Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[et]

＠xorxes
Do you think Balki as BA? Or Mafia?
Why Balki is very aggressive for you night 2?

[et]

Anyway I want to force connorcompton to post.
##vote connorcompton

Agreed. Connor needs to step up. Not sure he's worth risking lynching though.

Then, please vote!

[Percy Williams]

I'm scumreading both Percy and Xorxes, but Xorxes' top scumread is Percy, so I thought a BA kill on Percy had good value in hitting scum and getting info on Xorxes. I suppose killing Xorxes would accomplish the same type of thing but Xorxes is more valuable as town than Percy, and I have a slightly higher scumread on Percy.

This is a very locigal, towny post from Squigs.

[Percy Williams]

I just saw the Blind Assasin vote thing, Im going to vote for Percy solely because I think its smart to policy lynch xorxes Night 3, not Night 2
Im going to look at the arguments though and I might change

Can you explain what you mean when you say its smart to policy lynch xorxes Night 3?

Because xorxes is really good, and if he isn't killed by Night 3, something is up

If you guys keep saying this, scum won't lynch Xorxes even if he is town, because we will lynch him next phase.

[et]

Can you explain what you mean when you say its smart to policy lynch xorxes Night 3?

Because xorxes is really good, and if he isn't killed by Night 3, something is up

If you guys keep saying this, scum won't lynch Xorxes even if he is town, because we will lynch him next phase.

Do you think Flav is town and xorxes is scum?

[Percy Williams]

Did anyone even vote for TrPrado in Balki's thing? All of the people with powers in this game have hindered us more than helped.

Thankfully Tom posted some detailed reads before his death, and TrPrado has a lot of content to look through, so I will definitely be incorporating those reads into my decision.

For now I stand by my BA vote. One of Percy/Xorxes if not both are very likely scum imo.

##Vote Percy

Wait, why would we both be Scum? Do you think Xorxes would start a buss without any support?

[Percy Williams]

Because xorxes is really good, and if he isn't killed by Night 3, something is up

If you guys keep saying this, scum won't lynch Xorxes even if he is town, because we will lynch him next phase.

Do you think Flav is town and xorxes is scum?

Based on the way Flavius has played past games, I do think Flavius is Town. I am less sure on Xorxes, but he does seem kind of Scummy to me. I don't want to repeat the Xorxes V Teacon battle of the last game, it happened almost the same time, a lynch or to from mislynch lose.

[damo666]

I've just done a reread of TrPrado D2 N2 and cannot find any obvious hint of a N1 scan result.

If it was inno the most likely is Squigs because of his shift of stance.

If it was guilty then either Fox, Teacon or Flav.


Of these I'm guessing Squigs inno as most likely.

The following group should lead town Squigs/Neph/rdr/Durga.

[Percy Williams]

I'm really concerned about how to consolidate towns vote when the numbers are like that. Now if I trusted the judge, I would say great, but I don't, and I don't think the judge should use their power today. We definitely need a town leader though. Maybe the innocent child should reveal? I don't know. I'm getting a bit nervous and I don't have time to play this day probably. I won't even be around end of day.

Innocent child should never reveal unless it looks like their about to die, them revealing would be an automatic NK
Also, them revealing means absolutely nothing, because people would still disagree with them

At least there would be a confirmed town to follow. But fair.

@judge - before you use your last round of power you HAVE to claim. In fact, maybe just claim now and we can decide which 2 people to put up and you can direct the lynch or something.

I think the Judge shouldn't claim and save his/her power. If they can make it through, they can push back Mylo by selecting two scum for the force vote.

[et]

If you guys keep saying this, scum won't lynch Xorxes even if he is town, because we will lynch him next phase.

Do you think Flav is town and xorxes is scum?

Based on the way Flavius has played past games, I do think Flavius is Town. I am less sure on Xorxes, but he does seem kind of Scummy to me. I don't want to repeat the Xorxes V Teacon battle of the last game, it happened almost the same time, a lynch or to from mislynch lose.

Thanks I don't read past game yet.
Xorxes V Teacon battle was active town v active town battle?

[Foxcastle]

Balki - BA, will either confirm himself with the NK or be NK'd by the real BA.
Rdrivera - un'cc'd Reporter

My towncore is: Durga, et, Nd, Squigs. (And Rdrivera, obviously.)

My townleans are: Damo, Neph (with claims that can be confirmed process). Chippe, for all I think he's actually one of the worst anti-town elements. Percy has been on this list, and I don't see the scum in his play, but enough people are seeing it, I should go back to him.

Null: connor, peterlund/MF.

That leaves: Flavius, Teacon, Xorxes.

I'm not going to reread Chippe or Flavius. I can either enjoy the game enough to play it, or I can pay attention to them, but not both. So digging into them is out of the question. (And I don't believe it would be useful even if I were willing.)

[et]

Latest Reading list

Most towny
Durga
Squigs

Towny
Chippe
Percy I don't think his post is unnatural.

Middle
Flav Towny move at Day2, Weird Lurkers list at Day3.
Xorxes
Fox At home Night1. Many players voted Fox early Day3. Reading Percy as town.

Scummy
ND
damo always agree someone

Null
con
Peter

Hold
Nephthys
Teacon I want to see his reading.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 3.2

Balki Bartokomous (3) - teacon7, peterlund, Nephthys
Foxcastle (2) - FlaviusAetius, ChippeRock
Percy Williams (2) - Squigs44, Durga
FlaviusAetius (1) - damo666
xorxes (1) - Foxcastle
Connorcompton (1) - et

Unvoted: rdrivera2005, ND, xorxes

Balki, Connorcompton and Percy Williams have yet to vote.

Currently BALKI is set to be lynched.

28 hours and 54 minutes remain in Day 3.

[damo666]

Do you think Flav is town and xorxes is scum?

Based on the way Flavius has played past games, I do think Flavius is Town. I am less sure on Xorxes, but he does seem kind of Scummy to me. I don't want to repeat the Xorxes V Teacon battle of the last game, it happened almost the same time, a lynch or to from mislynch lose.

Thanks I don't read past game yet.
Xorxes V Teacon battle was active town v active town battle?

Yes

[ND]

Why is ET voting for someone he nulls? Bizarre.

[damo666]

Why is ET voting for someone he nulls? Bizarre.

He said it was an attempt to get him engage

[et]

Why is ET voting for someone he nulls? Bizarre.

He said it was an attempt to get him engage

Anyway I want to force connorcompton to post.
##vote connorcompton

[et]

Based on the way Flavius has played past games, I do think Flavius is Town. I am less sure on Xorxes, but he does seem kind of Scummy to me. I don't want to repeat the Xorxes V Teacon battle of the last game, it happened almost the same time, a lynch or to from mislynch lose.

Thanks I don't read past game yet.
Xorxes V Teacon battle was active town v active town battle?

Yes

Thanks

[teacon7]

Okay so in catching up on this, I'm not at all sure why my post last night felt so scummy to everyone. I was tired, and wrote it right before passing out, but idk what's so wrong with it. please explain, so it's not just a shade bandwagon, k?

[teacon7]

@peter how caught up are you?