may change by verification.

Why is damo-Connor likely?

[Squigs44]

I made list and I am going to verify from Day1.
1 damo-Connor-Fox-ND
2 damo-Fox-ND-peter
3 damo-Connor-Fox-peter
4 damo-Connor-peter-ND
5 damo-Connor-Flav-ND
1 is the list I think most likely.
2 is second likely, 3 is third...
These may change by verification.

And I think this crosspost from et just solidified ND in my team rather than et.

[et]

@Durga
I don't understand why damo claimed fake roleblocked.
1 damo thought damo can win connor?
2 For Connor looking like towny?

I think 2 is likely now.
But 1 is possible too.

[et]

That is promiseed on damo is scum.
But I think damo is scum now.

[Durga]

@Durga
I don't understand why damo claimed fake roleblocked.
1 damo thought damo can win connor?
2 For Connor looking like towny?

I think 2 is likely now.
But 1 is possible too.

If scum wanted to clear one of the two, they would have just not roleblocked anyone and had damo claim roleblock and then we'd have an almost town clear without this crazy counter claim thing. It makes no sense for two scum to claim roleblocked unless it was a mistake.

[ND]

I have to say Peter is pretty hilarious I laughed hysterically when he called Drugna honey lol

[ND]

Not the word I would use to describe here, but that aside.

I think BA is Chippie, I've given my scumteam. I am going to write up some reasons for why I think that.

I think Damo is scum over ConnEr I don't see both of them being scum though. Yes I emphasized the E for Damio.

[et]

@Durga
I don't understand why damo claimed fake roleblocked.
1 damo thought damo can win connor?
2 For Connor looking like towny?

I think 2 is likely now.
But 1 is possible too.

If scum wanted to clear one of the two, they would have just not roleblocked anyone and had damo claim roleblock and then we'd have an almost town clear without this crazy counter claim thing. It makes no sense for two scum to claim roleblocked unless it was a mistake.

I thought Mafia might read town is likely to think so and not use roleblock.

I thought both of Connor and damo is scum before their roleblocked claim.
I may have to change mind.
Anyway, I am going to verify.

[Durga]

I have to say Peter is pretty hilarious I laughed hysterically when he called Drugna honey lol

Peter and I are best buds. I've met his wife and children and everything.

[ND]

@ET: Where are you going to go to 'verify'?

@Durga: For real? That's kind of cool.

[et]

@ET: Where are you going to go to 'verify'?

@Durga: For real? That's kind of cool.

I am going to reread past posts based on this list and seek unnatural point.
If I find many unnatural point, I will lower the priority of list.

[ChippeRock]

This is Chippe disagreeing with Durga just to disagree with her, not because it's actually a good idea.
Durga please don't die. Why did you have to claim? Look at the list of players I'm left with after you're dead. Lurkers and unpleasants. Oh, and I guess Fox is still here.

This is another example of my ideas being overlooked simply because I was the one to utter them.

Please tell me why my logic is wrong if that's your opinion, but don't try to shade me without telling everyone what is wrong with my logic.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems here that you think:
A) Damo is scummier than Connor
B) Connor should die before Damo

If either of them is town, than it proves the other is scum. So if whoever is NKed flips town, than we lynch the other.

But, damo is acting scummier than connor, so if both are scum, than we're more likely to think that damo flipping scum "clears" connor than the other way around (which makes us less objective towards connor than we might be towards damo and allow him to lurk to victory).

Again, you're not bothering to look at my underlying logic.

[Durga]

....