Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Foxcastle]

Also guess what FoxCastle I went back and look what I found here; it was me and you who supported the idea of lists why didnt you ever mention this??? Instead youve been reading me because I never went back and just thought it was Squigs, ridiculous AGAIN

Are you kidding me? Like 5 times we told you it wasn't me arguing about the lists. Flav I can't deal with you right now.

Thats not even what Im talking about
FoxCastle said oh why did you say 'we' when I was talking about WE wanted everyone to do lists
I just assumed it was me and you, but nope it was me and foxcastle, but foxcastle never even cared to mention that

I remember the original comment about lists in the first pages, but I have no fucking clue what he's going on about.

[FlaviusAetius]

xorxes deserves pressure, please join me in voting for him

Actually I could get on this wagon, but Im staying on FoxCastle for now, you should join us

No. Fox is a dumb vote.

You know you really like to just say things and not do anything

[ChippeRock]

xorxes deserves pressure, please join me in voting for him

Actually I could get on this wagon, but Im staying on FoxCastle for now, you should join us

No. Fox is a dumb vote.

You're not going to "pressure" xorxes...

[Durga]

Innocent Child!

Get the GMs to reveal your identity if you are any one of the current lynch candidates with votes on them!

No. No PR reveal anything until Balki tells us which player he scanned

[Squigs44]

Innocent Child!

Get the GMs to reveal your identity if you are any one of the current lynch candidates with votes on them!

No. It's too early in the day to reveal. Chippe stop trying to get all the PR's to reveal.

[Durga]

With town like this, who needs scum?

[Foxcastle]

Fox, please join me on xorxes or Squigs on percy

I don't buy either Squigs or Percy, but yeah, ##VOTE XORXES

[Squigs44]

Fox, please join me on xorxes or Squigs on percy

If I were judge I would do a showdown between Xorxes and Percy rn probably.

[ChippeRock]

Innocent Child!

Get the GMs to reveal your identity if you are any one of the current lynch candidates with votes on them!

No. No PR reveal anything until Balki tells us which player he scanned

It doesn't matter what Balki says, if he's Mafia, the real BA will just NK him (this is of course assuming Tom wasn't the BA). If the Innocent Child is one of the top vote-getters, they need to reveal themselves.

[Foxcastle]

With town like this, who needs scum?

+1
+1
+1
+1

[Durga]

Fox, please join me on xorxes or Squigs on percy

If I were judge I would do a showdown between Xorxes and Percy rn probably.

For someone who claims to have read the set up........

[ChippeRock]

Fox, please join me on xorxes or Squigs on percy

If I were judge I would do a showdown between Xorxes and Percy rn probably.

Sucks that he can't use his power in consecutive days...

[ChippeRock]

Innocent Child!

Get the GMs to reveal your identity if you are any one of the current lynch candidates with votes on them!

No. It's too early in the day to reveal. Chippe stop trying to get all the PR's to reveal.

Yes, it's too early obviously. But if there's 12-16 hours left in the phase and they're one of the top vote-getters, that reveal needs to happen!

[Squigs44]

With town like this, who needs scum?

Durga even if someone claimed a guilty on you I'm not sure I could get myself to vote to lynch you and leave myself alone with this town

[Durga]

Innocent Child!

Get the GMs to reveal your identity if you are any one of the current lynch candidates with votes on them!

No. No PR reveal anything until Balki tells us which player he scanned

It doesn't matter what Balki says, if he's Mafia, the real BA will just NK him (this is of course assuming Tom wasn't the BA). If the Innocent Child is one of the top vote-getters, they need to reveal themselves.

I'm trying to be nice but it's really hard for me.

Chippe, we have a way to confirm Balki is BA and not mafia if he correctly identifies a PR. EoD is in two fucking days. We're not hammering anyone. There is no rush for the innocent child to claim anything. Even if they are leading currently. Which btw, is Balki

[Squigs44]

Fox, please join me on xorxes or Squigs on percy

If I were judge I would do a showdown between Xorxes and Percy rn probably.

For someone who claims to have read the set up........

No I know judge can't do his thing on consecutive days, Im just saying thats the matchup I would do today if I could.

[Durga]

With town like this, who needs scum?

Durga even if someone claimed a guilty on you I'm not sure I could get myself to vote to lynch you and leave myself alone with this town

God I wish I was scum in this game

[FlaviusAetius]

This is terrible reasoning. You think it's bad for someone to vote on the lead wagon several hours out? Then what's the point of trying to convince people? Also, I explained my vote, so you shouldn't be totally bereft, but feel free to ask questions if you're unclear.

I think it's bad for people to come ride in after doing nothing all day and vote for someone I think is clearly town based literally only on getting information rooted in a ridiculous theory that was stale 24 hours ago, and not on actually trying to find mafia:

However, that does also mean that if Flavius does flip scum, we can probably narrow down a somewhat narrower pool of players for the next scum. He posted the smart/experienced comment less than an hour after game start, so if the latter theory is true (which it might not be, even if he is scum), the Secretary posted it within the first hour, and then I would bet came to the game thread to say hello.

Actually, Flavius could be a high enough value lynch that it's worth it to see how he flips. If he's scum, I think that puts town even further ahead than if we manage to catch another one.

The fact that you don't have any comment on what the information means if he's town is bogus. How are you going to justify voting to hang someone because they're a "valuable flip" if you have no idea what it means if they flip town?

"Doing nothing all day"? Come on. First of all, it's Day 1, so manage your expectations; and second of all, you can critique my play and my actions all you like, but it's silly to say I've done nothing.

If he's town, we done fucked up. But here's a fun fact: town mislynches on Day 1 a lot, so yeah, I'm just going for what I think is the best chance. If you've got a better, more ironclad case, go ahead and push it.

Interesting. We had one and you never even went for it, but instead kept pushing me. Oh but you definetly werent pushing me Day 1, not at all!
What a joke

[ChippeRock]

No. No PR reveal anything until Balki tells us which player he scanned

It doesn't matter what Balki says, if he's Mafia, the real BA will just NK him (this is of course assuming Tom wasn't the BA). If the Innocent Child is one of the top vote-getters, they need to reveal themselves.

I'm trying to be nice but it's really hard for me.

Chippe, we have a way to confirm Balki is BA and not mafia if he correctly identifies a PR. EoD is in two fucking days. We're not hammering anyone. There is no rush for the innocent child to claim anything. Even if they are leading currently. Which btw, is Balki

Horrible idea to reveal the judge so the judge can get fucking NKed.

[FlaviusAetius]

It doesn't matter what Balki says, if he's Mafia, the real BA will just NK him (this is of course assuming Tom wasn't the BA). If the Innocent Child is one of the top vote-getters, they need to reveal themselves.

I'm trying to be nice but it's really hard for me.

Chippe, we have a way to confirm Balki is BA and not mafia if he correctly identifies a PR. EoD is in two fucking days. We're not hammering anyone. There is no rush for the innocent child to claim anything. Even if they are leading currently. Which btw, is Balki

Horrible idea to reveal the judge so the judge can get fucking NKed.

THANK YOU
She keeps pushing it