Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Balki Bartokomous]

Why wait till EoN to reveal? If you are telling the truth, they will have to RB you and kill Rdr, so revealing now vs EoN doesn't change mafia's actions.

Well they could do that. They also could kill the player I reveal, RB Rdrivera, and hope you guys lynch me or I kill Town. They have an awful lot of ways to win.

I mean, I don’t know what Scum will do. But I have one tiny piece of information, and I’d frankly like to live.

You think they would kill judge/inno over BA? I don't think they would.

Okay new question:
When you scanned this person, were you townreading at that time, or did you townread them after the fact? It doesn't make sense to scan someone you townread, it makes much more sense to scan the person you are scumreading most, and I trust you would make optimal plays as BA. So how did you go from most scumread to pretty sure they are town if this is the case?

Your claims just don't add up to me.

I’m not going to answer those questions because they may give it away.

[Squigs44]

Argh, I can't get a good read on Flav either. He is either mafia or just that one town guy that gets pushed all game long and gets mislynched in mylo.

[Squigs44]

Yeah sorry I can't be helpful this phase then. Good luck I'll check in frequently but it'll be busy for me from now on.

##vote Balki

Lynching me would be an appropriate way for this game to end.

My win condition is less than one percent. Thinking I should pander to you here is pretty darn entitled.

Lynching you doesn't end the game.

[Squigs44]

Well they could do that. They also could kill the player I reveal, RB Rdrivera, and hope you guys lynch me or I kill Town. They have an awful lot of ways to win.

I mean, I don’t know what Scum will do. But I have one tiny piece of information, and I’d frankly like to live.

You think they would kill judge/inno over BA? I don't think they would.

Okay new question:
When you scanned this person, were you townreading at that time, or did you townread them after the fact? It doesn't make sense to scan someone you townread, it makes much more sense to scan the person you are scumreading most, and I trust you would make optimal plays as BA. So how did you go from most scumread to pretty sure they are town if this is the case?

Your claims just don't add up to me.

I’m not going to answer those questions because they may give it away.

Do you see what I am saying though? Every scenario I can think of, your claims and arguments are suboptimal and I find it hard to believe you would play suboptimally. You're playing exactly how I think mafia Balki would play and not at all how BA Balki would play.

[Nephthys]

Hold on,

Its 9-6-1

Lynching Balki gives us either
7/8-5/4-1 OR 8-6
going into tomorrow.

Either way, we are still in it tomorrow.

I personally am happy with either odds from our current position.

I think it most likely that he's mafia which means that we may be doing alright going into tomorrow.

[Squigs44]

Hold on,

Its 9-6-1

Lynching Balki gives us either
7/8-5/4-1 OR 8-6
going into tomorrow.

Either way, we are still in it tomorrow.

I personally am happy with either odds from our current position.

I think it most likely that he's mafia which means that we may be doing alright going into tomorrow.

Yeah Balki is acting like we need him when we really don't.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Oh good, Nephthys is here.

My Night 1 scan was on Nephthys. At that point, I just wanted to scan someone who I thought would stay alive for a long time.

Nephthys is a power role.

But, I’m pretty sure he is Town. When Darg flipped Bailiff, I checked his ISO for clues, as Bailiff knows the identity of the Judge. He’s got a couple of crumbs in there saying, essentially, that he would sheep Neph. I figured that Neph was Judge. Otherwise, I would have shot him last night.

And Squigs, you only need me if you’re Town.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Nephthys, no need to confirm your role. Will you confirm that you are a PR?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Hello?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Nephthys just left. Maybe he is scum.

[Nephthys]

Maybe you're scum

[Squigs44]

Oh good, Nephthys is here.

My Night 1 scan was on Nephthys. At that point, I just wanted to scan someone who I thought would stay alive for a long time.

Nephthys is a power role.

But, I’m pretty sure he is Town. When Darg flipped Bailiff, I checked his ISO for clues, as Bailiff knows the identity of the Judge. He’s got a couple of crumbs in there saying, essentially, that he would sheep Neph. I figured that Neph was Judge. Otherwise, I would have shot him last night.

And Squigs, you only need me if you’re Town.

You can be useful to be town, but you're not necessary.

Time to reread and fact check all this

[Squigs44]

Yeah, scum Balki would have just killed Neph last night for seeing those crumbs. Balki is definitely not worth lynching today.

[Nephthys]

oh he's correct I'm a PR lol

[Squigs44]

Yeah, scum Balki would have just killed Neph last night for seeing those crumbs. Balki is definitely not worth lynching today.

That was written poorly. If balki were scum, and he saw those crumbs, he would have just killed Neph last night.

[Nephthys]

##vote Balki

[Squigs44]

##vote Balki

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

[Nephthys]

##vote Balki

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

I wanna talk to Balki more about his plans tbh

[Squigs44]

##vote Balki

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

I wanna talk to Balki more about his plans tbh

Okay, talk to him, but we aren't lynching him

[Nephthys]

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

I wanna talk to Balki more about his plans tbh

Okay, talk to him, but we aren't lynching him

We have like 36 hours left. Chill