Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

I don't know how you're so fucking dumb but you really are Chippe.

That's it. I'm not gonna explain this game to you any further.

[Durga]

I will GLADLY sacrifice the shitty judge to let rdr live another day. GLADLY

[ChippeRock]

I will GLADLY sacrifice the shitty judge to let rdr live another day. GLADLY

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

[rdrivera2005]

Just took a glorious 4 hour nap. Fwiw, I don't believe Balkis claim and I think he is mafia. But it's really not worth lynching him since the real BA will kill him tonight. I think we have to lynch elsewhere and try to hit mafia.
I'm really confused by Balkis claim that he thinks he scanned a town PR N1. What he has claimed doesn't fit with optimal BA play. BA should scan people they scumread. Also the fact that he thinks he should claim it at EoN doesn't make sense. Why then?

See at least Squigs believes me
Im voting for FoxCastle and I dont care what you say Fox yes you have been reading me or at least pushing me ever since I dared to mention your precious name
##vote Fox
Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

So, you are saying that I am lying. Why aren't you voting me?

[rdrivera2005]

Just took a glorious 4 hour nap. Fwiw, I don't believe Balkis claim and I think he is mafia. But it's really not worth lynching him since the real BA will kill him tonight. I think we have to lynch elsewhere and try to hit mafia.
I'm really confused by Balkis claim that he thinks he scanned a town PR N1. What he has claimed doesn't fit with optimal BA play. BA should scan people they scumread. Also the fact that he thinks he should claim it at EoN doesn't make sense. Why then?

See at least Squigs believes me
Im voting for FoxCastle and I dont care what you say Fox yes you have been reading me or at least pushing me ever since I dared to mention your precious name
##vote Fox
Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

So, you are saying that I am lying. Why aren't you voting me?

Or are you claiming BA? This would make some sense.

[Squigs44]

I will GLADLY sacrifice the shitty judge to let rdr live another day. GLADLY

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

Only if town chooses correctly, which town can do without the help of the judge.
Reporter on the other hand can get us a scan which tells us exactly whether someone took an action or not, aka, whether they are one of the mafia PRs / BA.

[Durga]

I will GLADLY sacrifice the shitty judge to let rdr live another day. GLADLY

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

Ah yeah, just like he got us EP. Classic.

[Durga]

Wait I said I'd stop explaining the game

[Squigs44]

See at least Squigs believes me
Im voting for FoxCastle and I dont care what you say Fox yes you have been reading me or at least pushing me ever since I dared to mention your precious name
##vote Fox
Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

So, you are saying that I am lying. Why aren't you voting me?

Or are you claiming BA? This would make some sense.

Outting BA (if it isnt Balki) so they can RB him is not good. But I see your thinking there.

[FlaviusAetius]

Just took a glorious 4 hour nap. Fwiw, I don't believe Balkis claim and I think he is mafia. But it's really not worth lynching him since the real BA will kill him tonight. I think we have to lynch elsewhere and try to hit mafia.
I'm really confused by Balkis claim that he thinks he scanned a town PR N1. What he has claimed doesn't fit with optimal BA play. BA should scan people they scumread. Also the fact that he thinks he should claim it at EoN doesn't make sense. Why then?

See at least Squigs believes me
Im voting for FoxCastle and I dont care what you say Fox yes you have been reading me or at least pushing me ever since I dared to mention your precious name
##vote Fox
Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

So, you are saying that I am lying. Why aren't you voting me?

It still makes no sense why you did it so early, but I was wrong, because Balki claimed he was BA which makes no sense for a town to do in that situation, cause he could easily be counter claimed

I still think its FoxCastle, but I think I misremembered a lot of things
Carl Tuckerson also was on FoxCastle pretty heavily before he died

[ChippeRock]

I will GLADLY sacrifice the shitty judge to let rdr live another day. GLADLY

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

Only if town chooses correctly, which town can do without the help of the judge.
Reporter on the other hand can get us a scan which tells us exactly whether someone took an action or not, aka, whether they are one of the mafia PRs / BA.

As I stated previously, the judge has a VERY good chance of isolating at least one scum among the two candidates.

[Squigs44]

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

Only if town chooses correctly, which town can do without the help of the judge.
Reporter on the other hand can get us a scan which tells us exactly whether someone took an action or not, aka, whether they are one of the mafia PRs / BA.

As I stated previously, the judge has a VERY good chance of isolating at least one scum among the two candidates.

Yes, I agree with you that judge has a good chance of isolating at least one scum candidate. The doesn't invalidate any of the points I brought up in this post.

[rdrivera2005]

Ok. I will try to read more tomorrow as this is probably my last day. I still think Fox might be scum but he has a lesser chance and if he is scum he is a less important role (as he didn't do nothing N1), so I don't think he is a good lynch today (and that's why I didn't push him much D2).

I will probably vote between Xorxes and Percy, but I don't want to influence much the discussion right now, maybe closer to EOD.

[rdrivera2005]

See at least Squigs believes me
Im voting for FoxCastle and I dont care what you say Fox yes you have been reading me or at least pushing me ever since I dared to mention your precious name
##vote Fox
Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

So, you are saying that I am lying. Why aren't you voting me?

It still makes no sense why you did it so early, but I was wrong, because Balki claimed he was BA which makes no sense for a town to do in that situation, cause he could easily be counter claimed

I still think its FoxCastle, but I think I misremembered a lot of things
Carl Tuckerson also was on FoxCastle pretty heavily before he died

I did it so early because we are losing pretty badly. If we myslinch or lynch the BA is practically game over. I could have tried to push a lynch on Balki, but I don't think it would have worked. Also, Jornalist is weak, Mafia only need one member to get out of home if they want.

[Durga]

Ok. I will try to read more tomorrow as this is probably my last day. I still think Fox might be scum but he has a lesser chance and if he is scum he is a less important role (as he didn't do nothing N1), so I don't think he is a good lynch today (and that's why I didn't push him much D2).

I will probably vote between Xorxes and Percy, but I don't want to influence much the discussion right now, maybe closer to EOD.

I don't think you're playing it right. I think you need to pressure both players.

[Squigs44]

Hey Durga, you may have already answered this but how does the Xorxes RB fit into your read of him?

[Durga]

Hey Durga, you may have already answered this but how does the Xorxes RB fit into your read of him?

I admit it doesn't fit the narrative but I don't see how town xorxes lurks and doesn't contribute anything when we're fucking losing SO hard. It isn't possible.

[ChippeRock]

Hey Durga, you may have already answered this but how does the Xorxes RB fit into your read of him?

I admit it doesn't fit the narrative but I don't see how town xorxes lurks and doesn't contribute anything when we're fucking losing SO hard. It isn't possible.

And you wonder why no one's joining xorxes' wagon when you can't explain a crucial part of xorxes' gameplay...

[Durga]

Hey Durga, you may have already answered this but how does the Xorxes RB fit into your read of him?

I admit it doesn't fit the narrative but I don't see how town xorxes lurks and doesn't contribute anything when we're fucking losing SO hard. It isn't possible.

And you wonder why no one's joining xorxes' wagon when you can't explain a crucial part of xorxes' gameplay...

yes, gee, wish i could figure out how to get dumb, dumb and dumber off fox's wagon

[Durga]

Chippe do you even have scum reads anymore? Isn't ND a scum read? Shouldn't that be setting off major flags for you. Who do you think is the scum team?