Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Anyway, whoever claims roleblock is gonna get Durga cleared!! Pls claim!!

[Percy Williams]

The whole thing with Balki D3 is so weird now in hindsight. It was so risky. Especially after Neph got involved and confirmed he was PR I just thought it was outlandish that he was mafia at that point. Now, obviously we know Balki is mafia and I do request for Neph if he is Judge to claim who he is using the power on or time it right before the GM announcement. That will at least clear him and clear up his role in all of this. Also, if someone was RB they should claim.

Idk the whole thing is just outlandish and a very risky gamble for Balki.

Well, it was the only PR left that left home, so if Balki had managed to get us to mislynch, and Roleblock whoever the real Ba is, then the scum team would have basically won. Even a mislynch and Balki's death gives a nice place for Mafia to be, but they lost both gambles.

[Percy Williams]

I'm claiming Vanilla Town with no known Roleblocked experience. I wish I could have had a more exiting game, especially with so many PRs and Players, but I guess my life is reflected in Mafia: mostly just boring. I mean sure, I'm alive, but... so boring.

Since Jamie's is GMing, this is not sarcasm.

[Foxcastle]

I think I'll start there

##vote fox

Not scum, no, but I have probably outlived my usefulness and am just bad noise for the rest of game.

[Durga]

I think I'll start there

##vote fox

Not scum, no, but I have probably outlived my usefulness and am just bad noise for the rest of game.

Honey ur smart don't say that pls try

[Squigs44]

I think I'll start there

##vote fox

Not scum, no, but I have probably outlived my usefulness and am just bad noise for the rest of game.

Outlived your usefulness? Why don't you try to become more useful then?

##vote Fox

[Squigs44]

Okay just got home, so I'll crunch the numbers now

[Squigs44]

Okay, so we are at 8 town (judge, ic, 6vts) 4 mafia (assassin, framer, lawyer, hooker) 1 blind assassin.

If we mislynch:
7/4/1
Two town deaths at night makes it 5/4/1 which means our fate is in SKs hands, but still alive.
1 town death and 1 mafia death (courtesy of BA) would mean 6/3/1 which is still good for town.
Of course it's also possible there is only 1 death if mafia target SK or SK holds their kill or they target the same person. 1 town death leaves us in a bad but survivable position (6/4/1) and 1 mafia death puts us in a good position (7/3/1).

If we lynch SK/BA:
Then I will also assume that mafia gets in a town NK, which leaves us at 7/4, which gives us 1 mislynch to spare.

If we lynch mafia:
8/3/1:
Two town deaths makes it 6/3/1 which is still decent for town but not the best
One town death one mafia gives 7/2/1 which is really good for town.
And with one death, we get either 7/3/1 which is good, or 8/2/1 which is amazing.


Tl;dr - We have some breathing room, and we could likely survive a mislynch, but with the volatility of the SK, lynching either mafia or SK today is the only way to ensure towns safety.

[Durga]

Who's left to still claim roleblock? Flav?

[Squigs44]

Who's left to still claim roleblock? Flav?

Chippe, Flav, Connor, and damo haven't posted this phase

[Percy Williams]

What if the hooker has yet to roleblock? Crazy and unlikely, but looking at this game...

[Squigs44]

What if the hooker has yet to roleblock? Crazy and unlikely, but looking at this game...

He roleblocked me

[Durga]

What if the hooker has yet to roleblock? Crazy and unlikely, but looking at this game...

Impossible for today. Balki's plan wouldn't have worked without it. Which means damo isn't the rb. Maybe teacon is the rb. I need to reread d3 tonight.

[Squigs44]

What if the hooker has yet to roleblock? Crazy and unlikely, but looking at this game...

He roleblocked me

Just to clarify this was from N2 not last night. I was not RBd N3

[ChippeRock]

Thank you Blind Assassin for not screwing up that easy NK of Balki!

On another note, either Balki was really lucky, or Neph is scum.

I would vote Fox, but Neph's hands are now way too dirty, and we need to lynch him unless he proves he's Judge (by announcing immediately before the GM post who the 2 lynch candidates the 2 exact lynch candidates he sent the GM) this turn, he needs to go because he must be scum!

##VOTE Nephthys

Neph, if you are the real Judge or are the town's Innocent Child, you need to prove that - as Judge by doing what I stated above, or as Innocent Child by revealing yourself (otherwise the real Judge will put you up as one of the two lynch candidates). Otherwise, you must be lynched, because than you must be scum for fake claiming Judge!

[ChippeRock]

Neph don't use your power unilaterally. I'd like to discuss the candidates with you.

Hit me with ideas currently percy vs teacon. I reckon we can kill ba now

I really dislike Percy as a choice for today. I'm actually leaning not mafia on him. Yeah. We don't really need to worry about lynching BA or not I think. We probably need to scout them out soon, I imagine they're someone we town read bc they too have to find scum. My best guess is Chippe but idk.

Agh I want to do like an in depth analysis before you use your power but I don't think I'll have the time.

What are the numbers, do we have a mislynch now?

My guess would be you among the "obvious town"...

[ChippeRock]

Who's left to still claim roleblock? Flav?

Chippe, Flav, Connor, and damo haven't posted this phase

Right, I forgot I MUST post within 3 hours and 45 minutes of the EoN...

[Durga]

This guy is the goddamn worst. Comes in, votes an uncc'd judge and makes shitty demands that will hurt town, makes snide comments, takes posts out of context and is rude in response. Who raised you? Seriously

[Durga]

Because Balki is going to out his fucking scum mate. Like yeah, that's really the logical play. Jfc

[ChippeRock]

@Judge

If you are not Neph, and Neph hasn't revealed himself as IC, than he needs to be one of the 2 candidates (I honestly think you should also reveal before the GM posts the 2 candidates who the 2 candidates are to prove yourself as Judge - because after that, you're just a glorified VT). If you are Neph, you need to prove that you are the Judge using the method in the previous parentheses.

@Innocent Child

You need to reveal yourself! That way the Judge does NOT pick you as one of the 2 lynch candidates and can instead pick 2 candidates who are more likely to be scum. You're just a glorified VT after that, so there's no harm in doing so since you'll get NKed eventually anyways (being a glorified VT doesn't make you a target).