Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Nephthys]

Also, I'm gonna go Fox/Teacon, any issues?

[Squigs44]

@Squiggles, give me your thoughts on connor.

Look into his Balki read, it makes me curious

His re-read is quick. Low impact player, so mostly null. He just has these moments though that have a townie tone to me. Things I would not expect from a new, hasn't-read-half-the-thread scumbo. In my POE, but not someone I would want to lynch today.

What Balki read are you talking about?

[Nephthys]

@Squiggles, give me your thoughts on connor.

Look into his Balki read, it makes me curious

His re-read is quick. Low impact player, so mostly null. He just has these moments though that have a townie tone to me. Things I would not expect from a new, hasn't-read-half-the-thread scumbo. In my POE, but not someone I would want to lynch today.

What Balki read are you talking about?

From page 35 to 60 something. He comes in with Balki being scum then with no reasoning switches him to be one of the most trustworthy town

[Squigs44]

Also, I'm gonna go Fox/Teacon, any issues?

I approve. Now that I think about it, there has been more posted about why these two are scum than any other two players alive, so this should be a fun ride.

[Squigs44]

@Squiggles, give me your thoughts on connor.

Look into his Balki read, it makes me curious

His re-read is quick. Low impact player, so mostly null. He just has these moments though that have a townie tone to me. Things I would not expect from a new, hasn't-read-half-the-thread scumbo. In my POE, but not someone I would want to lynch today.

What Balki read are you talking about?

From page 35 to 60 something. He comes in with Balki being scum then with no reasoning switches him to be one of the most trustworthy town

You mean this:

6. From my fairly unimformed opinion, Balki seems scum, don't read too much into that though.

To this:

1. Balki vs. teacon. A while a go now but I found Balki's 'smarmy' argument decent, but not AI. I think not getting to the point could easily be a sign of being just a bad town. Also, apparently teacon acted this way last game as town, so with that he could go either way. This makes me think that if he's town now, he should surely try and correct his mistake, rather than replicate it. (Overall though I still think he's Mafia, I'll get to that later)

2. Balki. I trust you. The comment previously was before your argument with teacon, and while I don't think your argument was particularly convincing, it put you in an earnest light for me.

The hedgiest scumread ever to a townread of him for putting together the smarmy argument. What do you find curious about it? The "I trust you" does seem a little strong, but he explained his reasoning for the townread.

[Nephthys]

His re-read is quick. Low impact player, so mostly null. He just has these moments though that have a townie tone to me. Things I would not expect from a new, hasn't-read-half-the-thread scumbo. In my POE, but not someone I would want to lynch today.

What Balki read are you talking about?

From page 35 to 60 something. He comes in with Balki being scum then with no reasoning switches him to be one of the most trustworthy town

You mean this:

6. From my fairly unimformed opinion, Balki seems scum, don't read too much into that though.

To this:

1. Balki vs. teacon. A while a go now but I found Balki's 'smarmy' argument decent, but not AI. I think not getting to the point could easily be a sign of being just a bad town. Also, apparently teacon acted this way last game as town, so with that he could go either way. This makes me think that if he's town now, he should surely try and correct his mistake, rather than replicate it. (Overall though I still think he's Mafia, I'll get to that later)

2. Balki. I trust you. The comment previously was before your argument with teacon, and while I don't think your argument was particularly convincing, it put you in an earnest light for me.

The hedgiest scumread ever to a townread of him for putting together the smarmy argument. What do you find curious about it? The "I trust you" does seem a little strong, but he explained his reasoning for the townread.

Maybe it is the wording as you pointed out, I just dont like it

[Nephthys]

Ah well, teacon vs Fox locked in and sent

Just waiting on GMs

[ChippeRock]

Ah well, teacon vs Fox locked in and sent

Just waiting on GMs

I suppose it's time to wait and see if you're proven to actually be the Judge.

Real Judge, if you somehow turn out to NOT be Neph, name him as a lynch candidate or at least set 2 lynch candidates that aren't the exact same as his stated above.

[Nephthys]

Ah well, teacon vs Fox locked in and sent

Just waiting on GMs

I suppose it's time to wait and see if you're proven to actually be the Judge.

Real Judge, if you somehow turn out to NOT be Neph, name him as a lynch candidate or at least set 2 lynch candidates that aren't the exact same as his stated above.

I'll give you credit that you've kept this up for so long...

[ChippeRock]

Ah well, teacon vs Fox locked in and sent

Just waiting on GMs

I suppose it's time to wait and see if you're proven to actually be the Judge.

Real Judge, if you somehow turn out to NOT be Neph, name him as a lynch candidate or at least set 2 lynch candidates that aren't the exact same as his stated above.

I'll give you credit that you've kept this up for so long...

You're believable as Judge, but Balki was believable as the BA - I'll believe it when the GM announces the proof.

[Squigs44]

Do you need anything else Neph, or can I go to bed now?

[Nephthys]

Do you need anything else Neph, or can I go to bed now?

I release you buddy, rest up <3

[Jamiet99uk]

ATTENTION

"Order! Order! I'll have order in my court!" boomed the judge.

"Yeah whatever, beaky" giggled Maya, blowing a large bubble-gum bubble.

"Maya, have a little respect..." groaned Phoenix.

The judge continued.

"Today the court will once again only consider the guilt.... or innocence, I guess.... of the two suspects whose names I wrote on this napkin at breakfast...."

He flopped a slightly stained napkin onto the bench. It contained two names:

FOXCASTLE
TEACON7

ONLY VOTES FOR THESE CANDIDATES WILL BE COUNTED TODAY.

[ChippeRock]

Well, Neph, you've proven you're the Judge (though now you've just become a glorified VT), I will go with my 2nd strongest scum read (after you, Neph) and ##VOTE Foxcastle. I will try to find the time to ISO both of our lynch candidates and reconsider this vote.

[ChippeRock]

@teacon7 @Foxcastle

If either one of you is the town's Innocent Child, I suggest you reveal yourself - otherwise a would-of-been-confirmed town (i.e., you) has a very good chance of getting lynched rather than someone who is at least less likely to be town (i.e., they wouldn't be GM confirmed to be town, so thus have a chance of being scum).

[damo666]

I was RB'd.

I think Chips is BA.

Teacon more sus than Fox so

##VOTE Teacon

[Foxcastle]

@teacon7 @Foxcastle

If either one of you is the town's Innocent Child, I suggest you reveal yourself - otherwise a would-of-been-confirmed town (i.e., you) has a very good chance of getting lynched rather than someone who is at least less likely to be town (i.e., they wouldn't be GM confirmed to be town, so thus have a chance of being scum).

Thanks, Chipper. Never would have thought of that on our own!

I have some time today and tomorrow, so you should see plenty from me.

[damo666]

Silly me. CHIPS not BA. He can't be 2 roles.

[et]

Silly me. CHIPS not BA. He can't be 2 roles.

2 roles? What do you mean?
Because Chippe 'proved' himself as VT?

And Damo claimed roleblocked.
Hmm.

[damo666]

Silly me. CHIPS not BA. He can't be 2 roles.

2 roles? What do you mean?
Because Chippe 'proved' himself as VT?

And Damo claimed roleblocked.
Hmm.

He's obvcrumbed a role other than BA. Two if you count VT. I believe neither.