Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

Damo's immediately preceding post strikes me as scummy.

This post strikes me as scummy because it provides no reasoning other than 'scummy'.

We could spiral into an infinite series of posts here....

[teacon7]

I don't see why you can't be scum together. At this point I expect scum to be distancing the most possible from the others as they just need a myslinch in 5 days (and keep the Hooker alive to rb the SK). In fact, wanting to hit the RB is the only thing that is keeping me from pushing your lynch. But if Xorxes is scum, then we have a lot of options for N1.
Teacon is another good lunch, I completely see him lurking as scum after that last game where he lost for lurkers.
I am also pretty confident Damo is scum, I did an Iso on him and can't see anything towny on him. His readlist on D2 doesn't seem natural and he only interacted with it's EP x et in the block then just fade away again. He never really push his reads, which is a big scumtell for Damo.

Two points of fact:
a) I didn't lose to lurking scum. I lost to low-committment scum. Moscow lurked until lylo. emc posted, but hedged and never committed to anything. That's different than lurking.
b) I was on a trip in california, which is why I didn't post much for n1-n2. I even mentioned this in the signup thread.

[teacon7]

His disappearance and anchor post is so on point for him being scum

oh ffs durga. I went to sleep.
Why won't you answer the question?

What... I did... I'm talking about Fox

oh... sorry then. I misread you. I thought you were talking about me :/

[damo666]

If my Flav theory is correct then Fox and Peter are probably cleared so this makes the other 4 scum and SK

Teacon
Percy
Chips
ND
Connor

[Balki Bartokomous]

Does anybody hear that sound? Anybody know what it is?

* pauses for dramatic effect

[et]

Do you mean if Flav is scum, Fox and Percy isn't scum?
Why do you think so?

[Foxcastle]

Does anybody hear that sound? Anybody know what it is?

* pauses for dramatic effect

Is it the sound of nothing happening because scum are sitting back waiting to win?

[peterlund]

##vote teacon

Great he was on my sus list!

[Balki Bartokomous]

Does anybody hear that sound? Anybody know what it is?

* pauses for dramatic effect

That's the sound of scum scrambling.

rdrivera, I don't think it's a good idea to keep Xorxes alive just because it was "too quiet." We have ND pushing ET, Damo pushing basically anyone but Xorxes, teacon pushing Foxy Knoxy. I mean...that's intense. I don't think you should expect six scum to joinm together and push a counterwagon. But this is about as much subtle Xorx defending as you would expect if he is scum. And nobody is actually defending him (also what you would expect). They are just pushing other wagons.

[teacon7]

a) does everyone agree with her on this? I'm not in a position to know as I haven't played scum since like m20-something.
b) I agree that our PR are weaker here - we knew coming into this that it was a maf-sided setup, and the bailiff dying doesn't help. Do you think scum would hunt for the BA though?

a) I agree after Tom died. Tom is most towny person at Night2. I have no idea scum thought Tom is PR or not.
b)That is possible.
Why do you ask it?

If we're trying to make sense of why tom was killed + cleaned, understanding maf motivation might be important. There's too much wifom dealing with whether Tom was PR or not, but scum still thought he was worth killing + cleaning. Why? That's useful to think about even now. I don't think it was just because he was perceived as towny, and I don't think it was because he was reporter, but I don't know why else it might be. Hence my question about scum motivation.

[teacon7]

##vote teacon

Great he was on my sus list!

That's kindof out of nowhere peter. Why was I on your sus list? please explain this better than "this looks like a viable wagon" ...

[Balki Bartokomous]

a) does everyone agree with her on this? I'm not in a position to know as I haven't played scum since like m20-something.
b) I agree that our PR are weaker here - we knew coming into this that it was a maf-sided setup, and the bailiff dying doesn't help. Do you think scum would hunt for the BA though?

a) I agree after Tom died. Tom is most towny person at Night2. I have no idea scum thought Tom is PR or not.
b)That is possible.
Why do you ask it?

If we're trying to make sense of why tom was killed + cleaned, understanding maf motivation might be important. There's too much wifom dealing with whether Tom was PR or not, but scum still thought he was worth killing + cleaning. Why? That's useful to think about even now. I don't think it was just because he was perceived as towny, and I don't think it was because he was reporter, but I don't know why else it might be. Hence my question about scum motivation.

Can you spell out your theory? I'm not sure I understand.

[damo666]

Do you mean if Flav is scum, Fox and Percy isn't scum?
Why do you think so?

Day 1 voting

[et]

a) does everyone agree with her on this? I'm not in a position to know as I haven't played scum since like m20-something.
b) I agree that our PR are weaker here - we knew coming into this that it was a maf-sided setup, and the bailiff dying doesn't help. Do you think scum would hunt for the BA though?

a) I agree after Tom died. Tom is most towny person at Night2. I have no idea scum thought Tom is PR or not.
b)That is possible.
Why do you ask it?

If we're trying to make sense of why tom was killed + cleaned, understanding maf motivation might be important. There's too much wifom dealing with whether Tom was PR or not, but scum still thought he was worth killing + cleaning. Why? That's useful to think about even now. I don't think it was just because he was perceived as towny, and I don't think it was because he was reporter, but I don't know why else it might be. Hence my question about scum motivation.

Thanks. That is possible to be useful. But now, we have a little time from EoD.
I think a little leisurely.

[et]

Do you mean if Flav is scum, Fox and Percy isn't scum?
Why do you think so?

Day 1 voting

Percy voted bozo.

[damo666]

If my Flav theory is correct then Fox and Peter are probably cleared so this makes the other 4 scum and SK

Teacon
Percy
Chips
ND
Connor

@et Fox and Peter, not Fox and Percy

[Jamiet99uk]

##Call GM
connorcompton will be modkilled or replaced?
When that will be decided?

It appears unlikely that a replacement will be available.

[et]

If my Flav theory is correct then Fox and Peter are probably cleared so this makes the other 4 scum and SK

Teacon
Percy
Chips
ND
Connor

@et Fox and Peter, not Fox and Percy

Sorry I misread.

[et]

##Call GM
connorcompton will be modkilled or replaced?
When that will be decided?

It appears unlikely that a replacement will be available.

Thank you.
##Vote ND

[Durga]

##Call GM
connorcompton will be modkilled or replaced?
When that will be decided?

It appears unlikely that a replacement will be available.

well if he's town don't modkill him =/